IMPACT OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY IN INSTITUTIONALIZING TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN GOVERNANCE BY - DINESH KUMAR MISHRA
IMPACT OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY IN INSTITUTIONALIZING TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN GOVERNANCE
AUTHORED BY
- DINESH KUMAR MISHRA
Abstract-
Corruption and lack of transparency remain
critical challenges in governance systems
not only in India but also
around the globe. These issues are often perpetuated by centralized systems and
their manipulation by system administrators. Furthermore, the lack of data
keepers and the monetization of user data by tech companies further
increase concerns about transparency.
In light of these issues, this research paper aims to review existing
blockchain-based governance models and identify best-practice governance models
focusing on corruption transparency, their characteristics,
and their components. The research
will also examine the concept of
token economy in addressing trusted third-party issues related to asset keeping
management. Further, the research will also explain
how blockchain technology is helping the government enhance transparency in
administrative projects by taking the example of land registry, voting system, supply chain, and identity management. also, the last of the paper will
discuss how blockchain technology is been adopted in India by some of the
states i.e. Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu in collaboration with some private
institutions also function regarding functioning in those states.
KEYWORDS- Blockchain, Transparency, Accountability, e-Government.
INTRODUCTION-
There is a lot of information available online that tries to explain
blockchain using complicated websites and futuristic pictures.
Blockchain is a lot easier
than that. Think of it as a big
collection of data and information that needs to be stored
digitally. That data needs to be broken up into small pieces and sent to
different users and platforms. You might think that someone else can get to
your data, but they won't be able to because every person or platform that has
access to small bits of your data has them encrypted using a method known as
cryptography. Additionally, if your data and/or information is kept in one set,
other people may be able to change it
or even delete it! Blockchain stops that from happening by making sure that
each piece of your data that has been broken
up can only be accessed
by the person who has the key that
can change the pieces of information that have been broken up. It can help users trust a lot
of different services and processes more. A terrible
way to end this research
paper would be to
say that blockchain will change the world
and be useful in every industry. That would not be a lie. That being said, let's look at
India and see how this kind of technology can be used there. Since the government is still looking
into whether cryptocurrencies can be used as money, this
article will not focus on how blockchain is used in cryptocurrencies.
Instead, it will talk about how it is used in manufacturing, banking,
healthcare, supply chain management, and making ledgers less centralized[1].
The person who goes by the pseudonym
Satoshi
Nakamoto created this peer-to-peer electronic transfer system that
needs more and more people to join to make data more encrypted, safer, and more
cost-effective to implement. If someone wants to hack blockchain technology,
they will have to go through millions of lines
of code and will be able to get all the data they want from a huge number of participants. Its first use in India could be to change the way accounting is done so that every transaction is recorded as soon as it happens, no matter what level it happens
at. Information can be sent safely, so there is no chance
of fraud in the many steps an
accounting number has to go through
before it is recorded. If there were
no middlemen, there would be no need for expensive
professionals like auditors
or for tasks
that don't add value, like immediate bookkeeping. Even better, compliances are easy to handle:
just change the rules that the information has to follow
before it is stored digitally[2]. So, all that needs to be changed for
businesspeople who are having trouble because GST rates are being changed is an
entry in the platform of a rule. People's lack of trust in banks has grown a
lot since the 2008 financial crisis. Fraudulent activities inside businesses
can be stopped by accounting apps that
use blockchain, which can
also be used to make it easier for the public to check corporate accounts. Blockchain
can also help with other issues, like lowering identity theft and making sure
that everyone can see what is happening with people's data without letting those
data be seen by everyone.
And making it easier for people to trust the system even more. Blockchain storage works best
in an ideal world where all business relationships are based on honesty[3].
In this kind of world, we can set up platforms
where a person's health data
and health activity can be stored on their personal blockchain, but not
available to the public. If the person lies to a business,
like their insurer
or medical consultant, the technology can help
with investigations. This could completely change the way we do business.
Research design- The
research design for this paper will focus exclusively on qualitative methods,
specifically a thorough review of existing research papers and books related to
blockchain technology, transparency, and accountability in organizational
contexts. the qualitative research design
will rely on a thorough
review of existing
research papers and books
to provide a comprehensive understanding of the impact of blockchain technology
on transparency and accountability in organizational contexts.
Limitation of the paper - The
qualitative research design outlined above offers valuable insights into the
impact of blockchain technology on transparency and accountability in
organizational contexts. The research will primarily rely on existing
research papers and books,
which may limit the scope of the study. It may not capture the latest
developments or perspectives on the topic.
Research Objective:
This research's primary
objective is to investigate blockchain technology's impact on instituting
transparency and accountability in governance contexts. Specifically, the study
aims to: Explore how blockchain technology enhances transparency
in Governance processes.
1. Examine the mechanisms through
which blockchain fosters
accountability in organizational governance.
2. Identify the challenges and opportunities associated with implementing blockchain for transparency and accountability.
3. Assess the implications of blockchain technology for organizational trust,
integrity, and efficiency.
What Is a Blockchain?
A blockchain is a shared database or ledger that is spread out among the nodes
of a computer network. Although they are mostly known for keeping a safe and
decentralized record of transactions in
cryptocurrency systems, they can be
used for other things as well.
Any kind of data can be made
immutable (the word for not being able to be changed) with blockchains. Since a
block can't be changed, the only place trust is needed is where a person or
program enters data[4].
Because of this, there is less need for trusted third parties, which are
usually auditors or other people who make mistakes and cost money. Blockchain
has seen a huge increase in use since Bitcoin came out in 2009. This is because
of the creation of many cryptocurrencies, decentralized finance (DeFi) apps,
non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and smart contracts.
·
Blockchain is a type of shared database
that stores data in blocks
that are linked
together using cryptography. This is different from how most databases
store data.
·
You can store different kinds of data on a blockchain,
but for transactions, it has been most often used as a ledger.
·
Blockchain is decentralized, as in the case of
Bitcoin, which means that no one person
or group is in charge. Instead, all users are in charge.
·
Because decentralized blockchains are immutable, the data that is entered
can't be changed back.
For Bitcoin, transactions are recorded forever
and can be seen by anyone.
How Does a Blockchain Work?
You may know how to use databases or spreadsheets. A blockchain is like
this in some ways because it is a database where people can enter and store
information. However, the main difference between a blockchain and a regular
database or spreadsheet is how the data is stored
and accessed. A blockchain is made up of computer programs called scripts that
do the same things you would do in a database, like adding and accessing data
and saving it somewhere. There are many computers that store different copies of a blockchain. All of these
copies must match for the blockchain to be valid.
The blockchain keeps track of transaction data and stores it in blocks, which are like cells
in a spreadsheet. When it's full, an encryption algorithm is used to turn the data into
a hexadecimal number known as the hash. After that, the hash is
put into the header
of the next block and encrypted with the block's
other records. It makes a chain
of blocks that can be used together[7].
·
Transaction Process- Depending on the blockchain they
happen on, transactions follow a certain
set of steps. For instance,
on Bitcoin's blockchain, starting a transaction with your cryptocurrency
wallet (the app that communicates with the blockchain) sets off a chain of
events. In Bitcoin, your transaction is sent to a memory pool. This is where it is stored
and put in a queue
until a miner or validator checks it. After it is added
to a block and that block is full of transactions, it is closed and encrypted
with an encryption algorithm. After that, the mining starts. The whole network
is working at the same time to "solve" the hash. Except for the
"nonce," which stands for "number used once," they all make a random hash. Each miner
starts with a nonce of zero, which is
added to the hash that
was made by chance. That number is given a value of one if it
is not equal to or less than the target
hash. A new block hash is then made. This keeps going until a miner makes a valid hash[8]. That miner
wins the race and gets the reward.A transaction is done when a block
is closed. Not until five other blocks have been validated, though, is the
block thought to be certain. According to the network, confirmation takes about an hour because
each block takes an average
of just under 10
minutes. This means that the first block with your transaction and the five
blocks that follow it take about 60 minutes. This process isn't used by all blockchains. For example, the Ethereum
network picks one validator at random from all the users who have staked ether to check blocks. The network then confirms the blocks. Bitcoin's process takes a lot more time and energy
than this.
The Importance of Transparency and Accountability in Government
Two of the most important parts of a democratic society are transparency
and accountability, which make sure that the government works for the good of
the people who live there. The government was made by the people, for the people,
and it is their job to make sure their
needs are met. This can't happen, though, unless the government is open
and honest about how it works. When the
government is transparent, the public can see what it does, what decisions
it makes, and what policies it enforces. Accountability, on the other hand,
means that the government is responsible for its actions
and choices, and there are ways to hold it accountable
if it does something wrong[9].
1. Transparency promotes public trust: Trust between the people and the
government must be built through openness. People can see what the government is doing and why
it is doing it when the government is open. Most importantly, this helps people
trust the government, which is very important for a democracy
to work well. People can see how their tax money is being spent, for
example, if the government is open about how it spends its budget. This makes
the government responsible to the people[10].
2.
Accountability
ensures responsible governance: For responsible governance to work, people must be held accountable. Because if it is accountable,
the government is more likely to do what is best for the
people instead of what is best for itself. It also makes sure that the government is accountable for its choices
and actions, and there are ways to hold it accountable for any
wrongdoings. This helps to keep things running smoothly and stops people from
abusing their power or being corrupt.
3.
Transparency
and accountability promote citizen participation: People are more likely to take part in the democratic
process when the government is transparent and answerable. The kids can see that their thoughts
and voices are being heard.
This makes sure that the government is listening to its people and encourages them to get involved.
4.
Lack of
transparency and accountability leads to corruption: When there isn't enough openness and responsibility,
it makes it easy for corruption to happen. People in power can use their power
for personal gain instead of good for the public if there aren't enough checks
and balances. This can cause a lot of corruption, which can hurt the way a
democratic society works.
Accountability and openness
are very important for a democratic society to work.
It builds trust in government, encourages
participation from citizens, stops corruption, and makes sure that government is run responsibly. The government is in charge
of making sure that its operations
are open and answerable, and there are ways to
hold it accountable for any mistakes it makes. A democratic society can't work right without
openness and responsibility, and the people
who live there suffer[11].
Blockchain
& Governance Concepts
Blockchain, which is sometimes called the "distributed ledger,"
is a decentralized, distributed database that works as a peer-to-peer (P2P)
network to provide security, authenticity, and openness. A distributed ledger
is a public ledger that is used by all peers and blocks on the network. Each peer has a copy of the full public ledger
on that blockchain. It's safe, spread out across the Internet, and not controlled by a single group. This cuts out middlemen like banks
and other trusted third parties.
In the blockchain, a block is a group of different pieces of data that
are added to one another. All blocks are linked together in order to make sure
that the data is real and can't be
changed. There are three
things that every
block must have:
(1) the block header, (2) a list of transactions, and (3) information about
how valid the transactions in the block are. There is a public cryptographic key that protects
all transactions and is checked
by all peers in the network. Once the data have been added to the
blockchain, it becomes unalterable and immutable.
Governance means the rules, laws, or powers of a government, business, or
network that control how things work. 'The rules by which assets
managed in the ledger are created and how
the ledger is maintained' are what blockchain governance models explain.
Governance sets clear roles and responsibilities and makes sure that decisions
are made using agreed upon methods. Governance could be looked at from two
different points of view: (1) at the firm level, a set of rules and structures could be used to guide the managers'
decisions; and (2) at the government level,
rules and structures are imposed on businesses, which changes the nature
and manner of these managers' decisions.
Blockchain governance decisions are looked at at three different levels:
micro, meso, and macro. This means that decisions
made at one level don't stand alone; instead, they are linked to
decisions made at higher levels of blockchain governance.
Blockchain Application in the Public
Sector and its Relevant Challenges
People abuse their power in the government by being
corrupt at all levels, from the state to the local level. Corruption can be as small as bribes or as big as tax breaks. But governments all over the world
are working hard to encourage people to take charge of their own lives. To do this, governments
and other public groups around the world are looking into new ways to use
blockchain technologies to get smart governance, cut costs, and make work more efficient. Blockchain can lower
the cost of infrastructure in some situations, mostly by getting rid of the
need for middlemen and allowing
peer-to-peer transactions. Blockchain technology does have some big downsides, though. For example, it
uses a lot of energy and costs a lot of money to buy the hardware and software
needed to run a decentralized network. Blockchain technology uses a wide range
of amounts of energy, depending on the design
choices that are made. It is important to weigh the cost savings of a blockchain against any increase
in the amount of energy
it uses. The type of
blockchain and its consensus mechanism have a lot to do with how much energy it
needs. People often say that public blockchains use a lot of energy, but
private or federated/consortium blockchains tend to use less energy.
For example, Proof-of-Work (PoW) consensus algorithms use a lot of energy,
while Proof-of-Stake (PoS) consensus algorithms use less energy[13].
Blockchain technology improves
democratic innovation and encourages people
to get involved in the public sector
by streamlining processes and protecting recorded data, which makes sure that
everyone can see what's going on[14].
To get people to trust their governments and have good governance, governments
need to be more open and honest. So, not having good government leads
to corruption, which makes it easier for people to do bad things. There are a number of
problems and issues that keep blockchain technologies from being widely used.
These are the technological limits of blockchain and smart contracts, the
organisational complexity and misalignment that come with using blockchain, the fact that systems don't
work with each other, there isn't a governance model,
and there are cybersecurity risks that will make
it hard for companies to use blockchain technologies.
Also, the biggest problems with using blockchain can be broken down into
three groups: (1) technological, (2) organizational, and (3) environmental.
Security, scalability, and flexibility are some of the technological aspects.
As for environmental barriers, they are a lack of legal and regularity support, as well as issues with acceptability and the need for a new
governance model.How important it is for blockchain technologies to be used by many people
depends on the goals that
need to be met. Other technologies might work in some situations, but
blockchains have benefits
that other technologies can't match. For example, if all that needs to be done is to automate a process, a
trusted third party could do it without blockchain. But for goals like making a system that is open,
can't be changed,
and isn't controlled by a few people,
blockchain might be the best option.
Aside from these benefits,
getting rid of third parties that people can trust could also cut down
on costs and corruption. This is especially important in financial situations
where people don't want to take risks and don't want to rely too much on trust.
This is another reason why blockchain technology is a good fit in general[15].
Token, Tokenization, and Token economy
Blockchain can be used for more than just managing cryptocurrencies. A growing
trend is the token economy, in which assets that
are represented by tokens are traded between different blockchain ledgers. The
idea of using digital tokens to own things is called the "token
economy." A token
economy is a way to get people to behave in a way
that you want them to. It's
a complicated system of rewards that
gives people tokens that they can use to buy and sell
different goods, services, or privileges. The token economy is also an
ecosystem, or reward system, made up of three main parts:
tokens, rewards, and desirable behavior. Values, both real and imaginary, move back and forth
between the desired behavior and the token, which is a reward for people who
join the network.
How Blockchain is Enhancing Transparency in Government
Administration Projects
In response to the growing
digital landscape, governments are adopting blockchain technology to augment transparency in their administrative
initiatives. Blockchain is a distributed, cryptographically secure,
and publicly verifiable ledger that enables
recording transactions and data
storage. Using blockchain technology, governments may enhance transparency, mitigate corruption,
and enhance accountability. This blog post will examine how blockchain
technology improves transparency in government administration initiatives.
Additionally, it will present five instances of successful blockchain projects[16].
1.
Land
Registry- A major
obstacle in land registry is the absence of transparency and accountability.
Land register records in numerous countries frequently suffer from
incompleteness, inaccuracy, or susceptibility to fraudulent activities.
Blockchain technology can mitigate these challenges by offering a safe and
transparent method to document land registration transactions. As an
illustration, the government of Georgia has successfully deployed a land
registry system based on blockchain technology, resulting in a significant
decrease in corruption and a notable improvement in transparency. The system enables
citizens to authenticate land ownership and transactions, mitigating the
potential for fraudulent activities and corruption[17].
2.
Voting
Systems-Blockchain technology has the ability to improve transparency
in voting processes. Blockchain-enabled voting systems offer a reliable and
transparent method for recording votes, minimizing the potential for fraudulent
activities and tampering. As an illustration,
the government of West Virginia
has adopted a voting system
based on blockchain technology, which enables
military troops stationed abroad to participate in elections. The technology
has enhanced openness and mitigated the danger of fraud.
3.
Supply
Chain Management
technology can potentially improve transparency in supply chain management.
Through the utilization of blockchain technology, governments have the
capability to monitor the flow of commodities and guarantee their ethical
production and transportation. As an illustration, the Dubai government has
adopted a supply chain management system based on blockchain technology, which
monitors the movement of commodities from their creation stage to delivery. The
approach ensures transparency and accountability, mitigating the potential for
fraud and unethical practices.
4. Identity Management technology has the power to improve transparency in
the field of identity management. Through
the utilization of blockchain technology, governments have the ability to establish a highly secure
and transparent method for managing identities. As an illustration, the
Estonian government has established a blockchain-powered identity management
system, enabling residents to access government services safely. The method
enhances openness and accountability, mitigating the potential for fraud and
identity theft.
5.
Taxation-Blockchain technology has the possibility to improve transparency in the field of
taxation. Blockchain technology enables governments to establish a robust and easily verifiable method for documenting tax transactions that are both safe and transparent.
As an illustration, the Swedish government has established a tax
system that utilizes blockchain technology, enabling citizens to access and
examine their tax information securely. The method promotes transparency and
accountability, mitigating the potential for fraud and tax avoidance.
The adoption
of blockchain technology in India and its future
Given India's extensive geographical expanse and large population, the
implementation of blockchain technology has the capacity to profoundly reshape
and modernize governance, as long as it is done with careful consideration.
While its roots may be traced back to 1979, blockchain technology gained
widespread attention in 2009 by introducing cryptocurrency, specifically
Bitcoin, as it served as the underlying framework. Initially met with caution,
the technology has since attracted significant attention and investment from
both the government and business sectors due to its numerous advantages. The
increasing utilization of blockchain
in governance is particularly noteworthy since it holds
the potential to provide an unparalleled
degree of transparency, precision, and protection[18].
Evolution of Blockchain technology
Initially, blockchain technology was mostly utilized for Bitcoin.
However, in 2014, a decentralized platform called "Ethereum" was
introduced, expanding its applicability to other
areas. The concept of "smart contracts" was established, which refers
to digital contracts that can execute themselves if the conditions are met,
thus eliminating the need for third-party verification.
The increasing adoption
of cryptocurrencies has led to the emergence
of Decentralised Finance (DeFi), which encompasses a
collection of blockchain-powered apps intended to surpass the existing
financial framework[19].
Smart contracts obviate the necessity of intermediary entities such as banks,
while the decentralized structure of the platform
confers individuals with direct
autonomy over their financial matters. Another noteworthy advancement has been
the emergence of Nonfungible Tokens (NFTs). These are distinct digital assets, such as paintings or movies, that
cannot be traded on a one-to-one basis. Due to their reliance on blockchains,
NFTs own distinct identities and ownership that can be promptly traced on the
digital ledger. Furthermore, this has resulted
in their utilization in managing the ownership of tangible assets such as property deeds or vehicle titles.
Applications of Blockchain by the
Indian government in governance
The Indian government has shown a strong interest
in blockchain technology and its use in the public sector. This is evident from
the release of the "National Strategy on Blockchain" by MeitY in
December 2021[20].
The strategy outlines the government's vision to implement blockchain in sectors such as healthcare, agriculture, finance, voting,
and e-governance. It also
aims to establish a "National Blockchain Framework" to create a
national-level infrastructure for blockchain. The goal is to make "Made in
India" blockchain technology accessible worldwide by 2027, while also establishing integration across
blockchain, Internet of Things, cloud, and Artificial Intelligence, referred to
as the "BICA Stack."Despite its previous antagonism towards
cryptocurrencies, the Reserve
Bank of India has been actively developing its own Central Bank Digital
Currency (CBDC), known as the digital rupee, and plans to introduce it in the
near future. Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) will decrease reliance on
physical currency, improve payment system efficiency, and protect the public
from the hazards of privately issued virtual currencies.
The government is presently implementing blockchain
technology for the purposes of land registration, issuance of digital certificates, and payment of customs duty. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI)
and the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)
actively implement blockchain technology in their respective sectors. Local and
state governments have enthusiastically welcomed the deployment of blockchain technology and are currently
integrating it into their governance frameworks. Currently, a significant
proportion of the states in the country are actively engaged in developing
initiatives linked to blockchain technology. An exceptional example
is the utilization of NFTs for land mutation by the
New Town Kolkata
Development Authority in West Bengal.
Spanning across 27,000 acres,
a total of 50,000 NFTs have been utilized to symbolize one million property
records. NFTs serve as evidence of land ownership, and any documents attached
to them are immune to tampering, ensuring transparency in the land mutation process
and eliminating the requirement
for laborious paperwork and record-keeping. The municipal corporations of
Durgapur and Bankura districts in West Bengal have developed a platform based
on blockchain technology to issue official papers such as birth certificates[21].
The "Tamil Nadu Blockchain Backbone" or "Nambikkai Inaiyam" seeks to furnish
each resident of Tamil Nadu with a distinctive state identification that will amalgamate all their vital documents, such as e-sevai,
academic, and birth certificates, into a solitary digital wallet. In addition,
the e-Pettagam App will be introduced,
enabling users to securely share these papers with employers, government bodies,
educational institutions, banks, and other relevant parties. The Karnataka Government has implemented a comparable effort
known as the "Unified Land Management System[22]."
The Uttar Pradesh Government,
in collaboration with Polygon, has introduced the "Firozabad
Public Grievance Management System," an internet platform utilizing blockchain
technology. This system enables
individuals to submit
and monitor grievances. By employing blockchain technology, the
procedure is guaranteed to maintain absolute transparency, preventing any
possibility of tampering by possibly unscrupulous personnel.
Conclusion and the way forward
In conclusion, blockchain technology has
become a powerful tool for
promoting transparency and accountability in various industries. With its decentralized nature, coupled with immutable,
transparent, smart contracts and other features, it enables organizations to
create systems that hold individuals and organizations accountable for their
actions Leveraging blockchain, organizations are tamper-proof records, ensure
transparent transactions, and implement decentralized governance models, which enhance trust and integrity. However, the adoption
of blockchain technology comes with its challenges. Scalability issues,
legal restrictions, and environmental concerns are some of the challenges that
must be addressed. Additionally, integrating blockchain into existing systems
and processes requires careful planning and investment. Moving forward it
requires more research and experimentation to address these challenges and
unlock the full potential of blockchain technology. Connectivity between
blockchain platforms, integrating privacy protection mechanisms, and developing
sustainable governance models are some of the areas that need to be focused on
Furthermore, a collaboration between independents and involvement between government,
industry, and academia is essential
to ensure the adoption and responsible use of blockchain technology also, while
blockchain technology holds great promise for increasing transparency and
accountability, its successful implementation requires a concerted effort
from all stakeholders. By addressing the
challenges and working together, we can harness the transformative power of
blockchain to create a more transparent, accountable, and trustworthy world.
[1] TRIPATHI P, ‘The Growing Role of Blockchain in Indian
Governance’ (orfonline.org, 27 November 2023) www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/the-growing-role-of-blockchain-in-indian-governance>
accessed 16 March 2024
[2] ibid
[3] Srivastava H, ‘Blockchain Technology: Transforming
Transparency, Security and Accountability in Law’ Reader’s Blog (Delhi, 23 June
2023) 3
[4] Supera note 1
[5] ibid
[6] Supra note 1
[7] ‘Exploring Blockchain Technology for Government
Transparency: Blockchain-Based Public Procurement to Reduce Corruption’ (2020)
<www.weforum.org>.
[8] ‘ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY IN GOVERNANCE’
(2022) <www.dmeo.gov.in>.
[9] Jiaying Christine Jiang, ‘Regulating Blockchain? An
Ex-Post Regulatory Impact Assessment of the U.S. Blockchain Regulatory Regime’
(2022) 8 Source: Journal of Law & Cyber Warfare 5
[10] Raffi Teperdjian, ‘THE PUZZLE OF SQUARING BLOCKCHAIN
WITH THE GENERAL DATA PROTECTION REGULATION’ (2020) 60 253.
[11] Supra note 9
[12] Rafael Miranda’s vision for transparent and
accountable governance (no date) FasterCapital. Available at:
https://fastercapital.com/content/Rafael-Miranda-s-Vision-for-Transparent-and-Accountable-Governance.html
(Accessed: 16 March 2024).
[13] Kevin Werbach, ‘Trust, but Verify’ (2018) 33
Technology Law Journal 487.
[14] Pelin Zorlu, ‘Institute for Global Environmental
Strategies Transforming the Financial System for Delivering Sustainable
Development: A High-Level Overview’.
[15] Supra note 13
[16] A Balan and others, ‘Transparency
and Accountability in Urban Public Procurement: Design of a Self- Sovereign
Blockchain App’, International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing
and Spatial Information Sciences - ISPRS Archives (International Society for
Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 2020).
[17] ibid
[18] Supra note 8
[19] Muhammad Ibrahim Khan, ‘Impact of Blockchain
Technology on Transparency and Trust in Programmatic Advertising Supply Chain’
(2024).
[20] Supra note 9
[21] A Balan and others, ‘Transparency
and Accountability in Urban Public Procurement: Design of a Self- Sovereign
Blockchain App’, International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing
and Spatial Information Sciences - ISPRS Archives (International Society for
Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 2020).
[22] Sergi Nin Sánchez, ‘The Implementation of
Decentralised Ledger Technologies for Public Procurement’ (2019) 14 180.