RIGHTS IN INDIA: PROGRESS DELAYED, BUT NOT DENIED THE JOURNEY OF TRANSGENDER BY - MR. RAHUL TIWARI, DR. VINEETA AGRAWAL & DR. ANIL MANJHI
RIGHTS IN INDIA: PROGRESS DELAYED,
BUT NOT DENIED THE JOURNEY OF TRANSGENDER
AUTHORED BY -
MR. RAHUL TIWARI
Research
Scholar (Law)
Govt. J.
Yoganadam C.G. College Raipur Chhattisgarh, India
Pt.
Ravishankar Shukla University Raipur, Chhattisgarh, India
CO-AUTHOR - DR.
VINEETA AGRAWAL
Assistant
Professor (Dept. of Law)
Govt. J.
Yoganadam C.G. College Raipur, Chhattisgarh, India
Pt.
Ravishankar Shukla University Raipur, Chhattisgarh, India
CO-AUTHOR - DR.
ANIL MANJHI
Assistant
Professor
(Dept. of
Humanities and Social Sciences)
National
Institute of Technology Raipur,
(An Institute
of National Importance) Chhattisgarh, India
ABSTRACT
India has made significant strides in
advancing transgender rights, with landmark developments such as the “NALSA”
verdict and enacting the TG Act, 2019. The NALSA judgment affirmed the right of
transgender individuals to self-identify their gender, leading to the official
recognition of a ‘third gender’ and catalysing crucial legal and social
reforms. Before these changes, transgender individuals faced systemic
challenges, including restricted access to education, employment, and
healthcare due to the absence of legal acknowledgement. The TG Act forbade
discrimination based on gender identification and created a legal framework to
safeguard transgender rights. It mandates government initiatives to promote
education, provide vocational training, improve healthcare accessibility, and
extend social security benefits. Additionally, programs such as the Support for
Marginalized Individuals for Livelihood and Enterprise (SMILE) and Garima Greh
aim to create safe spaces, foster economic empowerment, and enhance social
inclusion for transgender individuals. This article examines the progress of
transgender rights and welfare in India, highlighting the government's role in
promoting inclusivity, justice, and equal opportunities.
Keywords: Transgender, Rights, Discrimination,
Rehabilitation, Scheme
INTRODUCTION
As per the 2011 Indian Census, about 4.6
lakh people were classified as "others" in which includes transgender
people and others who do not identify as male or female. There is currently no
reliable demographic count of transgender people alone (Welfare of
Transgenders, 2019)[1]. The
Supreme Court of India's 2014 ruling in NALSA v. Union of India, which gave the
community legal status, was a joyous day for transgender people in India. Many
people believe that the ruling served as the impetus for the nation's progress
on transgender rights[2]. In
1987, the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) was created as a statutory
organization in India[3].
Its main goals are to set up People's Courts for the peaceful resolution of
conflicts and to offer India's poorer regions competent, free legal assistance.
After its historic 2014 ruling, also known as the NALSA Judgement, NALSA gained
considerable international prominence due to its crucial role in defending the
rights of underrepresented communities[4].
A fundamental freedom for everyone,
the right to use any gender insignia was upheld by this historic ruling[5].
The social and legal landscape for transgender people in India was complicated
before this historic ruling and the ensuing laws since they frequently
experienced systemic marginalization. They were denied mainstream schooling,
jobs, and health care after first being shunned by their family and then being
stigmatized and subjected to discrimination in society[6].
Their identity was not legally recognized, which made it more difficult for
them to obtain essential rights and services that the cisgender community
frequently takes for granted[7].
A major change in addressing the
serious issues encountered by transgender people was brought about by the NALSA
ruling, which acknowledged them as a third gender in India. Before this legal
milestone, transgender persons were not officially recognized, which made it
difficult for them to get necessary government documents like driver's licenses,
voter ID cards, and passports[8]. A
cycle of marginalization resulted from their lack of legal status, which made
it difficult for them to obtain essential public services and rights including
voting, work, and healthcare. Furthermore, transgender people experienced
pervasive discrimination and social exclusion, which had a negative influence
on their quality of life and showed up as violence and harassment in both
public and private settings[9]. The
stigma and discrimination experienced by the transgender community are
acknowledged in discussions recorded from a 2014 government consultation[10].
The community suffered from several abuses, such as neglect, discrimination,
and physical, sexual, and emotional violence, particularly during their
formative years[11].
Teachers and students also discriminated against members of the community who
attended school. The media has brought attention to and the courts have
acknowledged certain instances of police harassment of transgender people[12].
Police ignorance was blamed for this, and the necessity of sensitization was
brought up[13]. The
community was further stigmatized by a lack of access to health treatments
since doctors frequently lacked the knowledge and empathy necessary to handle
the special medical needs of transgender persons, including mental health
issues[14].
Furthermore, transgender people had very few economic options, which forced
many of them to live in abusive situations in unofficial non-profit industries
like sex work and begging. Due to their lack of access to healthcare, they were
also exposed to fatal illnesses like HIV/AIDS while participating in sex work.
Educational obstacles remained, since transgender students' employment
opportunities were restricted by high dropout rates caused by non-inclusive legislation[15].
The foundation for further laws,
rules, and initiatives was laid by this ruling, which centred the discussion of
gender identification around the principles of equality, respect, and dignity.
Thus, transgender individuals were finally acknowledged as a "third
gender" in India in 2014. Since then, India has advanced the recognition
and respect of the rights and dignity of the transgender community through
important court rulings, progressive laws, and government programs that promote
empowerment and social inclusion[16].
THE LEGAL RECOGNITION OF TRANSGENDER INDIVIDUALS
ACROSS NATIONS
Legal regimes around the world have
historically exclusively acknowledged the binary gender identities of men and
women, which are frequently non-excluding. Non-third genders, which are
frequently linked to binary identities, are, nevertheless, starting to be
recognized legally in a growing number of nations. Words like pangender,
genderqueer, polygender, and agender have entered the lexicon of society,
reflecting a rising awareness of diversity beyond conventional boundaries[17].
The legal status of transgender individuals varies greatly. Many nations now
accept sex reassignment surgery and hormone treatments and even permit people
to change their legal gender on birth certificates[18]. The
legality and accessibility of these medical procedures vary by country, though.
All things considered, the level of legal acceptance and healthcare
accessibility for transgender individuals illustrates the various ways that
gender identity is viewed in various jurisdictions and represents a complicated
interaction of medical, legal, and societal issues[19].
Transgender Europe claims that Argentina and trans-Denmark are at the top of
the list for adopting a progressive stance on gender recognition change. A
nonprofit organization managed by Transgender Europe (TGEU) was established in
2005 to promote the rights and welfare of transgender individuals throughout
Europe[20].
Around the world, transgender people
have very different legal statuses. Transgender rights are legally protected in
nations like Argentina, Canada, and India, enabling people to change their
legal gender on official documents without having to undergo hormone or
surgical procedures. However, transgender identities are illegal in many other
places, including Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, and Algeria, and those who identify
as trans face harsh legal limitations (OUTLAWED, 2019; UN Makes History on
Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity Human Rights Watch, 2016). Many nations
have intricated legal systems about the rights of transgender people.
Kazakhstan, Iran, and Bangladesh, for instance, allow transgender identities
but frequently demand sterilization. Similarly, although transgender rights are
recognized in nations like Singapore and the Czech Republic, they are subject
to complicated legislative criteria or medical standards[21].
Transgender rights, including legal
gender recognition without the need for medical procedures, are completely
supported by progressive countries like Denmark, Germany, and the Netherlands on
the other hand, transgender rights are either outright forbidden or severely
restricted in a large number of Middle Eastern and African nations, as well as
in regions of Asia like Malaysia and Myanmar[22].
Argentina is frequently mentioned as
having one of the world's most lenient laws regarding transgender rights.
Passed in 2012, the Gender Identity Law permits people to alter their gender on
official records without the need for surgery, hormonal self-treatment, or
court approval. According to this law is regarded as a model for determining
gender identity[23]. States
in the US have different laws about transgender people[24].
Gender identification is covered by comprehensive anti-discrimination laws in
some states but not in others. According to the policy of the current
administration, the situation has been unstable at the federal level, with
differing levels of protection. Transgender people can alter their legal gender
in the UK thanks to the Gender Recognition Act of 2004[25]. But
this method, which has been critiqued for not entirely self-embracing
identification, entails a diagnosis of gender dysphoria and living for a set
amount of time in the desired gender. Although transgender people are widely
visible in the media and in society, Thailand does not legally recognize gender
change without sex reassignment surgery. In Thailand, transgender persons
experience severe discrimination in society and legal obstacles[26].
In terms of transgender rights, Canada is forward-thinking and has strong
anti-discrimination legislation. Since 2017, discrimination based on gender
identity and gender expression has been illegal in Canada under the Canadian
Human Rights Act[27]. Beyond
the medical or surgical prerequisites for gender recognition, which are still
necessary in many nations, post-Indian laws, like NALSA, seek to define
transgender in a more comprehensive and wide sense[28].
This strategy puts India at the forefront of transgender rights legislation
reforms, promoting substantive equality as well as recognition. These Indian
law provisions seek to address social equity as well as identity recognition,
establishing a thorough legal framework that may act as a template for other
countries thinking about implementing comparable reforms[29].
ANALYSING
THE NALSA RULING
An important legal turning point in
the acceptance of transgender rights was reached by the Supreme Court of India
in the case of the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) versus the Union
of India. The petition, which was filed by NALSA and well-known transgender
activists like Lakshmi Narayan Tripathi, called for the legal recognition of a
third gender in addition to the conventional male and female binary[30].
The main arguments were that people should have the freedom to identify as a
third gender, that they should be entitled to constitutional rights and
benefits according to their identified gender, such as those about health,
work, and education, and that the government should develop policies to address
the social and economic difficulties that transgender people face[31]. Systemic
resistance to acknowledging -binary gender identities is indicative of implicit
hostility that stems from long-standing legal and social standards[32].
The Indian Constitution and
international human rights declarations served as the foundation for the
ruling. Articles 14, 15, 19, and 21 of the Constitution, which address
equality, non-discrimination, freedom of expression, and the right to life and
personal liberty, were heavily referenced in the ruling[33].
The transgender community's right to self-identify was affirmed when these
rules were interpreted to apply to them. Furthermore, the Yogyakarta
Principles, which created the worldwide standards for sexual orientation and
gender identity rights by applying human rights norms in these areas, were
released in 2006 as the result of an international summit of human rights
organizations in Indonesia[34].
Decisions about international norms, such as those about gender identity and
sexual orientation in human rights law, were greatly shaped by these concepts.
This historic ruling established a precedent for increased legal and societal
acceptance of transgender people in India by publicly recognizing the third gender
and directing the government to create inclusive policies. It marked a
significant step toward greater inclusivity and equality by reaffirming the
resolve to grant all people, regardless of gender identity, fundamental human
rights[35].
THE TRANSGENDER LEGISLATION OF 2019
A significant step forward for transgender rights and
welfare in India was taken with the passage of the Transgender Persons Act in
response to the NALSA verdict The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights)
Act, 2019[36]. Creating
a legal framework that protects transgender people's rights is the main goal of
the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. Intersexual people
are defined by the act as those who exhibit differences in sexual traits from
birth. The Act includes both intersexual and transgender identities under its
protections, but it makes a distinction between them. Since intersexual people
are covered by this larger framework, they are not subject to a separate law[37].
The Act's acknowledgement of transgender people's legal
rights is one of its most important features. The Act makes ensuring that
transgender persons are treated fairly in several areas, including public
places, work, healthcare, and education[38]. The
Act creates the National Council for Transgender Persons to handle complaints
and aid in policy-making. This council offers redressal processes, coordinates
actions about transgender people, and advises the government on policy
monitoring[39].
Additionally, the Act
takes care of their needs, stressing the availability of facilities for
hormonal therapy and sex reassignment surgery—this law prioritizes welfare
measures for transgender people[40].
As required by this Act, the government is in charge of creating policies and
initiatives that protect the rights and interests of transgender individuals[41].
Promoting education, providing possibilities for vocational training, providing
healthcare, and guaranteeing secure access are some of these measures[42].
The government and interested parties hope to encourage integration and enable
transgender people to live happy, productive lives by putting these policies
into place.
THE TRANSGENDER PERSONS RULES 2020
The Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Government of India, developed these regulations, which include
definitions, identity certification procedures, appeal and review processes,
and government guidelines for social security, welfare, education, and
non-discrimination Transgender Persons Protection of Rights Rules, 2020[43].
According to the regulations, every state must set up a Transgender Protection
Cell to keep an eye on and address crimes against transgender individuals.
Establishing an efficient grievance redressal procedure and creating and
publishing a policy for equal opportunity for transgender people are also
essential[44]. The
regulations also include a suggested list of social programs to protect
housing, education, health, and welfare policies to improve equality and
inclusivity for the transgender population. The regulations also include a
suggested list of social programs to protect housing, education, health, and
welfare policies to improve equality and inclusivity for the transgender
population. The law mandates that every state's government hospital provide
free gender-affirming surgery, counselling, and hormone replacement treatment[45]. However,
creating a thorough and considerate healthcare environment is essential.
Scholarships for transgender students are a significant step toward inclusivity
in the field of education. However, establishing an educational setting that
values and promotes gender diversity is essential to the success of this
endeavour[46].
SCHEME UPLIFTING THE MARGINALIZED
A welfare program for transgender
individuals and other marginalized groups was introduced by the Ministry of
Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of India, in 2022 as part of the
SMILE (Support for Marginalized Individuals for Livelihood and Enterprise SMILE
2022) initiative[47]. The
initiative has been embraced by all Indian states and territories. The broad
scope of this umbrella initiative, which includes hitherto underserved
populations, demonstrates its aspirational objectives and dedication.
Significant progress, thus, has been made toward mainstreaming marginalized
transgender individuals through the SMILE program’s effective utilization of
legislative and administrative measures[48].
The Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Government of India, launched "Garima Greh," a shelter
home initiative for transgender people[49],
with the assistance of various non-governmental organizations (NGOs) or
community-based organizations to translate the SMILE program into targeted
welfare measures for transgender people Guidelines for Garima Greh Shelter Home
for Transgenders, 2020). The Hindi words "Garima," which means
"dignity," and "Greh," which means "home," are
the roots of the etymology of "Garima Greh." These words come
together to make "Home of Dignity," which refers to refuge facilities
that assist transgender people with their reintegration and assistance[50]. In
order for transgender persons to live with dignity and blend in with society,
they wish to create a safe and welcoming environment. Garima Greh provides a
safe, secure, and friendly environment for transgender individuals,
particularly those without jobs or living below the poverty line (Pon Vasanth,
2021). Garima Greh offers basic services like food, clothing, healthcare, counselling,
and chances to improve one's skills. The shelter aims to foster social
integration, skill development, and personal growth via the dedication of
trained professionals and structured daily routines. The services offered by
the shelter include a variety of fundamental needs and interests, including
access to food, recreational spaces for leisure activities, and opportunities
for positive social interaction. Additionally, to support general well-being,
special days for social interaction are planned in addition to yoga and
meditation classes. Through Niti Aayog's Darpan Portal, NGOs that are trying to
improve transgender rights—particularly those that oversee Garima Greh—can
apply for government grants, highlighting the cooperation between governmental
and non-governmental organizations. Access to library resources for personal
development and, if necessary, legal aid are also provided. Employment and
skill development support and help acquiring identification cards are also
included in housing services. Lastly, the shelter guarantees inhabitants access
to the medical services they require for their healthcare requirements.
ADVANCEMENTS AND PERSISTENT CHALLENGES IN TRANSGENDER
RIGHTS IN INDIA
Indian culture and its transgender
inhabitants have been greatly impacted by the Act and the NALSA ruling, which
have progressively raised social awareness and acceptance of transgender people
and fostered a more inclusive atmosphere throughout the country[51].
However, societal perceptions are difficult to change, acceptability varies
widely, and discrimination and stigma continue, particularly in less urbanized
areas. Notwithstanding these developments, there is still inconsistency in the
application of laws meant to safeguard and empower transgender people. State-by-state
variations in how these rules are interpreted and applied have an impact on how
well they are implemented. Although there are legislative rules requiring
positive action in education and employment for transgender people,
bureaucratic obstacles and a lack of knowledge about their rights among
transgender people frequently hinder practical recognition[52].
As a result, even though the law is in place, social attitudes are changing
slowly and unequally, and transgender people's rights are still not fully
realized. Although the Act calls for
inclusive policies and the creation of a National Council for Transgender Persons
to oversee their implementation, the actual situation on the ground shows a
range of results[53].
Many Hijras still encounter
administrative obstacles while trying to obtain identity certificates, which
makes it more difficult for them to receive government health care and
assistance programs. Furthermore, the community continues to demand stronger
protections, such as reservations in employment and education, to guarantee
full societal integration, and the enforcement of anti-discrimination laws
remains uneven[54].
Although the Act calls for inclusive policies and the creation of a National
Council for Transgender Persons to oversee their implementation, the actual
situation shows a range of results. Many Hijras still encounter administrative
obstacles while trying to obtain identity certificates, which makes it more
difficult for them to receive government health care and assistance programs.
Furthermore, the community continues to demand stronger protections, such as
reservations in employment and education, to guarantee complete societal
integration, and anti-discrimination laws are still not consistently enforced[55].
The act is essentially a step in the right direction toward equality, but in
order to fully benefit the Hijra community, it will need to be implemented
consistently and social attitudes must change.
Concerns about individual autonomy
have arisen as a result of the Act's operational difficulties, including as the
requirement for identification confirmation from the District Magistrate
("Position of Transgender in Contemporary India," 2021)[56].
Discussions have also been triggered by the relatively light sentence for
sexual abuse and the lack of particular consequences for discrimination
("Male and Transgender Rape," 2021). But it is important to realize
that this Act supplements other relevant legislation, not replaces them. This
implies that the current laws are still in force in the same way as they were
before the new legislation was passed[57]. To
improve and refine the interpretation and application of legal principles,
these laws must be studied and comprehended in tandem with one another. The
"Model Prison Act, 2023" was recently finalized by India's Ministry
of Home Affairs. By filling in important loopholes in the current Prisons Act,
it seeks to offer comprehensive guidelines for jail administration. It contains
suitable clauses for inmates' reformation, rehabilitation, and reintegration
into society. Crucially, it guarantees transgender inmates special housing that
meets their unique medical and psychological requirements, protecting their
rights[58].
The Indian government is being urged by the National Human Rights Commission
(NHRC) to accept a transgender kid of a deceased government employee or
pensioner as an unmarried daughter for "family pension" and other
benefits[59].
The welfare of transgender people is emphasised
in this guideline, which also suggests protecting their property rights,
particularly the ability to inherit ancestral agricultural and cultural land.
Notwithstanding legislative developments and the Supreme Court's and the
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019's recognition of their
rights, the transgender population continues to encounter obstacles in social
inclusion, healthcare, and work[60].
The six main action areas listed in the NHRC's advisory are education,
healthcare, employment, welfare, inclusion, and grievance redressal.
Additionally, it is suggested that the state police create a transgender
protection cell, assign a transgender-focused focal officer to each police
station, make sure insurance companies accept TG certificates, and set up
committees and policies at educational institutions to prevent violence and
discrimination against transgender people[61].
CONCLUSION
The advancement of transgender rights
in India, as seen by historic court rulings, progressive laws, and
ground-breaking projects, has cleared the path for a more accepting and
inclusive society. When justice, equality, and respect are at the forefront,
social transformation may occur, as seen by the development of transgender
rights and welfare in India. It starts with the CG ruling, moves on to the
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, and concludes with Garima Griha
and the ADAPSM program. Despite ongoing challenges, progressive policies and
programs that strive to address the needs of the transgender community in India
are based on the core concepts of equality, empowerment, and social inclusion.
Supporting the particular medical requirements of transgender people requires
that therapies like hormone therapy and sex reassignment surgery be covered by
insurance. Better access to housing, safety, food security, and pension
benefits are also promised by the Act, which highlights how crucial it is to
carry out these provisions with dignity and respect. Additionally, NGOs
collaborating with government agencies to advance transgender rights is an
inclusive strategy for dealing with this problem. As progress continues, this
foundation will ensure a future where every transgender person is recognised,
respected and valued, fulfilling the vision of our Constitution makers to
establish a welfare state and the ideology of the Father of the Nation, Mahatma
Gandhi, that justice should reach the last man.
REFERENCE
‘About TGEU
- TGEU - Transgender EuropeTGEU – Transgender Europe’
accessed 18 February 2025
Abrams K,
‘Emotions in the Mobilization of Rights’
‘Access to
Health Services: Barriers Faced by the Transgender Population in India’ (ResearchGate)
accessed 14 February 2025
‘Advisory
for Ensuring the Welfare of Transgender Persons_Sep2023.Pdf’
accessed 19 February 2025
Ahmad SW
and Ali MA, ‘Social Justice and the Constitution of India’ (2006) 67 The Indian
Journal of Political Science 767
accessed 18 February 2025
Bal A, ‘The
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019: A Critical Analysis’
(2020) 3 Issue 6 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities 1069
Bhattacharya
S, Ghosh D and Purkayastha B, ‘“Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act”
of India: An Analysis of Substantive Access to Rights of a Transgender
Community’ (2022) 14 Journal of Human Rights Practice 676
accessed 14
February 2025
Canada W
and GE, ‘Celebrating Five Years of Legal Protections for Gender Identity and
Gender Expression’ (17 June 2022)
accessed 18 February 2025
‘Changes to
the Rape Law in the Offing. Is There Reason for Hope? | The Business Standard’
accessed 19 February 2025
‘Compendium_NHRC_Advisories_2024.Pdf’
accessed 19 February 2025
‘Discrimination
against Transgender Persons Must No Longer Be Tolerated - Commissioner for
Human Rights - Www.Coe.Int’ (Commissioner for Human Rights)
accessed 18 February 2025
Dutta A,
‘Contradictory Tendencies: The Supreme Court’s NALSA Judgment on Transgender
Recognition and Rights’
Europarat
and Europarat (eds), Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and
Gender Identity in Europe (2. ed, Council of Europe Publ 2011)
‘Explainer:
The Crucial Fight for Legal Gender Recognition | International IDEA’
accessed 18 February 2025
‘Frontiers
| Ruptures and Resurgences: Marking the Spatiality of Transgender Identity in
India since the Enactment of Transgender Persons Act 2019’
accessed 18 February 2025
‘Full
Article: Law, Gender Identity, and the Uses of Human Rights: The Paradox of
Recognition in South Asia’
accessed 14 February 2025
Garg R,
‘Government Policies for Gender Equality in India’ (iPleaders, 22 March
2022)
accessed 18 February 2025
‘Inclusion
and Exclusion of Third Genders – Social Hinderance in India’
accessed 19 February 2025
‘India-Living-with-Dignity-Publications-Reports-Thematic-Report-2019-ENG.Pdf’
accessed 18 February 2025
‘Indian
Supreme Court Recognises Third Gender’ (Human Rights Law Centre, 15
April 2014)
accessed 18 February 2025
Jain D and
Rhoten KM, ‘Epistemic Injustice and Judicial Discourse on Transgender Rights in
India: Uncovering Temporal Pluralism’ (2020) 26 Journal of Human Values 30
accessed 14 February 2025
Kishore S,
‘Transgender in India: A Socio-Legal Study’ (2023) 3 Indian Journal of
Integrated Research in Law 1
Kolmannskog
V, ‘“No Going Back”. A Case Study of Sexual and Gender Minorities’ [2016]
Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal
‘LGBTQIA+
Department – Abuse Refuge Org’ accessed
14 February 2025
‘Ministry
of Social Justice and Empowerment - Government of India’
accessed 18 February 2025
‘National
Legal Ser.Auth vs Union Of India & Ors on 15 April, 2014’
accessed 14 February 2025
Nazim S,
‘Historical Development of Legal Aid System in India: A Legal Perspectives’
(2023) 17 History and Sociology of South Asia 69
accessed 14 February 2025
——,
‘Historical Development of Legal Aid System in India: A Legal Perspectives’
(2023) 17 History and Sociology of South Asia 69
accessed 19 February 2025
‘NHRC
Issues an Advisory to Ensure Welfare of Transgender Persons | National Human
Rights Commission India’
accessed 19 February 2025
‘Report of
the Expert Committee on the Issues Relating to Transgender Person’
accessed 14 February 2025
Rupesh KA
and others, ‘A Comprehensive Primer on Transgender Health in India’ (2023) 1
NATIONAL BOARD OF EXAMINATIONS JOURNAL OF MEDICAL SCIENCES
accessed 19 February 2025
Sharma M,
‘A Review of The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 on
Perspective of the Transgender People’ (2023) 6 Issue 2 International Journal
of Law Management & Humanities 3209
Singh J,
‘NALSA Judgement: A Legal Recognition of Third Gender’ (2021) 4 Issue 3
International Journal of Law Management & Humanities 5552
Sriraam S,
‘Time to “Act”: Guaranteeing Full Citizenship of Transgender Persons in India’
in Douglas A Vakoch (ed), Transgender India: Understanding Third Gender
Identities and Experiences (Springer International Publishing 2022)
accessed 18 February 2025
‘Standards
of Care for the Health of Transgender and Gender Diverse People, Version 8 -
PMC’ accessed 18
February 2025
‘Support
for Marginalized Individuals for Livelihood and Enterprise (SMILE’
accessed 18 February 2025
Taylor JK, Transgender
Rights and Politics: Groups, Issue Framing, and Policy Adoption (University
of Michigan Press 2014)
accessed 18
February 2025
‘TG RULES,
2020’
accessed 18 February 2025
‘The SAGE
Handbook of Global Sexualities - Davy, Zowie - Thoreson, Ryan - Bertone, Chiara
- Santos, Ana Cristina - SAGE Publications Ltd - Torrossa’
accessed 18
February 2025
‘THE THIRD
GENDER IN PRESENT DAY INDIA:EXAMINING THE NALSA CASEOF 2014’
‘The
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill, 2016’ (PRS Legislative
Research)
accessed 14 February 2025
‘Transgender
People and Law Enforcement Interactions: Rights and Realities’ (Transgender
Law Center)
accessed 14 February 2025
‘Transgender
Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.’
accessed 14 February
2025
Winter S,
‘Lost in Transition: Transpeople, Transprejudice and Pathology in Asia’ (2009)
13 The International Journal of Human Rights 365
accessed
18 February 2025
‘Yogyakartaprinciples.Org – The Application of
International Human Rights Law in Relation to Sexual Orientation and Gender
Identity’ [3] Shamayeta Bhattacharya,
Debarchana Ghosh and Bandana Purkayastha, ‘“Transgender Persons (Protection of
Rights) Act” of India: An Analysis of Substantive Access to Rights of a
Transgender Community’ (2022) 14 Journal of Human Rights Practice 676
accessed 14
February 2025.
[5] Sohail Nazim, ‘Historical
Development of Legal Aid System in India: A Legal Perspectives’ (2023) 17
History and Sociology of South Asia 69
accessed 14 February 2025.
[6] ‘Full Article: Law, Gender
Identity, and the Uses of Human Rights: The Paradox of Recognition in South
Asia’
accessed 14 February 2025.
[8] Dipika Jain and Kimberly M
Rhoten, ‘Epistemic Injustice and Judicial Discourse on Transgender Rights in
India: Uncovering Temporal Pluralism’ (2020) 26 Journal of Human Values 30
accessed 14 February 2025.
[9] ‘Report of the Expert Committee
on the Issues Relating to Transgender Person’
accessed 14 February 2025.
[10] ‘The Transgender Persons
(Protection of Rights) Bill, 2016’ (PRS Legislative Research)
accessed 14 February 2025.
[12] ‘Transgender People and Law
Enforcement Interactions: Rights and Realities’ (Transgender Law Center)
accessed 14 February 2025.
[14] ‘Access to Health Services:
Barriers Faced by the Transgender Population in India’ (ResearchGate)
accessed 14 February 2025.
[16] ‘India-Living-with-Dignity-Publications-Reports-Thematic-Report-2019-ENG.Pdf’
accessed 18 February 2025.
[17] Jami K Taylor, Transgender
Rights and Politics: Groups, Issue Framing, and Policy Adoption (University
of Michigan Press 2014)
accessed 18 February 2025.
[18] ‘Discrimination against
Transgender Persons Must No Longer Be Tolerated - Commissioner for Human Rights
- Www.Coe.Int’ (Commissioner for Human Rights)
accessed 18 February 2025.
[19] ‘Standards of Care for the Health
of Transgender and Gender Diverse People, Version 8 - PMC’
accessed 18 February
2025.
[21] ‘Explainer: The Crucial Fight for
Legal Gender Recognition | International IDEA’
accessed 18 February 2025.
[22] Europarat and Europarat (eds), Discrimination
on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity in Europe (2. ed,
Council of Europe Publ 2011).
[26] Sam Winter, ‘Lost in Transition:
Transpeople, Transprejudice and Pathology in Asia’ (2009) 13 The International
Journal of Human Rights 365
accessed
18 February 2025.
[27] Women and Gender Equality Canada,
‘Celebrating Five Years of Legal Protections for Gender Identity and Gender
Expression’ (17 June 2022)
accessed 18 February 2025.
[30] Jigyasha Singh, ‘NALSA Judgement:
A Legal Recognition of Third Gender’ (2021) 4 Issue 3 International Journal of
Law Management & Humanities 5552
.
[31] Aniruddha Dutta, ‘Contradictory
Tendencies: The Supreme Court’s NALSA Judgment on Transgender Recognition and
Rights’.
[32] ‘The SAGE Handbook of Global
Sexualities - Davy, Zowie - Thoreson, Ryan - Bertone, Chiara - Santos, Ana
Cristina - SAGE Publications Ltd - Torrossa’
accessed 18
February 2025.
[33] S Waseem Ahmad and M Ashraf Ali,
‘Social Justice and the Constitution of India’ (2006) 67 The Indian Journal of
Political Science 767 accessed 18
February 2025.
[34] ‘Yogyakartaprinciples.Org – The
Application of International Human Rights Law in Relation to Sexual Orientation
and Gender Identity’ accessed 18
February 2025.
[35] ‘Indian Supreme Court Recognises
Third Gender’ (Human Rights Law Centre, 15 April 2014)
accessed 18 February 2025.
[40] Ankana Bal, ‘The Transgender
Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019: A Critical Analysis’ (2020) 3 Issue 6
International Journal of Law Management & Humanities 1069
.
[42] Muskan Sharma, ‘A Review of The
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 on Perspective of the
Transgender People’ (2023) 6 Issue 2 International Journal of Law Management
& Humanities 3209
.
[43] Sangeetha Sriraam, ‘Time to
“Act”: Guaranteeing Full Citizenship of Transgender Persons in India’ in
Douglas A Vakoch (ed), Transgender India: Understanding Third Gender
Identities and Experiences (Springer International Publishing 2022)
accessed 18 February 2025.
[44] “Frontiers | Ruptures and
resurgences: Marking the spatiality of transgender identity in India since the
enactment of Transgender Persons Act 2019,” available at:
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/political-science/articles/10.3389/fpos.2022.963033/full
(last visited February 18, 2025).
[47] ‘Support for Marginalized
Individuals for Livelihood and Enterprise (SMILE’
accessed 18 February 2025.
[50] Rachit Garg, ‘Government Policies
for Gender Equality in India’ (iPleaders, 22 March 2022)
accessed 18 February 2025.
[52] Vikram Kolmannskog, ‘“No Going
Back”. A Case Study of Sexual and Gender Minorities’ [2016] Advances in Social
Sciences Research Journal.
[53] Sohail Nazim, ‘Historical
Development of Legal Aid System in India: A Legal Perspectives’ (2023) 17
History and Sociology of South Asia 69
accessed 19 February 2025.
[55] Kattamreddy Ananth Rupesh and
others, ‘A Comprehensive Primer on Transgender Health in India’ (2023) 1
NATIONAL BOARD OF EXAMINATIONS JOURNAL OF MEDICAL SCIENCES
accessed 19 February 2025.
[56] Suvam Kishore, ‘Transgender in
India: A Socio-Legal Study’ (2023) 3 Indian Journal of Integrated Research in
Law 1
.
[57] ‘Changes to the Rape Law in the
Offing. Is There Reason for Hope? | The Business Standard’
accessed 19 February 2025.
[58] ‘Inclusion and Exclusion of Third
Genders – Social Hinderance in India’
accessed 19 February 2025.
[60] ‘NHRC Issues an Advisory to
Ensure Welfare of Transgender Persons | National Human Rights Commission India’
accessed 19 February 2025.
[61] ‘Advisory for Ensuring the
Welfare of Transgender Persons_Sep2023.Pdf’
accessed 19 February 2025.