DATA BREACH BY: MS. LAIBA KHAN & PROF DR. JAY PRAKASH YADAV
DATA BREACH
AUTHORED BY: MS. LAIBA KHAN & PROF DR. JAY PRAKASH YADAV,
Amity Law School
ABSTRACT
The rapid growth in
advancement of science and technology have compelled legislature of every
country to enact strict laws . In recent years the cases of data protection has
been increased. Right to privacy includes right to protect one’s data also
.Though many legislations are there which talks about data protection for
instance Article 19,21 of Indian constitution, Indian Penal Code, Information Technology
Act, still data protection has become a big concern for the individuals as well
as the lawmakers .The purpose of this research paper is to study the existing laws
relating to data protection and under standing the concept of data protection .For
writing this research paper I have used many statutes including Indian
constitution, IPC, RTI, And IT Act.
Key Words; Data Protection, Indian
Constitution, Information Technology Act, Indian Penal Code.
ThisdescriptivestudyusesDoctrinalMethodtoobtaintheneededdata.Adoctrinalresearch
study is one that has been conducted on a legal theory by means of applying
reasoning capability to the analysis of current statutory provisions and cases.
Doctrinal refers toa fundamental tenent or principal . This implies that the
legal universe would be governed by legal tenents found in legal philosophy. In
order to evaluate them and get to a reliable conclusion, it follows that
doctrinal legal study would entail delving deeper into the legal principals and
notions from a variety of sources , including cases, precedents, statutes. Most
often the starting point in any research is doctrinal that is library based and
then we move forward to other methodologies.
INTRODUCTION
The
concept of Data Protection[1] is
not a new concept . Government of India recently envisaged
theideaofDigitalIndia,butitisabigchallengetoprotectpersonaldataofpeopleinsuchlarge
populatedcountry. The judiciary has recognizedthe RighttoPrivacy as
anInstinctrightimplicit inArticle21of
IndianConstitution.AutoShankarCaseandPuttaswamyareoneofthecasesin which Hon’ble
Supreme Court has recognized the Right To Privacy as Fundamental right. Right
to Privacy is co extensively related with Data Protection. In present time we
are depend on online apps from buying clothes to ordering food, groceries and
medicines . The life have becomes easier due tointroduction of technology but
it can become a danger tous as number ofpeoplearevictimofbreachofdataprotection.A
renownedpizzacompanynamedDomino’s is the victimof a massive databreachthat
exposedorder details of 18crore people , whichis a huge number . The strange
thing is that big companies like Facebook, Air India , Unacademy could not
handle people’s data safely. The largest data breach according to World
Economic Forum’s Global Risk Report is Aadhaar leak case² , which exposed the
data of nearly 1.1 billion Indian People.
India
has witnessed significant shifts in ranking in respect of data breach over the
past few years. According to a report by
Surfshark[2] in2022,Indiarankedas7thonthelistofcountries
with most breached data. However , in 2023, India reached to 5th
position, with 5.3 million leaked accounts.
In Q1 2023, Europe was the sole region which
witnessed significant quarter over quarter growth, with an increasing number of
breaches from 9.9millionto17.5million. Asia is the second most affected region
, which results in 10.6 million breaches.
Globally[3] around 299.8 million accounts
breachedin2023.The United States ranked1st with almost 100 million
breach accounts, marking rapid growth from the previous year. Russia followed by
second place , while France, Spain, and India secured their position at 5th
.
Privacy
and Data protection are not defined any where but the scope of these terms have
been
coveredundermanyIndianlegislations.Thelawsrelatingtotheprivacyanddataprotectionare
as follows;
1.ConstitutionOfIndia;
According to Article 21 of Indian Constitution, ‘’ No person
shall be deprived of his life or
personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. ‘’The Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India recognized right to privacy as fundamental right in the
year 2017 in Puttoswamy case.
In the case of M.P. Sharma v. Satish
Chandra, SC observed that though the recertain exceptions to right to privacy but
conducting search and seizure by police at midnight is a violation right to
privacy enshrined under Article 21 of the constitution.
Kharak Singh v. State of U.P.? , it was
concluded by SC that expression life is not only restricted
tobodilyrestraintbutsomethingmorethanmereanimalexistence.Inthiscasethepetitioner
named kharak singh was framed with the offence of dacoity , but was acquittedas
there were not sufficient evidence against him. U. P. Police started conducting
police surveillance against the accused in order to keep an eye upon him. SC
held that domiciliary visits of police officers upon the house of petitioner
were an invasion on his personal liberty .
From
time to time SC emphasized that right to live is not confined to physical
existence but it includes within its ambit
the right to live with human dignity and it covers all the aspects data protection
is one of them .As right to privacy is a
fundamental right, the victim of breach of privacy or data privacy have the
option to move to SCor High court under article 32 and 226 respectively.
InformationTechnologyAct,2000?;Thisactspecificallycoverscybercrimes,
frauds.It’s provisions covers the cyber crime which is linked with privacy and
data protection . The most important provisions relating to cyber frauds are as
follows;
a] Section66;Thissectiontalksabouthacking,whichisunauthorizedaccesstosomeone’s
Fine
which may extend to 5 lacks or with both.
Section66E;This section provides that any
person who intentionally captures the pictures of a person and transmits or
publishes the image of such person without his consent is an offence under this
provision , for which the imprisonment provide is 3 years or fine up to rs. 2
lacks or both.
Section 67A; It relates to the offence
of publishing or transmitting any material consist of sexuality through
electronic means, which objectionable and shall be punishable with an
imprisonment which may extend to five years and a fine which may extend to rupees
ten lacks , and upon the second conviction, the imprisonment may extend to seven
years and a fine which may extend to rupees ten lacks.
Copyright Act 1857; This act was enacted to protect the intellectual
rights of a true owner. Theactmainlypreservetheliterary,dramatic,musical,andartisticworksoftheauthorduring
his life time and sixty years after his death . If any person copies the work
of the author for some commercial purposes without his consent is liable to be
prosecuted under this act.
K.S.
Puttoswamy v/s Union Of India?
This
case is popularly known as Adhaar case, a nine constitutional judge bench of SC
of India in the year 2017 declared right to privacy a fundamental right under
article 21 which right to life and personal liberty . Right to privacy includes
protection of data, the leakage of someone’s data or accessing any electronic
items without his permission is violation of right to privacy.
Justice Sri Krishna Committee?;The
cases are rising day by day , so the government of India through it’s Ministry of
Electronics and Information Technology, appointed a committee of ten members
under the leadership of SC retired judge , justice B.R. Krishna to provide a
detailed report on the passing of new data privacy laws to curb cyber crimes.
Digital Personal Data Protection Act , 2023 is the result of this committee.[5]
1. Cyber Attack on AIIMS?; The government owned hospital named AIIMS experienced cyber
attack resulting in the encryption of around 1.3 terabytes of data across five
servers. This was not the first time when AIIMS became the victimof cyber
attack , only after six months second cyber attack on AIIMS took place. Cyber
attack caused chaos, delay in services at AIIMS, adversely affected the patient
care services at the hospital. With the
server being down, the OPD and sample collection were handled manually but the
sample system for those who do not have a Unique Health Identification was affected.
2.
Air IndiaDataBreach¹?; In February 2021, Air India data breach occurred which
resulted in disclosing 4.5 million Air India customer’s personal information.
The breached comprised of personal data which includes name, date of birth,
contact number, passport information.
3.
Aadhaar Data Leak case; A U.S. based cyber security firm
has claimed that personal
informationofapproximately18.5cr.Peopleleakedincludingaadhaarnumber,address and
passport details, were being sold on dark web. This was the massive data breach
as 99 percent Indians aged 18 and above
have registered for Aadhaar card. Eventually UIDAI assures that the aadhaar
data including biometric information is fully safe.
4. Rail Yatri Data Breach; Indian railways became
the topic of news after an incident of data breach at Rail yatri , the
e-booking services website . More than 30 million users were affected which
booked online tickets , their data was sold in dark web . Rail yatri had
previously faced similar breach in 2020 disturbing 700, 000 users.
5. Bharat Pay Hacked¹¹; In present time online money transaction apps have a necessity
,there
are number of digital financial services apps such as google pay, paytm, Bharat
pay is one of them which experienced massive data breach resulting in
disclosure of around 37,000 users. The leaked information includes user names,
password, UPI ID, mobile numbers and email ids .
In
present scenario the people are compelled to provide information in every
sphere from taking admission in an educational institutions to ordering items
from digital apps, in such a situation there is always threat to personal details
of the people .Privacy¹²isasimportantasthe
oxygenforthehumanbeing.Dataprotectionhasbecomeabigissueineverycountryandwith
the passing of time this can become worse. It has become normal to see cyber
fraud cases in news everyday. With the increasing number of sharing information
on online platforms , it is essential to protect the data from being misused.
It is the duty of government to implement
Strict
laws to resolve the issue of cyber data breach¹³ and to protect privacy of it’s
citizens.
SUGGESTIONS
1.
Though
there are many legislations covering data protection ,still the government of
India failed to secure personal information of the people , the examples of
this are AIIMS, Rail yatri, Cowin data breach cases , these are the
institutions regulated by government. There is a need to enact new laws to tackle
the problems of data breach.
2. The government must take attractive initiatives
to aware the people regarding data
protection in the form of advertisement on television , internet, picture
depiction.
3. Low literacy rate of India is also a
reason for the significant data breach incidents. The innocent people click on the
unknown links without applying their mind and suffer a lot, so the government
is responsible to spread education and awareness relating to such issues in a easier
manner .
4.
There
is need of enhancing the punishment in for imprisonment and heavy amount of
fine, even death penalty should be an option in severe cases.¹[7]
1.
The
constitution of India
2.
Indian
Penal Code
3.
InformationTechnologyAct,2000
4.
CopyrightAct1857
5.
https;//indianexpress.com
7.
https;//bwsecurityworld.businessworld.in
8.
https;//blog.ipleders.in
10. https;//thecyberexpress.com
12. IndianJournalofIntegratedResearchinLaw;ISSN,2583-0538
13. International Journal Of Law Management And Humanities, ISSN 2581-
5369,VOLUME 4, ISSUE 5 .
[1]https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/tech-news-technology/dominos-data-breach-name-address-other-details-of-over-18-crore-orders-leaked-7328416/lite/
4https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/technology/how-the-personal-data-of-815-million-indians-got-breached-explained/article67505760.ece
? https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/tech-news-technology/indias-data-breach-cases-fall-by-75-in-2023-surfshark-8616094/