IMPACT OF AI AND CLIMATE CHANGE ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRY IN INDIA WITH RELATION TO LABOUR LAWS BY - DR. AMEENA S. HALIMA
IMPACT OF AI AND CLIMATE CHANGE ON LABOUR AND
INDUSTRY IN INDIA WITH RELATION TO LABOUR LAWS
AUTHORED BY - DR.
AMEENA S. HALIMA,
Assistant Professor
at A.K.K. New Law Academy, Pune
Abstract
Artificial Intelligence (AI) and climate change
are two transformative forces reshaping labour and industry in India. As
AI-driven automation advances across sectors such as manufacturing and retail,
concerns regarding job displacement and workforce restructuring have emerged.
Low-skilled workers are particularly vulnerable to job loss, while AI-powered
platforms have contributed to the rise of the gig economy, raising challenges
related to employment security, wages, and social protections. Simultaneously,
the demand for highly skilled workers is increasing, necessitating a focus on
upskilling programs like the Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana. However,
existing labour laws, including the Factories Act of 1948, are outdated,
prompting the need for regulatory reforms. New labour codes like the Code on
Wages, 2019, offer some updates, yet further adjustments are necessary to
address AI-driven shifts.
In parallel, climate change is disrupting
traditional labour sectors, particularly agriculture, where erratic weather
patterns, floods, and droughts result in job losses and workforce migration to
urban areas. The emergence of green jobs in renewable energy and environmental
sectors offers potential for growth, yet health and safety concerns are rising
due to extreme weather conditions in labour-intensive industries. Current labour
regulations, such as the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions
Code, 2020, require enhancement to accommodate these climate-induced risks.
Additionally, corporate sustainability initiatives are intersecting with labour
practices, demanding a rethinking of corporate responsibility within the
environmental context.
Key labour law reforms are essential to address
the dual impacts of AI and climate change. These reforms include redefining
employment to recognize gig, platform, and climate-vulnerable workers,
enhancing health and safety standards, and promoting continuous reskilling to
facilitate worker transitions to new roles. As India navigates the evolving
workforce, a balance must be struck between automation and human labour, with a
focus on ensuring a just transition to a green economy. The future of labour in
India will depend on proactive government policies and corporate responsibility
to ensure fair, sustainable labour practices in an era of rapid technological
and environmental change.
Keywords:
Artificial Intelligence (AI), Climate Change, Labour Laws, Automation, Job Displacement, Gig Economy, Skill Gap, Reskilling, Health and Safety, Green Jobs, Sustainability, Labour Codes, Employment Redefinition, Occupational Safety, Just Transition, India Labour Industry.
Artificial Intelligence (AI), Climate Change, Labour Laws, Automation, Job Displacement, Gig Economy, Skill Gap, Reskilling, Health and Safety, Green Jobs, Sustainability, Labour Codes, Employment Redefinition, Occupational Safety, Just Transition, India Labour Industry.
Introduction
In the 21st century, two of the most
significant forces reshaping economies and societies worldwide are Artificial
Intelligence (AI) and climate change. While these phenomena appear distinct,
their combined effects are already transforming labour markets, industries, and
regulatory frameworks. AI is revolutionizing industries by automating tasks,
optimizing processes, and creating new types of jobs, while climate change is
disrupting traditional industries, particularly those reliant on natural
resources and environmental stability.
For a country like India, with its vast and
diverse labour market, these changes are creating both opportunities and
challenges. AI-driven automation is enhancing productivity but also causing job
displacement, especially in sectors like manufacturing and services, where
low-skilled workers are at the highest risk. Meanwhile, climate change is
impacting agriculture, water resources, and urban labour markets by increasing
the frequency of extreme weather events and shifting patterns of employment.
These developments demand an urgent re-evaluation of India’s labour laws, many
of which are outdated and fail to address the new forms of employment and
workplace risks introduced by AI and climate change.
The purpose of this article is to explore how
AI and climate change are reshaping labour and industry in India, with a focus
on their implications for labour laws. By examining the changes in job markets,
skill demands, employment relationships, and health and safety risks, we will
argue for the need to modernize India's labour laws to meet the challenges
posed by these twin forces. This article also proposes key labour law reforms
to ensure that the future of work in India is fair, sustainable, and resilient.[1]
Impact of AI on Labour and Industry
1. Automation and Job Displacement
AI has emerged as a key driver of productivity
improvements across industries. The most visible impact of AI in the labour
market is its role in automating repetitive tasks, which were traditionally
performed by human workers. In sectors like manufacturing, retail, and
logistics, AI-powered machines and software are increasingly replacing human labour
for routine tasks such as product assembly, data entry, customer service, and
inventory management. For example, robots now handle assembly-line operations
in the automotive industry, while automated checkout systems are becoming the
norm in retail stores.
While this automation enhances efficiency and
reduces operational costs for businesses, it has also led to significant job
displacement, especially for low-skilled and semi-skilled workers. In India,
where millions of people are employed in labour-intensive sectors such as
textiles, manufacturing, and agriculture, the rise of automation threatens to
render many traditional jobs obsolete. The workers most at risk are those with
limited educational qualifications and skill sets that do not match the demands
of the evolving job market.
The displacement caused by automation is not
just a matter of numbers; it raises profound questions about the social and
economic consequences of technological change. With a large portion of India's
workforce reliant on jobs that are vulnerable to automation, the risk of
increased unemployment, poverty, and social inequality looms large. To mitigate
these risks, the government and businesses must work together to develop
strategies for reskilling displaced workers and creating new employment
opportunities in AI-driven industries.
2. Rise of the Gig Economy
Another significant impact of AI on labour is
the rise of the gig economy, which refers to a labour market characterized by
short-term contracts or freelance work rather than permanent jobs. AI-powered
platforms such as Uber, Ola, Zomato, and Swiggy have revolutionized industries
such as transportation, food delivery, and logistics by creating new types of
jobs. These platforms use AI algorithms to match workers with customers,
optimize service delivery, and provide real-time data on performance.
In India, the gig economy has grown rapidly,
providing employment to millions of people, especially in urban areas. Gig work
offers flexibility and opportunities for individuals to earn income on their
own terms, often as a supplement to other jobs. For young people and those
without formal qualifications, gig work has become a valuable source of income.
However, this type of employment also presents several challenges.
One of the most pressing concerns is the lack
of legal protections for gig workers. Since gig workers are often classified as
"independent contractors" rather than employees, they do not have
access to many of the rights and protections that traditional employees enjoy.
This includes the right to a minimum wage, social security benefits, health
insurance, paid leave, and protection from unfair termination.[2]
The absence of these protections leaves gig workers vulnerable to exploitation
and economic insecurity.The classification of gig workers as independent
contractors has also raised questions about their employment status under Indian
labour laws. The current legal framework does not adequately recognize the
unique nature of gig work, which straddles the line between self-employment and
traditional employment. This gap in the law has led to calls for new labour
legislation that specifically addresses the rights and protections of gig
workers. The introduction of such laws is essential to ensure that the gig
economy can grow in a way that is fair and sustainable for workers.
3. Skill Gap and Reskilling
As AI continues to transform industries, it is
creating a growing demand for workers with advanced technical skills. AI
technologies, such as machine learning, data analysis, and robotics, require
specialized knowledge and expertise that many workers, particularly those in
low-skill jobs, do not possess. This has led to a significant skill gap in the labour
market, where the supply of workers with the necessary skills is not keeping
pace with the demand from employers.
In India, this skill gap is particularly
pronounced. While the country produces a large number of engineers and IT
professionals, many of its workers lack the training and qualifications needed
to participate in the AI-driven economy. This mismatch between the skills of
the workforce and the needs of industries is a major barrier to economic growth
and job creation. The workers most affected by this skill gap are those in
low-wage, low-skill jobs, who are at risk of being displaced by automation and
unable to transition into higher-paying, AI-driven roles.
To address this challenge, the Indian
government has launched initiatives aimed at reskilling and upskilling the
workforce. One of the most prominent of these initiatives is the Pradhan Mantri
Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY), which provides vocational training and skills development
programs to millions of workers across the country. The goal of these programs
is to equip workers with the skills needed to succeed in the evolving job
market, particularly in sectors such as IT, data science, and renewable energy.
However, the scale of these efforts must be
expanded to address the specific challenges posed by AI. In addition to
technical training, workers need access to continuous learning opportunities
that allow them to adapt to changing technologies and industries. Public-private
partnerships, involving both the government and businesses, could play a key
role in providing the resources and infrastructure needed to support lifelong
learning and skill development.
4. Regulatory Challenges
India's labour laws were largely designed in a
different era, one that was characterized by industrial manufacturing and
manual labour. For example, the Factories Act, 1948, which regulates working
conditions in manufacturing units, was drafted at a time when factories relied
on human labour for most tasks. Today, with the rise of AI-driven industries
and the gig economy, many of these laws are outdated and do not adequately
address the realities of the modern labour market.
One of the key regulatory challenges posed by
AI is the need to redefine employment. Traditional labour laws assume a clear
employer-employee relationship, where the employer provides a job, sets working
conditions, and offers social security benefits. However, in the gig economy
and AI-driven workplaces, this relationship is often more ambiguous. Workers
may be employed on a freelance basis, work for multiple employers, or perform
tasks that are mediated by AI algorithms rather than human supervisors.
In response to these changes, India has
introduced new labour codes, such as the Code on Wages, 2019, and the
Industrial Relations Code, 2020. These codes aim to simplify and modernize labour
regulations by consolidating multiple laws into a more streamlined framework.
The Code on Wages, for example, establishes a national minimum wage and extends
its application to a wider range of workers, including those in informal
sectors.
However, these reforms are not without
limitations. The new labour codes still do not fully address the unique
challenges posed by AI and the gig economy. For example, the question of how to
classify gig workers remains unresolved, and there is little guidance on how to
regulate AI-driven workplaces where human oversight may be minimal. As AI
continues to reshape industries and employment relationships, further
regulatory reforms will be necessary to ensure that labour laws remain relevant
and effective.
Impact of Climate Change on Labour and Industry
1. Job Losses in Agriculture and Other Sectors
Climate change is having a profound impact on labour
markets in India, particularly in sectors that are dependent on natural
resources and environmental stability. Agriculture, which employs nearly half
of India’s workforce, is especially vulnerable to the effects of climate
change. Erratic weather patterns, rising temperatures, and extreme weather
events such as floods and droughts are reducing agricultural productivity and
threatening the livelihoods of millions of farmers and agricultural workers.
For example, changes in monsoon patterns and
increasing temperatures have led to declining crop yields in many parts of
India. This has not only reduced the incomes of farmers but also led to a
decline in agricultural jobs. The workers most affected by these changes are
those who are already economically vulnerable, including smallholder farmers,
landless labourers, and women who rely on agriculture for their livelihoods.[3]
The impact of climate change is not limited to
agriculture. Other sectors, such as forestry, fisheries, and textiles, are also
experiencing job losses due to changing environmental conditions. For instance,
rising sea levels and ocean temperatures are affecting fish populations,
leading to a decline in jobs in the fishing industry. Similarly, the
availability of raw materials such as cotton, which is heavily dependent on
stable weather patterns, is becoming less predictable, leading to job losses in
the textile sector.
These climate-related job losses are
contributing to a broader pattern of migration from rural to urban areas. Many
displaced workers are moving to cities in search of employment, leading to
increased competition for jobs in already crowded urban labour markets. This
rural-to-urban migration is creating new challenges for policymakers, as it
exacerbates issues such as unemployment, poverty, and inadequate access to
housing and social services in cities.
2. Emergence of Green Jobs
While climate change is causing job losses in
some sectors, it is also creating new employment opportunities in others,
particularly in the emerging "green economy." The green economy
refers to industries that focus on sustainability, environmental protection,
and the transition to renewable energy sources. As India seeks to reduce its
carbon emissions and meet its commitments under international climate
agreements, the demand for green jobs is expected to grow.
One of the most promising areas for job
creation is renewable energy. India has set ambitious targets for expanding its
solar and wind energy capacity, and the renewable energy sector is expected to
create millions of jobs in areas such as solar panel installation, wind turbine
maintenance, and energy-efficient construction. Similarly, jobs are emerging in
sectors such as waste management, water conservation, and environmental
restoration, as businesses and governments invest in sustainability
initiatives.
The growth of green jobs presents an
opportunity to offset some of the job losses caused by climate change. However,
to fully realize this potential, workers need to be equipped with the skills
and training required for green jobs. This includes both technical skills, such
as those needed to install and maintain renewable energy infrastructure, and
broader knowledge of environmental issues and sustainable practices. Government
programs and public-private partnerships will be crucial in providing the
necessary training and support for workers transitioning to the green economy.
3. Health and Safety Concerns
Climate change is also having a direct impact
on worker health and safety, particularly in labour-intensive industries such
as construction, agriculture, and manufacturing. Rising temperatures and
extreme weather events are creating hazardous working conditions, especially
for outdoor workers who are exposed to the elements.
For example, heat stress is becoming an
increasingly serious issue in many parts of India, where temperatures regularly
exceed 40°C (104°F) during the summer months. Workers in agriculture,
construction, and other outdoor industries are at risk of heat-related
illnesses, including dehydration, heatstroke, and exhaustion. Prolonged
exposure to high temperatures can also reduce worker productivity and increase
the risk of accidents.
In addition to heat stress, extreme weather
events such as floods, storms, and landslides are posing new safety risks for
workers. These events can disrupt transportation and supply chains, damage
infrastructure, and create dangerous working conditions in industries such as
mining and construction. Workers in these sectors need access to adequate
protective equipment, training, and safety protocols to minimize the risks
associated with extreme weather.
India's labour laws must be updated to reflect
these new health and safety challenges. The Occupational Safety, Health, and
Working Conditions Code, 2020, is a step in the right direction, as it
consolidates and modernizes health and safety regulations across industries.
However, more specific provisions are needed to address the unique risks posed
by climate change, including guidelines for managing heat stress, improving
workplace ventilation, and ensuring that workers have access to adequate rest
breaks and hydration during extreme weather.
4. Corporate Responsibility and Sustainability
As businesses and industries adapt to the
challenges of climate change, there is increasing pressure on companies to
adopt sustainable practices and reduce their environmental impact. This trend
is being driven not only by government regulations and international agreements
but also by consumer demand for environmentally responsible products and
services.
Corporate sustainability initiatives are
closely linked to labour practices. For example, companies that invest in
renewable energy and energy-efficient technologies are often able to reduce
their operating costs, which can lead to higher wages and better working
conditions for employees. Similarly, businesses that prioritize waste reduction
and recycling can create new jobs in areas such as waste management and
environmental restoration.
However, there is also a risk that the push for
sustainability could lead to job losses in industries that are dependent on
fossil fuels and other environmentally harmful practices. For example, the coal
industry, which has been a major source of employment in India for decades, is
facing significant job cuts as the country transitions to cleaner energy
sources. To ensure a just transition to a green economy, labour laws must be
updated to protect workers in industries that are being phased out, while also
promoting job creation in sustainable sectors.
Key Labour Law Reforms for AI and Climate
Change
1. Redefining Employment
One of the most pressing labour law reforms
needed in response to the rise of AI and the gig economy is the redefinition of
employment. Current labour laws are based on a traditional model of employment,
where workers are hired by a single employer, work fixed hours, and receive
benefits such as health insurance and retirement plans. However, this model no
longer reflects the reality of the modern labour market, where gig workers,
freelancers, and AI-driven platforms play a significant role.
To address this gap, labour laws must be
updated to include new categories of workers, such as gig workers, platform
workers, and freelancers. These workers should have access to basic rights and
protections, including minimum wage guarantees, social security benefits, and
protection from unfair dismissal.[4]
The introduction of a legal framework that recognizes the unique nature of gig
work is essential to ensure that workers in the gig economy are not exploited
or left vulnerable to economic insecurity.
Additionally, labour laws should consider the
inclusion of climate-vulnerable workers, such as those in agriculture or other
sectors impacted by climate change. These workers require special protections,
including income support and social security, to mitigate the risks posed by
environmental disruptions.
2. Improving Health and Safety Standards
AI-driven industries and climate-affected sectors
both present new health and safety challenges. In AI-powered industries,
job-related stress, mental health issues, and the impact of surveillance
technologies on worker privacy are emerging concerns. In climate-sensitive
industries, the physical risks posed by extreme weather events and rising
temperatures are significant. Labour laws must be updated to reflect these new
realities, ensuring that both physical and mental health risks are adequately
addressed.
Provisions for heat safety, workplace stress
management, and the use of protective equipment in hazardous environments
should be incorporated into existing labour codes. Furthermore, workers should
be given the right to refuse unsafe work conditions in industries that are
vulnerable to climate-related hazards.
3. Promoting Reskilling and Transitioning to New
Roles
The rapid pace of technological change, coupled
with the need for a green economy, has made reskilling and upskilling critical
for workers. Government programs such as the Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas
Yojana (PMKVY) are already providing training for millions of workers, but
these efforts must be scaled up. Public-private partnerships could play a key
role in expanding reskilling programs, ensuring that workers displaced by
automation or climate change are prepared for new roles.
Continuous learning should become a central
component of India’s labour policies, with incentives for businesses to invest
in their workers’ skill development. Labour laws could be reformed to mandate
corporate contributions to worker training funds, ensuring that businesses take
responsibility for the reskilling of their employees.
The Future of Labour in India
The future of labour in India will be shaped by
two major forces: AI and climate change. The rise of automation will require a
careful balancing act between maximizing efficiency and protecting jobs, while
the transition to a green economy will create new opportunities in emerging
sectors. The role of the government, businesses, and workers themselves will be
critical in navigating these changes.
The government must take the lead in ensuring
that labour laws are modernized to reflect the realities of AI and climate
change. Businesses, too, must adopt sustainable labour practices and take
responsibility for the well-being of their workers. Workers must be empowered
to adapt to these changes through access to education, training, and legal
protections.
Conclusion
The impact of AI and climate change on labour
and industry in India is profound and far-reaching. These forces are reshaping
the economy, displacing traditional jobs, and creating new opportunities in
green industries and AI-driven sectors. However, to ensure that these changes
lead to fair and sustainable outcomes for workers, India must reform its labour
laws to protect vulnerable workers, promote reskilling, and improve health and
safety standards. The need for proactive, comprehensive labour law reform is
urgent, and the future of India’s workforce depends on the steps taken today to
adapt to these transformative forces.
[1] M P Jain Indian Constitutional Law,
Publisher, LexiNexis Edition, Eighth, Publication Date,4 February 2018
[2] Labour and Industrial Laws, Publisher, Commercial Law
Publishers (India) Pvt Ltd. Publication Date
1 January 2023
[3] Taxmann's Labour Laws,Publisher,
Taxmann Publications Pvt. Ltd. Edition 2023 Edition Publication Date 3 January
2023
[4] Introduction to Labour and Industrial Laws by Avtar Singh and Harpreet Kaur, Publisher: Lexis Nexis Edition: 1st Edition, 2022