ANALYSIS OF BHARTIYA NYAYA SANHITA BY - HARSH S. BHAGAT
ANALYSIS OF BHARTIYA NYAYA
SANHITA
AUTHORED BY - HARSH S. BHAGAT,
B.BA. LL.B., Anand Law College,
Anand, Gujarat
Abstract: -
Bhartiya Nyaya
Sanhita, 2023, represents a significant reform in Indian criminal regulation, reflecting a concerted effort to modernize
the felony framework by means of casting off
colonial legacies and aligning with current values. Enacted by the
Indian Parliament in 2023, this new Sanhita introduces a variety of reforms aimed toward improving
justice and performance inside the crook justice gadget.
This research article
examines the key adjustments delivered by using the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita, which include the redefinition of crook offenses,
procedural innovations, and adjustments in sentencing practices.
Introduction: -
The First Law Commission, led by Lord Thomas Babington
Macaulay, drafted the Indian Penal
Code in 1834, and it was presented to the Governor-General of India
Council in 1835. It is divided into 23 chapters
and 511 sections, each of which addresses a different area of criminal
law. A more contemporary version of the Indian Penal Code is being
suggested, called the Bhartiya Nyaya
Sanhita (BNS). Its goal is to modernize and revise India's criminal laws so they are more appropriate for the
country's modern society. The BNS aims to bring the penal laws into compliance with the demands
of the modern judicial system
by addressing a number of shortcomings and out-of-date provisions of the IPC. On August
11, 2023, the Bhartiya Nyaya
Sanhita (BNS) was established to replace the IPC. The Standing Committee
on Home Affairs looked into it.
Following the withdrawal of the previous Bill, the Bhartiya Nyaya (Second) Sanhita,
2023 (BNS2) was introduced on December 12, 2023. It includes some of the Standing Committee's recommendations. The BNS2
basically keeps the IPC's provisions in place while adding some new offenses, eliminating others that have been
declared unconstitutional by courts,
and stiffening the penalties for a number of existing ones. Lastly, there are
20 chapters and 358 sections in BNS.
Abbreviations: -
1. IPC- Indian Penal Code
2. BNS- Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita
New Chapter
Added: -
1. CHAPTER IV OF ABETMENT, CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY AND
ATTEMPT
2. CHAPTER V OFFENCES AGAINST WOMAN AND CHILDREN 3.
CHAPTER X OF OFFENCES
RELATING TO COIN, CURRENCY NOTES,
BANK NOTES, AND GOVERNMENT STAMPS
Deleted Offences:
-
1. Sedition
(Section 124A)
2. Punishment
for knowingly carrying arms in any procession or organizing, or holding or
taking part in any mass drill or mass training with arms. (Section 153AA).
3. Abetting in
India the counterfeiting out of India of coin (Section236).
4. Offences
relating to weights and measures (CHAPTER XIII)
5. Attempt to
commit suicide (Section 309)
6. Thug
(Section 310)
7. Unnatural
offences (Section 377)
8. Adultery
(Section 497)
New Offences
added: -
1. Terroirst
act (BNS Section 111)
2. Organised
Crime (BNS Section 109)
3. Petty
Organized Crime (BNS Section 110)
4. Mob
lynching (BNS Section 301(2))
5. Hit and Run
(BNS Section 106(2))
6. Hiring,
employing or engaging a child to commit an offence (BNS Section 95) 7. Act
endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity of India (BNS Section 152A)
8.Snatching (BNS Section 302)
A. Definitions: -
1.
Child
(2(3)- BNS
The section
2(3) of BNS defines child any person below the age of 18 years it is new
provision before this in IPC there is no specifically definition of child.
2.
Documet
2(3) BNS/ Section 20 IPC
The section
2(3) of BNS defines document as any matter expressed or described upon any
substance by means of letters, figures or marks, or by more than one of those
means, and includes electronic and digital record, intended to be used, or
which may be used, as evidence of that matter, in short it now includes the
electronic and digital records before this in IPC it not includes the
electronic and digital records.
3.
Gender
2(10)-BNS/ Section 8 IPC
The section
2(10) of BNS defines gender and it includes the transgender.
4.
Movable
Property 2(21)-BNS/ Section 22 IPC
The section
2(10) of BNS defines Movable Property as it includes property of every
description, except land and things attached to the earth or permanently
fastened to anything which is attached to the earth. It now includes tangible
and intangible property except immovable property before this in IPC intangible
property like actionable claims, patents, trademarks, copyrights etc. is not
included
5.
Month and
Calendar 2(20)-BNS / Section 49 IPC
The section
2(20) of BNS defines Month and Calendar, reference of British calendar is
replaced by Georgian calendar in BNS
6.
Public
Servant 2(28)-BNS/ Section 21 IPC
The section
2(28) of BNS define public servant, mostly the section is similar to IPC,
except these two changes: -
2(28)(d)
every assessor or member of a panchayat assisting a Court or public servant,
here it omits the word juryman which is found in IPC 2(28)(k) in the service or
pay of a local authority as defined in clause (31) of section 3 of the General
Clauses Act, 1897, a corporation established by or under a Central or State Act
or a Government company as defined in clause (45) of section 2 of the Companies
Act, 2013. While in IPC in the service or pay of a local authority, a
corporation established by or under a Central, Provincial or State Act or a
Government company as defined in section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of
1956).]
B. Expressions: -
1.
"Denotes" word replace by "Means"
word (e.g., judge in section 2(15))
2.
Contemporary style of drafting
3.
Archaic expressions like 'lunatic', 'insane' and
'idiot' have been done away with.
4.
Colonial remnants like 'British calendar', 'Queen',
'British India, 'justice of the peace' has been deleted.
5.
In 44 places 'Court of Justice' has been replaced with
'Court'
C. Punishments: -
1.
Community
Service [Chapter 2, Section 4 of BNS / Section 53 of IPC]
In section
53 of IPC, it only describes about 5 types of punishments viz. (1) Death;(2)
Imprisonment for life; (3) Imprisonment which is of two descriptions– rigorous
and simple;
(4)
Forfeiture of property and (5) Fine. In this particular section, a new
punishment called "community service" is introduced by BNS 4(f).
However, the term itself is not defined here. Instead, the explanation provided
under Section 23 of the BNSS,2023 clarifies its meaning: "Community
service" means work ordered by the court as a form of punishment that
benefits the community. The convict will not be entitled to any remuneration
for this work.
Following
sections includes community service as punishment: -
Section 202 - Public
Servant unlawfully engaging in trade.
Section 209 - Under Section 84 of BNSS, failure to appear upon proclamation.
Section 226 - Attempt to
commit suicide or to compel or restrain
the exercise of lawful power.
Section 303(2)
- For theft, the offender may face imprisonment of either type for up to three years,
a fine, or both. In the case of a repeat offense,
the punishment includes
rigorous imprisonment for at least one year, extending up to five years,
and a fine. If the value of the stolen property
is under five thousand rupees and it is the offender's first conviction, they may receive
community service upon returning the stolen property or compensating its value.
Section 355 - Misconduct by a drunken person in a public place.
Section 356 - Defamation.
D. Chapter VI: Crimes impacting the human body: -
1.
Penalties
for Homicide (New Crime: Mob Lynching) under BNS Section 103(2):
BNS creates a
new category of crimes that explicitly targets mob lynching. It imposes severe penalties for murders
committed by groups
of five or more people based on race, caste,
religion, gender,
birthplace, language, personal beliefs, or any other similar criteria. The
following is how the law is written:
According to Section
103(2), if a group of five or more people conspire to commit a homicide on the basis of
race, caste, religion, gender, place of birth, language, personal beliefs, or any other similar grounds, each member of
that group shall be subject to the
most severe legal penalties, including the possibility of life imprisonment or
the death penalty, in addition to financial penalties.
2.
Terrorist
Acts (New Crime: Section 113 BNS):
A new crime connected
to terrorism is defined
in Section 113 of the BNS. This section focuses
on actions taken with the intention of putting a threat to the unity,
integrity, sovereignty, security, or
economic stability of India or any other nation, or of provoking fear in the population. such acts include: 1. Making
Use of Dangerous Substances: Using explosives,
firearms, toxic gases, or other potentially hazardous materials to: Inflict harm or death, Cause property damage or destruction, Interrupt essential services
or supplies, Use counterfeit currency to undermine India's
economic stability, Destroy
or damage property
used for defence
or government purposes. 2.Unlawful Force: Using force against public
officials or attempting to kill them
illegally.3. Kidnapping or hijacking: holding people hostage or kidnapping them with threats of harm to compel governments or international organizations to take action.
Terrorist acts come with consequences:
Terrorism-related offenses
carry severe penalties
that vary depending
on the severity of the crime:
·
Resulting
in Death: If a person dies as a result of the terrorist act, the perpetrator
could face severe repercussions,
including financial repercussions and a sentence of life imprisonment or death.
·
Other
Circumstances: The punishment may also include financial penalties and a
minimum period of incarceration
that may extend to life in prison.
·
Conspiracy
or Assistance: Engaging in, attempting, supporting, assisting, advising,
inciting, or intentionally
facilitating a terrorist act can result in monetary fines and lengthy prison sentences—possibly up to life—along with participation
in a conspiracy.
·
Recruitment
and Training Camps: Organizing or assisting in the establishment of training Organizing camps for terrorist activities or recruiting individuals for such activities could result in lengthy
prison sentences—possibly up to
life—along with financial penalties.
·
Membership
in Terrorist Organizations: Being a part of a group associated with terrorist activities can result in fines
and long-term, possibly life-long, prison sentences.
·
Giving
Shelter to Terrorists: Knowingly sheltering or concealing a person who is known
to have committed a terrorist act can
land you in prison for a long time. potentially lasting all of one's life and carrying financial penalties. If the offender's spouse
conceals the crime,
there are some exceptions.
·
Possession of Terrorist Assets: Having possession of property obtained
through activities may result
in monetary penalties as well as a significant period of imprisonment—possibly
up to life.
Explanation of Key Words:
·
Public
Official: This term refers to constitutional authorities or any central
government- appointed official.
·
Counterfeit
Indian Currency: Currency verified by an authorized forensic authority that
imitates or compromises the essential security features of Indian currency.
Law Enforcement's Role:
An officer
with a rank not lower than that of a Superintendent of Police makes the
decision to file a case under this
section or the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act of 1967. Police. This guarantees that every instance of
terrorist activity is dealt with within the appropriate legal framework.
3.
Organized
Crime (Section 109 BNS):
According to
Section 109 of the BNS, organized crime is any ongoing illegal activity that includes a variety of serious offenses
like contract killings, robbery, vehicle theft, highway robbery, human trafficking for prostitution or forced labour,
economic crimes, cybercrimes, and
more. These activities are carried out by individuals or groups that work
together as part of an organized crime syndicate or independently. To gain material
or financial benefits, either directly or
indirectly, the methods may include violence, threats, intimidation, coercion,
or other illegal methods.
Key Explanations:
·
Organized
Crime Syndicate: A gang or syndicate is a group of two or more people who
regularly engage in illegal activities either alone or together.
·
Persistent
Illegal Activity: Any offense that carries a minimum one-year jail sentence. It
involves multiple offenses that have been acknowledged by the court and for
which multiple charge sheets have been filed with a competent court in the past
ten years. Economic crimes are also included.
·
Economic
Crime: Violations of trust like forging documents, currency counterfeiting,
hawala transactions, mass-marketing fraud, and schemes to defraud banks or
other financial institutions in exchange for financial gain.
Impacts on Organized Crime:
Participation in organized crime carries severe consequences that vary depending on the nature
of the crime and its outcomes:
1. Having a Fatalities:
Penalty: The most severe
legal penalties, including substantial financial penalties and the possibility of life imprisonment or the death penalty.
2. Other Situations:
Penalty: Significant
financial penalties in addition to prolonged incarceration—possibly up to life.
3. Attempt, preparation, facilitation, or participation:
Penalty: A significant fine and substantial imprisonment,
possibly for life.
4. Participation in a Syndicate of Organized Crime:
Penalty: Significant financial penalties and long-term confinement, possibly up to life.
5. Giving shelter to or hiding criminals:
Penalty: Financial
penalties and extended prison time, possibly for the rest of one's life. Exclusion: This does not apply if the offender's spouse harbours or conceals them.
6. Possession of Property from Organized crime:
-
Penalty: Imprisonment for a
term of not less than three years, which may extend to life imprisonment, and a fine of not
less than two lakh rupees
7. Possession of Unaccounted Property
on Behalf of Syndicate
Members: -
Punishment: Imprisonment for a
term of not less than three years, which may extend to ten years,
and a fine of not less than one
lakh rupees.
The severe punishments
underscore the seriousness with which the law treats organized crime, aiming to deter individuals and
groups from engaging in such activities and to protect the public and national interests from the extensive harm
caused by organized criminal enterprises.
4.
Hit and Run
(section 106(2) of the BNS):
This new BNS Section
106(2) offense applies
to situations in which a person causes
someone else's death without
intending to homicide by driving carelessly or recklessly. The driver could
face up to ten years in prison and a financial penalty
if they flee the scene
without immediately informing authorities or a magistrate.
5.
Hurt from
grief (sections 117, 117(3), and 117(4) of the BNS):
According to Section 117(1),
a person is considered to have "voluntarily caused grievous hurt" if they either intend to cause or are aware that their actions
are likely to cause severe injury and the injury occurs.
Sections 117(3)
and 117(4)'s elaboration:
·
Section
117(3): This section addresses the penalties for violators of Section 117(1)
who cause injuries that result in
permanent disability or a state of persistent vegetative state. o Rigorous Imprisonment: The individual
will receive a sentence of rigorous imprisonment as one of the penalties. Duration of Imprisonment: The
offender will be imprisoned for at least
ten years, with the possibility of life imprisonment, which means they will be imprisoned for the rest of their lives.
·
Section 117(4): This section deals with situations in which a group of five or more people
harms another person because of discriminatory factors like race, caste,
religion, gender, birthplace, language, or personal beliefs. The among
the penalties are:
Group Offense: Every member of the group is held responsible for grievous
harm. Penalty: A sentence of up to seven years in prison is possible.
Penalty for Money:
The offender may also be fined.
Connections Between
Section 103(2) (Mob Lynching) and Section 117(4):
·
Action as a
Group:
A group of five or more people acting together is covered in Section
117(4), and a group of five or
more people acting
in concert is covered in
Section 103(2).
·
The Nature
of the Crime:
Section 117(4)
focuses on discrimination-based grievous
bodily harm. Section
103(2) deals with murders committed on similar grounds of discrimination.
·
End Results:
Section 117(4) imposes a fine and up to seven years in prison on each
group member. Section 103(2):
Imposes a fine and either
the death penalty
or life in prison for each group member who committed a homicide.
Key distinctions:
·
The degree
of the offense:
Violation of Section 117(4) entails grievous
bodily harm. The more serious
offense of murder
is addressed in Section
103(2).
·
The severity of the punishments:
Section
117(4): Up to seven years in prison may be imposed. Section 103(2): Includes the death penalty or life imprisonment.
Impact:
The death penalty or life in prison are included in Section 103(2).
Section 117(4) emphasizes the severe harm done to the
victim. Section 103(2): Concerned with murder
as the ultimate result.
6.
Murder by a
Lifer Convict (Section 104 of the BNS):
If a person who is already
serving a life sentence kills someone, they will either get the death penalty
or life in prison, which means they will be locked up for
the rest of their life.
7.
Negligence
that Leads to Death (Section 106 BNS/Section 304A IPC):
Section 106(1)
deals with situations in which a person kills another person without intending to homicide by acting rashly or negligently. The offender could face a fine and up to five years
in prison. A registered medical practitioner could face up to two years
in prison and a fine if they accidentally cause death during
a medical procedure. With specific penalties
for medical professionals, these provisions hold
individuals accountable for negligent actions that result in death.
8.
Crimes of a
Minor Organized Form/ Petty Organised Crimes (BNS Section 112):
According to Section 112(1),
"petty organized crimes" are offenses committed by members of a
group or gang, either on their own or in concert. These activities like
stealing, snatching, cheating,
selling tickets without permission, betting or gambling illegally, and other
similar offenses are examples. The
term "theft" in this section refers to a variety of activities, including shoplifting, card skimming,
trick theft, vehicle theft, theft from residences or businesses, cargo theft, pickpocketing, and ATM theft.
Subsection
112(2):
Petty
organized crime offenders face severe penalties, including the following:
Penalty Up to seven years in
prison, with a minimum sentence of one year.
And fine infractions may also result in the
payment of a fine.
E. Chapter V: Crimes against
women and children: -
1.
Sexual Intercourse
with Deceit (BNS Section 69):
This section
deals with situations in which a person engages in sexual activity with a woman in a deceptive manner or by falsely
promising marriage without intent on achieving it. The individual could face up to ten years in prison and a possible
fine if the act does not qualify as rape.
2.
Employing or
Getting a Child to Do a Crime (BNS Section 95):
Anyone who hires, employs,
or engages a child to commit a crime is subject to a new offense under this section, which carries a
maximum sentence of ten years in prison and a fine. The perpetrator will be held accountable for both the act of
involving a child and the crime itself if
the crime is committed as a result of such engagement. As a result, they will
be subject to both the punishment
imposed by Section 95 and the specific punishment for the crime committed.
3.
Rape IPC Section
375 and BNS Section 63:
With the
exception of sexual intercourse or acts by a man with his wife, provided she is
not under the age of eighteen, this
section does not define rape. This is in contrast to IPC Section 375, which specifies a fifteen-year age
limit for Exception 2. In addition, the BNS definition of rape does not include people of other genders, such as men
and transgender people, in the discussion of gender equality.
4.
Cruelty by Husband
or His Relatives (BNS Section 84) / (IPC Section 498A):
Section 84 mirrors IPC Section 498-A
and is prone to misuse. The Supreme Court of India's judgment in Achin Gupta
vs. State of Haryana (2024) highlights potential abuses of this provision.
Summary of Case (Achin Gupta vs. State of Haryana -2024):
-
Background:
Achin Gupta was accused of cruel treatment toward his wife, including dowry demands
and an extramarital affair, under
Section 498A of the Indian
Penal Code.
Allegations:
The wife claimed that Achin and his family repeatedly harassed her, including demands
for a car and physical abuse.
The Analysis of the Supreme Court: The
Supreme Court found that in such cases, exaggerated claims are common, resulting in social problems and unfair
suffering for the accused. The Court
emphasized the need for a comprehensive examination of evidence beyond the
FIR's allegations. Earlier rulings
(such as Preeti Gupta v. State of Jharkhand), which called for a legislative review of Section
498A to prevent misuse, were cited.
Legislative
Suggestions: To address misuse concerns, the judgment suggested legislative amendments to Sections 85 and 86 of the
Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, similar to Section 498A IPC.
5.
IPC Section
376-D and BNS Section 70 gang rape:
The IPC's age categories are removed from the definition of gang rape in BNS Section 70. The offense
is defined as follows: -
Section 70(1):
Each person is considered to have committed the crime of rape if a woman is raped by a group or individuals with the
same goal. The sentence is severe imprisonment for at least twenty years, with the possibility of life in prison,
which means the remainder of the person’s
normal life. A fair and reasonable fine must also be imposed to cover the
victim's medical bills
and rehabilitation costs. The victim must be compensated for the fine.
Section
70(2): The offenders will face life in prison,
which entails the rest of their natural
lives, or even the death
penalty, if the victim is under the age of eighteen. In this instance, the fine provisions of subsection (1) also
apply.
6.
Assault or Use
of Criminal Force with the Intent to Disrobe (BNS Section 76) and Voyeurism (IPC
Section 354C):
By substituting "whoever" for "man," the BNS has made these two sections
gender-neutral. As a result of this modification, victims
of these crimes of any gender are now protected by law as well as male victims.
7.
Kidnapping from
Legal Guardianship (BNS Section 137(b)) and IPC Section 361:
By eliminating
the age requirement, BNS Section 137(b) makes changes to the previous law. The new provision states that kidnapping
is committed by anyone who removes a child or
person of unsound mind from the custody of their legal guardian without
the consent of the guardian.
A "lawful guardian" is a person who has been legally
appointed to look after or be in charge
of a child or mentally ill person. Unless the act is carried out for sinister
or unlawful purposes. Unless the act
is committed for immoral or unlawful purposes, those who, in good faith, believe they are the father of an
illegitimate child or are entitled to lawful custody are exempt.
F. Chapter XVII:
Property-related violations:
1.
Snatching (section
304 of the BNS):
According to the definition provided in this section, snatching
is a serious form of theft in which the perpetrator abruptly
or quickly seizes,
grabs, or removes
any movable property
from a person or their possession. This offense carries
a fine and up to three years in prison as punishment. The BNS recently added this offense, which is
not covered by the IPC.
2.
(BNS Section
305) Theft from dwelling house transportation, or places of worship:
Theft is a crime
that can result
in a fine and up to seven
years in prison
under this section.
This applies to thefts of
buildings, tents, or vessels used for human habitation or property custody, as well as any means of transportation
used to transport goods or passengers, items or goods from transportation means, idols or icons from places of
worship, and government or local authority
property. This provision, in contrast to IPC Section 380, which only addresses
theft in human dwellings, covers a wider
range of locations.
3.
Mischief (BNS
Section 324):
In contrast to IPC Section 426, which stipulates a maximum of three months in prison
or a fine, this section's
mischief penalty has been
increased to six months in
prison, a fine, or both.
4.
BNS Section
324(4&5) mischief:
Section 324(4):
Mischief that causes damage or loss of more than one lakh rupees but less than 20,000
rupees is punished under this section. The penalty could be either a fine or up
to two years in prison.
Section
324(5): This section increases the severity of the penalty for mischief that
results in a loss or damage of one lakh rupees or more. The offender faces up to five years in prison,
a fine, or both, depending on the severity
of the offense. IPC Section
427, which previously dealt with mischief
involving damages exceeding
fifty rupees, has been replaced
by these subsections.
5.
Mischief Involving
the Killing or Maiming of an Animal ((BNS Section 325):
This section
discusses mischief that results in the death, poisoning, or disfigurement of an animal. The penalty may include a fine or
a maximum sentence of five years in jail. In the BNS, the IPC's various classifications (Sections 428 and 429)
are combined into a single provision.
6.
Punishment for
Theft (BNS Section 303):
Section 303(2):
Individuals who are found guilty of theft face either
a fine or up to three years
in prison under
this section. The penalty for repeat offenses
is increased to harsh imprisonment for a minimum of one year and a fine of up to five years. Additionally, the section makes provisions for first-time offenders who
steal property with a value of less than five thousand rupees. The offender may receive community service instead of
prison time if the stolen property is
returned or its value is compensated. The IPC does not address this idea of community
service and subsequent
offenses.
G. Chapter VII Offenses against
the State:
1.
Sedition and
Acts Endangering India's Sovereignty, Unity, and Integrity:
Defining Section 152:
Individuals who intentionally or knowingly incite or attempt
to incite secession, armed rebellion, subversive activities, or separatist sentiments through spoken or written words,
signs, visible
representations, electronic communication, financial means, or other methods
threaten India's sovereignty,
unity, and integrity. Along with a fine, the punishment includes either life in prison or up to seven years in
prison. This section clarifies that it is not illegal to express disapproval of government actions or measures with the intention of pursuing legal
changes.
Under the Indian Penal Code (IPC),
Section 124A (Sedition):
Punishes
individuals who, by spoken or written words, signs, visible representations, or
other means, bring or attempt
to bring hatred,
contempt, or discontent toward the Indian
government. The punishment
can range from a possible fine and life in prison to a possible fine and up to three years in prison. Disloyalty and
hostility are included in the definition of "disaffection," and it is not illegal
to criticize government policies without inciting
hostility or discontent.
How Section 152 and Section
124A differ:
1.The nature and scope of the offense:
Section 152
focuses on secession, armed rebellion, subversive, or separatist activities
that directly threaten the nation's
sovereignty, unity, and integrity. The more serious threats to the state's existence and territorial
integrity are discussed in this section. While in section 124A addresses
actions that incite
hatred, contempt, or discontent and focuses on maintaining respect
and loyalty for the
government.
Acts Included:
Section 152:
Reflects contemporary threats to the nation's security and covers a wider range of actions, including contemporary methods
like electronic communication and financial meanwhile
in section 124A focuses primarily on verbal and written expressions, signs, and visible
representations intended to undermine the government's authority
H. Chapter XI Offenses Against
Public Tranquility:
1.
Imputations
and claims that harm national integration (BNS Section 195):
This section discusses actions that target specific groups and undermine
national integration. The law
condemns the accompanying activities:
- Declaring in public (through
speech, writing, images,
electronic messages, etc.)
that a specific religious, racial, linguistic, regional, caste, or community
group: -
1. Cannot uphold India's sovereignty and integrity or be loyal
to the Indian Constitution.
2. Should be denied their Indian citizenship rights.
3. Should be dealt with differently or targeted.
4. Disseminating inaccurate or misleading
information that poses a threat to India's
unity or security.
Penalties: -
A fine, up to three years in prison, or both. (1) - The penalty is more severe—up to five years
in prison and a
fine—if the offense
occurs in a place of worship
or during religious services.
2.
Attempt suicide
in order to prevent or restrict the exercise of Lawful Power (BNS Section 224):
Any person
who makes a suicide attempt
with the intention
of preventing a public servant
from carrying out their
official responsibilities will be subject to either a fine, simple imprisonment for up
to one year, or both. In addition,
community service may be required.
I. Chapter IV Abetment, Criminal Conspiracy, and Attempt:
1.
Abetment Outside
India for an Offense in India (Section 48)
The offense of
aiding an offense committed in India from abroad is discussed in this section. For instance, if a person (A) in country X
encourages another person (B) in India to commit a homicide, A is thought to have aided the homicide.
References:
1.
The
Wire: "Duplication or Duplicity?" Retrieved from (https://thewire.in/law/duplication-or-duplicity)
2.
The
Hindu: "New Criminal Bills Have Provisions for Time-Bound Investigation
and Trial: Shah" Retrieved from
(https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/new-criminal-bills-have-provisions-for-time-
bound-investigation-and-trial-shah/article67659180.ece)
3.
Deccan
Herald: "Key Points of Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Which Will Replace
IPC" Retrieved from
(https://www.deccanherald.com/india/key-points-of-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-which-will-
replac
e-ipc-2819605
)
4.
Taxman
Blog: "Comparative Study: Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) and Indian Penal
Code (IPC)" Retrieved from
(https://www.taxmann.com/post/blog/comparative-study-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-bnsindianpenal-code-ipc)
5.
AZB
& Partners: "Overview of the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (2023) Penal
Code" Retrieved from (https://www.azbpartners.com/bank/overview-of-the-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-2023-penal-
cod
e/)
6.
Taxman
Blog: "Analysis: Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) – An Overview"
Retrieved from (https://www.taxmann.com/post/blog/analysis-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-bns-an-overview)
7.
YouTube
Video: "Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023" Retrieved from (https://youtu.be/B_jQ3DIrVs4?si=b85xSwaWZv-lzcsg)
8.
Indian
Penal Code: " Retrieved from
9.
"Bhartiya
Nyaya Sanhita 2023" " Retrieved from (https://prsindia.org/files/bills_acts/bills_parliament/2023/Bharatiya_Nyaya_Sanhita,_20
23.
pdf
10.
YouTube
Video: "Indian Penal Code" Retrieved from (https://youtu.be/4k89RghUIF0?si=Kmcn5FaDFRi95VEq
)
11.
Achin
Gupta Vs State Of Haryana "" Retrieved from (https://www.verdictum.in/pdf_upload/achin-gupta-v-state-of-haryanawatermark-
1614012.pdf)