Open Access Research Article
ROLE OF HUMAN RIGHTS ON BUSINESS PRACTICE
Published Paper
Article Details
ROLE OF HUMAN RIGHTS ON BUSINESS
PRACTICE
Authored by - AKANSHA YADAV AND
PRIYANSHU SHEKHAR DUBEY
3rd Year(6th
semester)
Amity University Uttar Pradesh
Lucknow Campus
ABSTRACT
Human rights are basic liberties that
must be accorded to each person equally and fairly. This is a result of the
legal underpinnings of human rights, which are rights that are acquired solely
by virtue of being a person. We recognise that businesses have a significant
influence on how we live and how we enjoy our human rights, whether we are
company owners, workers, customers, or simply ordinary members of society.
Therefore, it must be expected of businesses to uphold these liberties. As the
first global standard "for preventing and addressing the risk of adverse
impacts on human rights linked to business activity," the UN Guiding
Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs) were established in 2011. This
provided a globally recognised structure and raised internal standards for
human rights protection and compliance. As a result, the importance of civil
rights has increased and expanded, now also encompassing corporate law
companies. In fact, 77% of respondents to a survey by the Business and Human
Rights Resource Centre agreed that "law firms should have a policy
commitment to human rights and human rights due diligence processes in
place" because they are "business enterprises with a responsibility
to respect human rights."
Businesses that successfully uphold
and enforce human rights naturally increase their brand recognition and
contribute to the general welfare of society. Companies are encouraged to
implement policies and take an approach that integrates human rights
responsibilities into their daily operations by such business benefits. While
some businesses may view the protection of human rights as a "box-ticking
exercise," more are beginning to take it seriously because any violations
could severely harm their interests in terms of money and reputation.
Additionally, businesses all over the world are being held more and more
responsible for how they treat people with respect in their everyday
operations, supply chains, and business dealings. Globally, the body of
national laws and standards is expanding, ensuring that businesses are
constantly reminded of their responsibilities and urged to adopt beneficial
laws to protect human rights. However, as the private sector comes under more
scrutiny and pressure, it also takes steps to safeguard the rights of people
who are involved in how their businesses operate.
"Human rights issues" –
what are they?
The term "human rights
issues" is used to refer to a broad variety of effects that a business,
its contractors, its suppliers, or other organisation may have. on individuals
and their civil rights. However, they are not confined to:
— Negligence in health and safety,
environmental mishaps, and pollution damage to people's health.
— The use of coerced labor, child
labor, or worker underpayment
— The establishment of hazardous or
unhealthy working circumstances
— The displacement of communities,
including indigenous groups, either forcibly or involuntarily
— excessive force by security
personnel guarding valuables
— Discrimination against workers
based on their ethnicity, gender, or sexual orientation
— The depletion or contamination of
water sources used by nearby towns.
Why take steps to address issues
related to human rights?
Why do businesses take action to
resolve human rights issues? Four key drivers were recognised by interviewees;
they are listed here in the order of frequency of mention.
1. Regulations and standards
Regulatory pressure
A major force encouraging businesses
to handle issues of human rights and disclose their operations is increased
regulation. For instance, the UK Modern Slavery Act (2015) mandates that
businesses with a turnover of £36 million or more and operations in the UK
disclose the steps they take to prevent slavery and human trafficking in their
operations and supply networks.
Pressure to conform to international
guidelines and standards
Another potent driver of change is
the proliferation of international norms and standards, such as the GRI sustainability
reporting standards and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights
(UNGPs). Even though there is generally no legal requirement for them to react,
the companies interviewed do not want to be seen as falling short of
internationally agreed upon expectations.
2. Reputation and relationships
Customers
Customers' expectations of their
vendors' compliance with human rights policies and show how they are
effectively addressing issues related to human rights. Good human rights
performance is viewed as a chance to obtain competitive advantage and fortify
ties with important stakeholders.
Media and NGOs
An important motivator is the
increased scrutiny from NGOs, activists, and the media, especially for
consumer-facing businesses that are undoubtedly most vulnerable to brand
erosion and market share loss. However, business-to-business firms also noted
that unfavourable publicity could harm vital connections with locals and
employees.
Labor unions
Labor and trade unions are paying
more attention to labour rights in particular and to problems relating to human
rights in general.
Media and NGOs
An important motivator is the
increased scrutiny from NGOs, activists, and the media, especially for
consumer-facing businesses that are undoubtedly most vulnerable to brand
erosion and market share loss. However, business-to-business firms also noted
that unfavourable publicity could harm vital connections with locals and
employees.
Employees
The negative publicity surrounding
human rights issues, according to several interviewees, would severely harm the
company's relationship with current workers and dissuade prospective new hires
from applying.
Suppliers
Working with suppliers on human
rights problems can be a chance to get to know them better. Some businesses
claim long-term advantages from assisting their suppliers with labour standards
and workplace improvements, such as better collaboration on invention and
communication. Human rights approval standards that are more stringent can also
be a motivator.
3. Investor and lender scrutiny
Increasing investor and lender
monitoring of human rights performance is a key justification for taking
action. One business admitted it had suffered significant losses. owing to
claims that there was child labour throughout the supply chain. On this
subject, long-term owners like pension funds are regarded as being the most
activist.
4. Company purpose
Many businesses asserted that
addressing problems related to human rights is simply the right thing to do. Failure
to do so would be inconsistent with the mission, ethos, and values of the
organisation.
What do human rights have to do with
business?
People can be impacted by businesses
both positively and negatively. Of course, a business can make a good difference.
human rights of others, such as by giving workers respectable jobs, giving
customers worthwhile services, or funding neighbourhood initiatives. However,
you could also have a negative effect on people's human rights, for example, by
fostering an unsafe work environment, contaminating the water that nearby
communities consume, or offering a dangerous product for sale. When we talk
about "business and human rights," we actually mean how businesses
handle any possible negative effects on individuals. Of course, businesses can
have a long-lasting, significant positive influence by managing these potential
negative effects.
This means that while charitable work
is pleasant to do, managing negative effects on people through business is a
must-do. For example, concentrating Managing the well-being of your employees
and making sure that your existence does not harm the community where you
operate are must-dos, while choosing to make a charitable donation or support a
nearby orphanage is a nice-to-do. Human rights are fundamental liberties and
rights that everyone is entitled to. They are founded on principles like
independence, justice, equality, dignity, and respect. The government may
occasionally place restrictions on them, but it will never take them away. International
human rights instruments include a list of the different types of human rights
businesses. These include the International Covenant on Civil and Political
Rights, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and others. Rights, the ILO
Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, and the International
Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights. Here, we give some
illustrations of human rights.
I already follow the rules, and I've
asked my business partners to try the same thing; what makes this different?
You might already be managing some of
your human rights threats by adhering to the law. laws regulating the legal
drinking limit, banning Companies can reduce their human rights risks by
discriminating against employees and controlling how garbage is disposed of. At
the same time, we are aware that following the law is not always simple. For
instance, adhering to health and safety regulations may be especially difficult
given the dominant culture in a particular operating context. Or it might be
difficult to safeguard communities during a large-scale project due to corrupt
business practises in the area. Therefore, we cannot assume that our business
partners or even our own firm always abides by laws pertaining to human rights.
We also understand that, despite the
fact that governments that ratify and execute treaties are required to do so in
order to participate in international organizations, Not all governments have
been able to uphold the norms they agreed to during the international
treaty-making process. For instance, some States have enacted national rules
that offer less protection for human rights than do international standards.
National laws that have been enacted by some States go against these norms.
Take into account, for instance, laws that sanction discrimination based on
sexual orientation, gender, or religion; that sanction dangerous child labour;
or that limit the freedom of assembly. Because of this, even though your
business will aim to adhere to local laws, you should also be conscious that
Compliance with the law alone is inadequate. Depending on the specifics and
pressing problems affecting your company, merely adhering to the law may not
allow you to say with assurance that your company and value chain respect
people's human rights.
What benefits can human rights
effects be addressed of? to the company?
Over the years, businesses have
shared with us that they have experienced a variety of benefits from having
policies and procedures in place to enable respect for civil rights. The
advantages you experience as a result of this work depend on a variety of
different factors, such as how you develop your products, operations, and
services; how your business is financed; the types of workers who are involved
in your operations and value chain; and the degree to which you rely on land,
water, and other natural resources. Human rights considerations assist
organisations with a strong culture in upholding their ideals. Paying attention
to human rights enables businesses that want to be resilient and foresee
regulatory requirements to be better prepared for the future. Paying attention
to human rights can assist businesses as climate change disrupts activities
more and more. Consider potential disruptions and make plans appropriately.
Businesses that employ a manual workforce often speak of increased productivity
that is connected to improved employee wellbeing and happiness. Businesses that
are located close to communities or that depend on resources (like water, land,
or timber) that are also used by those communities report having better
relationships with those communities. Companies seeking reputable investors
report having simpler access to funding and investment. Companies reporting an
increased chance of joining an international supply chain include those looking
for foreign clients. Additionally, there are more cases being filed against
businesses for allegedly violating human rights norms. even though your
business Even though the company itself may not be sued, one of your business
partners may be for effects on your operations. The law in this field is
changing quickly.
Examples of how
business might affect internationally recognised human rights
|
Applicable fundamental right
|
Detailed description of the right
|
Examples of business activities
that could have an effect on the right
|
|
Right of self-determination.
|
-
A peoples' privilege rather than a personal one.
-
People have the right to choose their own political standing and position
in the world.
-
It involves the freedom to pursue one's own economic, social, and
cultural development, to use the natural resources of one's land, and to not
have one's means of subsistence taken away from one.
-
Indigenous peoples have a unique right to self-determination, which has
been explicitly recognised by the international community.
|
-
Engaging in commercial activity on property that has cultural
significance to the local populace but was acquired by the government without
proper local community input.
-
Any action that could affect the lands of indigenous peoples, whether
through acquisition, building, or operation, could have an effect on their
right to self-determination.
|
|
Right to life
|
|
·
The lethal use of force by
security forces (State or private) to protect company resources, facilities
or personnel.
·
Operations that pose life-threatening
safety risks to workers or neighbouring communities through,for example,
exposure to toxic chemicals.
·
The manufacture and sale of
products with lethal flaws.
|
|
Right not to be subjected to torture,
cruel, inhuman and/or degrading treatment or punishment.
|
-
An unqualified privilege that
holds true in all situations.
-
According to some definitions,
torture entails extremely severe pain or suffering that is purposefully
administered.
-
Treatment that is cruel or
inhumane also results in terrible pain.
-
According to some definitions,
degrading treatment involves severely humiliating the sufferer.
|
-Operating
a business in a nation where the police or state security forces responsible
for safeguarding the assets of the company do not uphold this right.
-The
failure to promote an environment free from severe forms of harassment that
result in significant mental anguish.
-Making and
selling machinery that has been improperly used by others for torture, cruel
treatment, or without their permission, medical or scientific
experimentation.
|
|
Right not to be subjected to slavery,
servitude or forced labour
|
When one person essentially owns
another, that is slavery.
Other severe forms of economic
exploitation or degradation, such as the trafficking of employees or
financial bondage, are covered by the right to be free from servitude.
Absolute rights include the
liberation from slavery and servitude.
The ILO defines forced or
compulsory labour as any work or service that is demanded of a person against
their will and for which they have not freely offered themselves.
Even if payment is made, labour is
still considered forced labour if the other criteria are satisfied.
|
Businesses may unwittingly profit
from the labour of workers who have been trafficked and are forced to work as
slaves, for instance on agricultural plantations, through their supply
chains.In such circumstances, women and children may experience especially
negative effects.
A business may be engaged in the
transportation of persons or goods that aids in human trafficking.
Any industry in which an employer
places workers in a state of debt bondage through the payment of fees to
secure employment or business loans, or in which an employer withholds
workers' identity documents, is susceptible to forced labour. As a recognised
vulnerable group, migrant labourers are particularly at risk in this
situation.
|
|
Right not to be subjected to
imprisonment for inability to fulfil a contract
|
When a person is unable to fulfil a
private contractual obligation, they are entitled to this privilege.
It limits the kinds of penalties
the state may apply.
|
When a small local supplier is
truly unable to fulfil their contractual duties and the company takes action
against them, for example, there may be a connection between companies and
such an effect even though this right is not protected by the State.
|
|
Right to recognition as a person
before the law
|
Legal personality, or autonomous
legal recognition, is a right for everyone.
|
Companies may be responsible for
such an effect, for instance, if they gain from a State-led land acquisition
process that compensates only male household heads because married women's
property is regarded as their spouses' property under domestic law.
|
|
Right to work
|
People have a right to the ability
to support themselves through employment that they voluntarily choose or
embrace. The job must respect their human rights and be considered
"decent work."
The right includes the ability to
form and join a union, the right to just and advantageous working
circumstances, and the prohibition of arbitrary dismissal, all of which are
covered below.
|
Even if permitted by state law,
firing a worker arbitrarily or unfairly.
preventing or failing to fulfil
workers' legitimate aspirations for job advancement.
|
Impact and Implications
Despite the complexity of the problem,
an increasing number of groups keep moving the agenda forward. More and more
international organisations are creating human rights policies that outline
both their dedication to upholding human rights and how this commitment will be
carried out in reality. Initiatives involving collaboration between businesses
and government agencies are also progressing. The Human Rights and Labour
Working Group (HRLWG), a group of experts made up of members from business,
civil society, and UN agencies, is an appropriate example. The HRLWG was
established to offer direction and support on the implementation of the human
rights and labour principles of the UN Global Compact. The Global Business
Initiative on Human Rights, a non-profit organisation led by a core group of 18
corporations from various industries, stands out among other business-driven
initiatives as being particularly intriguing. Its goal is to advance human
rights in a business context through cross-industry peer learning, outreach and
capacity building, and by influencing policy.
CONCLUSION
In accordance with international
human rights legislation, states are required to take measures to prevent third
parties, including commercial enterprises, from violating human rights on their
soil and/or under their jurisdiction. All business enterprises are expected to
respect human rights, which means they should refrain from violating the rights
of others and should resolve any negative effects on those rights that they may
be responsible for, even if States do not uphold their obligations to do so.
Victims of maltreatment must have access to efficient redress through legal and
extralegal grievance procedures if they are wronged.
As a result, the relationship between
corporate law firms, governments, and businesses is very essential. Businesses
and the legal firms that counsel them must incorporate international law and
norms supporting human rights into their domestic policies. For corporate and
business law companies, the significance of human rights has legal and ethical
ramifications.
Article Information
ROLE OF HUMAN RIGHTS ON BUSINESS PRACTICE
Authors: AKANSHA YADAV, PRIYANSHU SHEKHAR DUBEY
- Journal IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Published 2023/04/06
- Volume 2
- Issue 7
About Journal
International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis
- Abbreviation IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Access Open Access
- License CC 4.0
All research articles published in International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis are open access and available to read, download and share, subject to proper citation of the original work.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis.