CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF CRIMINAL OFFENCES AGAINST GENDER BY - KASHISH PUSHKAR
CRITICAL
ANALYSIS OF CRIMINAL OFFENCES AGAINST GENDER
AUTHORED BY
- KASHISH PUSHKAR
Institution:
Jigyasa University Dehradun (Formerly Himgiri Zee University)
BA LLB (Hons)
2 Year Student
SYNOPSIS
Every year, the National Crime Record
Bureau (NCRB) releases an annual report on the statistics of crime against
women in India. From the previous census to the present, we can examine the
highlighted rate of increase. In 2020, there were 3,71,503 cases, which
increased to 4,45,256 cases in 2022. In 2021, 4,28,278 cases were recorded. The
terrible increase in the number of cases of crime against women is an alert
sign that, in the 21st century, the question of the safety of women
is at its peak. Another point of concern from these statistics is “Why is only
the crime rate against women increasing?” YES! The answer to this question is
undoubtedly in our subconscious mind: women, being considered the weakest
section of society, are easily targeted. And living a life under the dominance
of patriarchal bargaining, women are considered emotional decision-makers
rather than strong sentient beings. So far, women are only considered the
victims of violence, and society has a stereotype of women being the
sufferers. The author, through this article, throws light on the different
types of violence faced by women and why the crime rate is increasing against
women only. One individual parameter of the article elaborates on the point of
men being the victims too. The summarised evolution talks about gender-neutral
laws. This article also deals with the constitutional safeguards and other
Indian laws that help curb violence against women.
Keywords: Crime; Statistics; Patriarchal
bargaining; Stereotypes; Constitutional safeguards
Introduction to Roots of Crime against Gender
The actual calculation or census of
violence against women in India has not been accurate because most of the
crimes are not even reported. The history of violence against women can be
traced back to Draupadi’s Vastra Haran in the Mahabharata, which was a form of
violence she faced that was very traumatic. A look at the Indian social
structure showcases the important role of women and even the discrimination
faced by them. Evil practices like Sati Pratha, child marriage, polygamy,
female foeticide, etc. were the social problems faced by women. Not only in
India but also in English Common Law in England and America in the 18th century,
men had the permission to use sticks and whips to teach discipline to their
wives and children, which continued till the 19th century until regression was
shown to these practices.
In history, we can see the condition
of the Rohingya population. Raziya Sultan became an advocate for Rohingya
refugee women in Bangladesh and globally. They experienced harassment and abuse
by the army. They also did dehumanising and physical checks on women, like
vaginal tests. They were raped and mutilated.
During the Renaissance period, which
is termed the Enlightenment period in the history of France, there was also
violence faced by women. There was the belief that if a girl loses her
virginity, it will be dishonour. If any woman were raped or was a victim of
rape, then she would be the one who would be punished. When some young girls
became victims of rape or seduction, they were turned into prostitutes. In an
earlier time, the scope of crime was just offline. But with the spread of
modernization, cybercrime against women has also increased. It can be
clearly seen that patriarchal culture prevailed from the roots of history.
Men are mainly the ones who commit crime, and in most cases, women
are the victims. Globally, there is an
estimate by UN Women[1]
that 736 million women—almost one in three—have been subjected to physical or
sexual violence. Intimate partner violence is another common form of violence
faced by women, with a figure of 640 million in total.
Understanding the Key Concept
The prevailing gender
stereotypes target women as the weaker section of society. They are considered
emotional sentient beings. This discriminates against the rights and duties
given to them as compared to men. The pattern of patriarchal dominance has been
performed in society in the past and still is in the present.
The term
·
Violence
·
Crime
·
Offence
·
Victim
·
Patriarchy
Has
different meanings and different aspects for women.
A.
The Declaration on the Elimination of
Violence Against Women[2]
issued by the UN General Assembly in 1993 defines violence against women as
“any act of gender-based violence that results in, or is likely to result in,
physical, sexual, or psychological harm or suffering to women, including
threats in public or private life.”
The
United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR)[3]
defines violence as the intentional or unintentional use of force, whether
physical or psychological, threatened or actual, against an individual,
oneself, or a group of people, a community, or a government.
B.
In the Rome Statute of the International
Criminal Court[4],
Article 7—crime against humanity—gives the definition of crime. It includes
such acts as murder, enslavement, imprisonment, torture, rape, sexual slavery,
etc. Done at a widespread range as organised attacks against civilian
populations.
According
to an article from the National Health Institute[5],
crime has been defined in different social and humanistic sciences as
“behaviour against order” and “behaviour against public feelings and emotions.”
Crime is a human behaviour and a social phenomenon that can be studied from
different viewpoints. Crime is something that affects the whole state or
country at large. It involves both criminal intention and criminal acts.
C. ‘Offences’ are also referred to as
crimes, unlawful acts, etc. In simpler terms, they can be defined as violations
of the law or illegal actions. Offences are diverse and come in various types.
Based on different criteria, offences can be classified into several types,
including:
1.
offences
against the human body.
2.
Offences
against the state
3.
Offences
against children and women. Section 40 of the Indian Penal Code defines
‘offence’: when a thing punishable under the special or local law is punishable
under such law with imprisonment for a term of six months or upwards, whether
with or without a fine.
D. In the Declaration of Basic
Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime and Abuse of Power[6],
the definition of victim means persons who, individually or collectively, have
suffered harm caused by actions or inactions, such as bodily or mental pain,
emotional distress, financial loss, or a significant impairment of their
fundamental rights.
In the Cambridge Dictionary, the word
victim means someone or something that has been hurt, damaged, killed, or has
suffered, either because of the actions of someone or something else or because
of illness.
E. According to Sylvia Walby,
patriarchy is “a socially structured system and practices in which domination,
oppression, and exploitation of women are done by men.” It is a system in which
power is handled by men, and they have more control in their hands than women.
Patriarchy (or “pitrasatta” in Hindi) means the dominance or rule of the father
in a family where males hold more power. Most of the citizens are unaware of
the differences in basic terms, which leads them to take the wrong actions.
Lack of awareness is the major reason why most crimes are unregistered. To
understand the situation of women, a wide analysis of reports of crime against
women, not just nationally but globally, should be done.
Human
rights are those rights that are given and enjoyed by all human beings,
regardless of their race, caste, language, religion, etc. But when women and
girls face violence, it is the most prevalent human rights violation. All
around the globe, each and every day, the crime rate against women is
increasing. It just harms the woman mentally or physically, but the dignity of
the woman in her own mind gets shattered, which is the basic reason why the
victim commits suicide. The fact that they will not be again recognised by society neutrally
creates a fear and compels the gender not to report the crime committed against
her
Various Types of violence against
Women[7]
1. Intimate-Partner Violence: It is the most common form of violence that is seen
with women. It is a clear indication of the practice of domestic violence.
Intimate partner violence includes
·
Physical
violence: hurting, hitting or trying to hit, denying medical care, forcing
alcohol or drug use, etc.
·
Sexual
violence: abusive behaviour, physical and emotional abuse, etc.
·
Psychological
violence: causes interpersonal trauma, depression, suicidality, etc.
·
Economic
violence: control over a partner’s or ex-partner’s money and finances, etc.
Domestic violence: Domestic violence is also used to
describe intimate-partner violence. It occurs within the private or domestic
sphere. It is not just done with women but also with children, like child abuse
and elder abuse.
Every 1.7 minutes, a woman
experiences domestic abuse, according to the 2018 National Crime Research
Bureau (NCRB) crime report[8] in
India.
The Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act 2005 provides protection to women against domestic violence and
other crimes.
Case Law: Lalita Toppo v. State of
Jharkhand (2018): The Supreme Court of India ruled that a woman in a
live-in relationship, akin to a wife, is entitled to maintenance. The court emphasised
the need to protect women’s rights and financial security even in
non-traditional relationships. In the case Inder Raj Malik v. Sunita Malik
(1986): The Delhi High Court held that a person can be found guilty under
both Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1956, and Section 498A of the
Indian Penal Code (IPC) without it being considered double jeopardy. The
court’s reasoning is that these two laws serve different purposes: Section 4 of
the Dowry Prohibition Act punishes mere demands for dowry, while Section 498A
of the IPC deals with acts of cruelty against newly married women. Therefore,
someone can be charged under both laws for their respective offences.
2.
Sexual Violence: The unwanted sexual behaviour or
harm that is done on someone is called as sexual violence. It also includes
abusive sexual touching, making someone to do sexual things against their
consent, verbal abuse, unwanted touching & other such acts. Sexual Violence
also includes the following:
·
Sexual harassment: It is a sexual behaviour which is inappropriate and unwanted due to
which someone feels uncomfortable, scared, or offended. It includes touching,
comments, jokes or gestures of sexual nature. Sexual Harassment can be verbal,
non- verbal, physical, even written or electronic communication.
Now days sexual harassment
took place as Cyber Crime also. Section 354A of IPC defines the term sexual
harassment and provide punishment for it, which is further explained in this
paper.
CASE LAW: Vishaka and
others v. State of Rajasthan 1997: It is a landmark case in which the
Supreme Court gave the definition of sexual harassment, “Any direct or indirect
unwelcoming sexual action like demand or request of sex, verbal or non-verbal
sexual conduct, physical contact.” Vishaka Guidelines were laid down in this
judgement that said Article 14,15,19(1)(g),21 of the constitution provides
safeguard against sexual harassment & provide right to work with dignity.
A separate law had
established on prevention of sexual harassment against female employees at
workplace “The Sexual Harassment of Women at workplace (Prevention,
Prohibition, Redressal) Act 2013.
·
Rape: In
Indian Penal Code (IPC) Section 375 and 376 deals with Rape. In simple words,
the act of forcing someone to have sex without their consent, using violence,
threat, or taking advantage of their inability to refuse.
Cases
like Unnao Rape (2017), Nirbhaya Rape (2012), Ankita Bhandari Rape (2022),
Hyderabad Rape & Murder (2019). “Matri Devo Bhava” is the culture of India
that means “mothers and women should be worshipped”, but this belief has
vanished away due to rise in rape cases. According to National Crime Report
Bureau (NCRB) every 6-minute one rape took place, which is calculated than
comes to an estimate of 100 rapes in one day.
REASONS FOR RAPE:
·
Male
domination un society
·
The
societal thoughts or stereotypes that women are born to be used.
·
The
bar over women for just Domestic work & Sexual activities.
·
Poverty
gave rise to criminals who commit rape
·
Lack
of education about gender and sex.
3.
Child, early and forced Marriage: In the Hindu
Marriage Act of 1955, the legal age for marriage of girls in India was 18 and
for marriage of boys was 21. But there is a wrong belief among people that
child marriage is only performed in rural areas, but this practice is still in
urban areas as well. A special age is fixed because, with age, maturity and
consent come up. And a marriage that is held without consent is a forced
marriage, which is a crime.
The
Child Marriage Restraint Act (1929) and the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act
(2006) aimed to stop marriage before the maturity age came.
4.
Human trafficking: a crime that is committed at the global level. The
traffickers use different tricks to trap the victims, mostly girls and women,
by giving false job opportunities, conducting interviews, or using manipulative
techniques. Not just women, but even men and children are also targets. Sexual
exploitation, or organ trade, is the major reason for human trafficking. In
countries like Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Libya, and Yemen, the rate of human
trafficking is the highest, as per the Organised Crime Index[9].
5.
Female Genital Mutilation (FGM): In this, there is complete or
partial removal of female external genitals, or other injuries are done to that
part. The harm caused by this is very serious; it can even cause death, health
risks, infection, HIV, etc. In 1996, the United Nations General Assembly passed
the “Girl Child Resolution[10],”
which defined female mutilation as discrimination against girl children and a
violation of fundamental rights. In 2020, the 44th session of the
Human Rights Council took place, in which a resolution was adopted to eliminate
female genital mutilation[11].
6.
Femicide: The intentional killing of women because they are women or
girls is called femicide. The intention of murdering women. The major reason
behind femicide is armed conflict, gangs, and human trafficking. In 2022,
Africa recorded the highest cases of female killing and intimate violence, with
an estimate of 20,000 victims. The UN Special Rapporteur on Violence Against
Women recognised femicide as a form of violence against women.
7. Web Violence: The use of digital tools for physical,
sexual, psychological, social, political, or economic harm or taking away of
rights and freedom. Females, or even males or children, are trapped by online
space, which can also result in offline meetings with the criminal. GPS
trackers are also used in this.
Online violence includes:
·
Cyberbullying means sending someone messages or online communications that scare
or threaten them.
·
Non-consensual sexting means sending someone wrong intentional messages or photos related
to sexual aspects without their permission.
·
Doxing means posting or releasing someone's private or personal
information online without their consent.
Statics of crime against women
1. National Crime Records
Bureau (NCRB)[12]: The NCRB report showed that crimes
against women increased significantly. In 2020, there were 3,71,503 cases reported,
which rose to 4,45,256 cases in 2022. This was higher than the 4,28,278 cases
reported in 2021, indicating a troubling rise in 2022. The report pointed out
that many crimes against women, according to Indian laws, involved specific
types: 31.4% are related to 'Cruelty by Husband or His Relatives', 19.2% to
'Kidnapping and Abduction of Women', 18.7% to 'Assault on Women with Intent to
Outrage Her Modesty', and 7.1% to 'Rape’. The rate of these crimes per lakh
women increased from 64.5 in 2021 to 66.4 in 2022. It highlighted a rise in
crimes against women, children, seniors, SCs, and STs by 8.7%, 9.3%, 13.1%, and
14.3%, respectively. Economic offences increased by 11.1%, corruption by 10.5%,
and cybercrimes by 24.4% in 2022.
2. World Health
Organization (WHO)[13]: More than one out of four women aged 15 to 49 who have been in a
relationship have experienced physical and/or sexual violence from their
intimate partner at least once in their life (since they were 15 years old).
The percentage of women affected varies across different regions: it's around
20% in the Western Pacific, 22% in high-income countries and Europe, and up to
33% in regions like Africa, the Eastern Mediterranean, and South-East Asia,
according to the World Health Organisation (WHO). In 2018, the World Health
Organisation (WHO), working with the UN, studied data from 2000 to 2018 across
161 countries. They found that globally, almost 1 in 3 women, which is about
30%, experienced physical and/or sexual violence from either an intimate partner
or non-partner sexual violence, or both.
3. Pan America Health Organisation[14]: One out of every three women and girls aged 15 to 49 in the
Americas has faced physical and/or sexual violence from either a partner or
someone who is not their partner. 38% of female homicides worldwide are carried
out by a male intimate partner.
4. National Institute for Health (NIH):
In a study conducted in India with about 10,000 women, 26% reported
experiencing physical violence from their spouses in their lifetime. In some
areas, like Uttar Pradesh, this figure could be as high as 45%. According to
the latest data from the National Crime Records Bureau, a crime against women
is recorded every three minutes in India. Every hour, at least two women are
sexually assaulted, and every six hours, a young married woman dies due to
beating, burning, or suicide. It’s shocking to know that 28.4% of pregnant
women suffer from domestic violence. As a result of such violence, women face
social isolation, unemployment, loss of income, neglect of self-care, and
difficulties in childcare, which is a serious concern. According to the World
Health Organisation’s Multi-Country Study on Women’s Health and Domestic
Violence, between 40% and 60% of women surveyed in countries like Bangladesh,
Ethiopia, Peru, Samoa, Thailand, and Tanzania reported being physically and/or
sexually abused by their intimate partners.
5. Equality and Human Rights Commission[15]: In the year leading up to March 2020, statistics revealed that 1.6
million women in England and Wales had faced domestic abuse. During this time,
92% of those prosecuted for domestic abuse were men, and 77% of the victims
were women. Additionally, 618,000 women and girls between the ages of 16 and 74
had experienced sexual assault, including rape. In 2021, a review conducted by
Ofsted on sexual abuse in schools and colleges found that sexual
Harassment and online sexual abuse
are common and considered normal, which often means they are not reported.
6. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare[16]: India's National Family Health
Survey-III, conducted across 29 states during 2005–06, revealed alarming
findings about violence against married women. The survey found that a
significant number of married women had experienced physical or sexual abuse from
their husbands at some point in their lives. Nationally, 37.2% of women
reported experiencing this kind of violence after getting married.
In
Bihar, the situation was particularly severe, with the highest rate of abuse
against married women at 59%. Surprisingly, most of these incidents, 63%, were
reported by urban families rather than rural areas, which are often considered
more traditional or conservative. Following Bihar, other states with high rates
of abuse included Madhya Pradesh (45.8%), Rajasthan (46.3%), Manipur (43.9%),
Uttar Pradesh (42.4%), Tamil Nadu (41.9%), and West Bengal (40.3%).
7. National Coalition
against Domestic Violence[17] : About 1 in 4 women and 1 in 7 men have
experienced severe physical violence from a partner, like being beaten, burned,
or choked, at some point in their lives. Around 1 in 7 women and 1 in 18 men
have been stalked by a partner to the extent that they felt extremely scared or
believed they or someone close to them might be hurt or killed. Every day,
domestic violence hotlines across the country receive over 20,000 phone calls
for help.
Impact of Pandemic over crime rate against women: COVID-19
This phase of COVID was very tough
for the whole world. There were several problems faced by people in education,
employment, health, agriculture, etc. Everything was affected at a very high
pace. There was a global misbalance between the cycle of human life and
day-to-day activities. The most drastic effect was on people’s emotional and
physical health. The crime rate also increased. The graph of violations against
women rose to a high extent.
The pandemic has made the situation of violence against women and
girls (VAWG) pathetic. It has also shown and made worse large inequalities,
reversing many years of progress for women. working, made more women very
poor, and made unpaid care and housework much harder, all of which makes VAWG
worse. In 2021, since the pandemic began, 45% of women said they or a woman
they knew had VAWG. Seven in 10 women said they think verbal or physical abuse
by a partner has gotten more common. It was felt that sexual harassment in
public places has gotten worse[18].
According to data from the National Commission for Women, cases of
domestic violence (DV) increased by 2.5 times between February 27 and May 31.
During this period, the Commission received 1477 complaints related to DV. In
the months of April and May 2020, half (47.2%) of all cases reported to the NCW
were related to DV, compared to only about one-fifth (20.6%) during January to
March 2020[19].The
most common type is when someone says hurtful things (50%), followed by being
bothered in a sexual way (40%), hurting someone physically (36%), not letting
someone have what they need (35%), and stopping someone from talking to others
(30%). Seven in 10 women asked said they think violence against women happens a
lot where they live.
Women were affected:
·
Physically:
Detrition in health, lack of physical activity, isolation effect on body
·
Mentally:
depressed thoughts, lack of attention, inactivity of mind
·
Socially:
lack of communication, lack of interaction with nature
·
Economically:
loss of job, money-related issue
Factors responsible for growth of
crime against women during pandemic:
? Lockdowns and Isolation: Due to lockdown, people were just
confined in their homes, which was the major cause of the increase in domestic
violence and abuse. Women were often trapped with their abusers without access
to external support networks or safe spaces.
?
Economic Hardships: Most of the people lost their jobs during the pandemic, which created
economic pressure, reduced income, and financial instability that caused
tensions within households. This financial pressure on men led to increased
violence against women.
?
Disruption of Support Services: Essential services, including shelters and helplines, faced
disruptions or reduced capacity during lockdowns. This limited women’s ability
to seek help or escape abusive situations.
?
Increased Stress and Anxiety: The uncertainty and fear surrounding the pandemic, coupled
with social isolation, contributed to heightened stress levels among
individuals. Stress can escalate conflict and increase the likelihood of
abusive behaviour.
?
Digital Spaces and Cyber Violence: As more activities shifted online, women became more
vulnerable to cyber harassment, stalking, and online abuse. The anonymity of
digital platforms sometimes emboldens perpetrators to engage in harmful
behaviour.
?
Barriers to Legal Recourse: Court closures and delays in legal proceedings limited
women’s access to justice and protection orders. This hindered their ability to
seek legal recourse or obtain restraining orders against abusers.
?
Social Norms and Gender Inequality: Deep-rooted societal norms and gender inequalities
continued to perpetuate violence against women. The pandemic exacerbated these
inequalities, making it harder for women to challenge or escape abusive
situations.
The magnitude of crime in India given
by the National Record Bureau from 2009 to 2015 was drastic. There were a total
of 3,77,394 crimes against women in 2015 as compared to 2014. In 2016, Delhi
and Bangalore were the top places for reported crimes against women. Mumbai
comes next to Delhi in crime rate. Andhra Pradesh has reported the maximum
number of crimes. The zone of isolation faced by people because of the pandemic
turned human feelings, daily activities, and day-to-day life into a total mess,
which was the basic reason for physical, mental, and psychological
changes.
Does crime against men is recognized?
The ‘FACT’ that cannot be ignored is
that not only women are unsafe today but men too. There are cases where men are
also sexually harassed, but no such serious actions are taken towards that.
Most of the cases of such crimes against men remain unreported. And the major
reason is that society made them so uncomfortable that, because of this, they
refused to register their case. Discrimination is not just practiced with
women; men also face it by not getting the proper attention of the judiciary
for crimes against them. It should be given attention that gender-neutral
legations should be there.
Why do people have the stereotype that men can’t be raped, that sexual assault or domestic violence can’t be practiced with them? The perfect answer to this question is because men are always considered the criminals and women the victims. Because the definition in society of a victim is that the least powerful person or the weakest one is the victim, which can’t be a man because they are considered dominating and powerful. On this earth, nothing is planned; circumstances and situations can change at any time, and anyone can be the victim. India’s domestic violence laws pay more attention to protecting women than men. And this thing gives the false impression that men in society can just be criminals, not victims. According to the National Crime Bureau’s 2021 records, the number of cases of domestic violence against men by their intimate partners in India has increased. In this year, 33.2% of males committed suicide, and the major cause was an issue related to family, and 4.8% committed suicide due to a problem in their marital life. In the Lancet Regional Health report, it was found that the suicide rate of men is higher than that of women in the years 2014–2021. National Statistics figures (2022-2023) reported that men are one in three victims of domestic abuse (3.2%) and women (5.7%). Domestic abuse reported by police shows that 25% of the victims were men. Not only men, but women are also victims of gender-based violence.
Necessary amendments must be made in
the Domestic Violence Act of India for the benefit of men as well. There are
many cases in which women make false allegations against men. In such cases,
laws should be made for the protection of men. In India, rules that are
gender-neutral are necessary. There is a failure in legislation to accept
that men can also be victims of sexual violence and physical assault. Only one
law of the IPC, Section 377, talks about sexual violence against men, but only
penile sexual intercourse and not non-penile intercourse. The stereotype made
in society that “men don’t cry” should vanish. And create a perspective in
society so that people start seeing men as victims, not just criminals.
Crimes under Indian Penal Code, 1860
The Indian Penal Code (IPC) contains
several sections specifically dealing with crimes against women. These sections
address various forms of violence and discrimination. Here are some key
sections:
·
Section
354: Assaulting or using force against a woman to deliberately offend her
modesty
·
Section
354A: Sexual harassment and punishment for sexual harassment.
·
Section
354B: Assaulting or using force against a woman with the intent to undress her
·
Section
354C: Address Voyeurism
·
Section
354D: Stalking.
·
Section
375: Rape, including the detailed description of what constitutes rape and the
punishment for it.
·
Section
376: Punishment for rape, including life imprisonment and even the death
penalty in certain cases.
·
Section
498A: Husband or relative of husband of a woman subjecting her to cruelty,
often used in cases of domestic violence and dowry harassment.
·
Section
509: Word, gesture, or act intended to insult the modesty of a woman.
Crimes under Special laws
Apart Indian Penal Code there are
different laws incorporated for the protection of women and to address Crime
against them. These are some special laws in India:
·
The Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961, prohibits the giving
or receiving of dowry and penalises any associated acts of coercion and
harassment.
·
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act,
2005: Provides protection to women from domestic violence and allows for legal
recourse and support mechanisms for victims.
·
The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace
(Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013: Protects women from sexual
harassment at their place of work and outlines procedures for complaints and
redressal.
·
The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, prohibits
the marriage of girls below the age of 18 and boys below the age of 21 and aims
to prevent child marriages.
·
The Pre-Conception and Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques
(Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994: Prohibits sex selection before or after
conception and regulates the use of prenatal diagnostic techniques to prevent
female foeticide.
·
The Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition)
Act, 1986: Prohibits indecent representation of women through advertisements or
in publications, writings, paintings, figures, or in any other manner.
·
The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956, aims to
prevent human trafficking and prostitution and provides for the rehabilitation
of victims.
·
The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971: Allows
for the termination of certain pregnancies by registered medical practitioners
under specified conditions to ensure women’s health and rights.
·
The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, protects the
employment of women during their maternity and entitles them to maternity
benefits.
·
The Commission of Sati (Prevention) Act, 1987:
Prevents the practice of Sati (the burning or burying alive of widows) and
provides for the punishment of anyone promoting or glorifying the practice.
JUDICIAL PRONOUNCEMENTS
1. Laxmi v. Union of India (2014):
In this case, amendments were made to
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Section 357A was inserted by Act 5 of
2009.Compensation of Rs. 3,00,000 for every acid attack victim. In the IPC
(Indian Penal Code), Section 326A and Section 326B were added, which tell about
voluntarily causing hurt by the use of acid, etc., or an attempt to throw acid.
This action was taken because cases of acid attacks were increasing against
women in India.
2. Ritu Kholi Case (a
cyberbullying case):
Under
Section 509, this case was registered for destroying the modesty of a woman by means
of a gesture or action. An amendment was brought to the Information Technology
Act under Section 66E because Section 509 was not able to successfully deal
with the case.
3. Tukaram v. State of
Maharashtra, 1979:
In this case, the Supreme Court held that rape was not proven under
Section 375 of the IPC.
The reason was no evidence of body harm or any kind of threat and
changing of statement of victim several times.
In this case, the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1983 was passed.
Section 376 of the IPC was amended, and the punishment for custodial
rape was increased to 7 years.
4. Vishaka & Ors. V. State of Rajasthan 1997:
·
In
this case, the Supreme Court defined sexual harassment as direct or indirect
unwelcoming sexual action like demand or request of sex, verbal or non-verbal
sexual conduct, or physical contacts
·
Setting
up of Redressal mechanisms for complaints of sexual harassment at the workplace
was done.
·
Articles
14(2), 19(1)(g), and 21 of the Constitution emerged for the right to a safe
working environment.
·
Vishaka
Guidelines were passed, and it was said these will work until the real law is
framed.
·
‘Vishakha
guidelines ‘formed the basis for the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace
(Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013.
5. Mukesh
& Another vs State for NCT of Delhi 2017:
·
This
case was called by the Supreme Court ‘Rarest of the Rare Case’.
·
Enactment
of the Criminal Law Amendment 2013 was there.
·
Several
sections were added to Section 376 of the IPC (Indian Penal Code).
a. Amendment to what constitutes rape.
b. Section 376(2)(c) was added for rape
by personnel of the armed forces.
c. Section 376A, for death or vegetative
state because of rape.
d. Gang rape, Section 376D
e. Repetition of such offences will
cause life imprisonment or death.
f.
Clarification
on ‘penetration’ was given under rape.
Changes in IPC (Indian Penal Code):
- Section 166A was
added.
- Acid Attack, Section
326A & 326B was added.
- Sexual harassment
& Penal provisions were given under Section 354A.
- Offences of
Voyeurism were added under Section 354C.
- Staking was made an
offence under section 354D.
- The age of consent
was changed from 16 to 18 years.
6. State of
Punjab v/s. Gurmit Singh 1984:
In this case, there were interpretations of:
·
Section
118 of the Evidence Act 1872 can be paraphrased as follows: “All individuals
are eligible to testify unless the Court determines that they are unable to
comprehend the questions asked or to provide coherent answers due to young age,
advanced age, illness affecting either body or mind, or any similar condition.”
·
Section
363 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) can be rephrased as follows: “Anyone who
kidnaps a person from [India] or from lawful guardianship shall be punished
with imprisonment for a term extending up to seven years, along with a fine.”
·
Section
366 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) can be rewritten as follows: “Anyone who
kidnaps or compels a woman to marry or engage in any sexual activity shall be
punished with imprisonment for up to ten years and shall also be liable to pay
a fine. Similarly, anyone who induces a woman to leave any place knowing that
she is likely to be coerced or seduced into sexual intercourse with another
person shall be subject to the same penalties.”
·
Section
368 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) can be paraphrased as follows: “If anyone
unlawfully conceals or confines a kidnapped or abducted person, knowing that
the person has been kidnapped or abducted, they shall be punished as if they
had themselves kidnapped or abducted that person for the same purpose or with
the same knowledge or intention.”
·
Section
376 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) can be rephrased as follows: “Whoever
commits rape shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of not less than
seven years, which may extend to life or for a term up to ten years, and shall
also be liable to pay a fine, unless the victim of the rape is not younger than
the age of twelve years old and his own wife. In such cases, the punishment
shall be imprisonment for a term that may extend to two years, a fine, or both.
·
In
this case, the significance of the rape victim’s testimony was underscored. The
case revolved around the abduction and rape of a minor girl by three men.
Despite perceived inconsistencies in the victim’s testimony and the absence of
corroborating evidence, the trial court acquitted the accused.
CONCLUSION
In my opinion every living being
whether it is men, women, animals etc. Has the perpetual rights and duties as
guaranteed by our constitution. “Nothing is above the law” is the phrase used
commonly because no one can supersede the law. Crime is exercised everywhere in
the world with different ratio against men, women and even animals. In
conclusion, the citizens must be aware of the offences and crime and their
rights for protection against them. Even if 50 per cent of the people out of
hundred are illiterate still the basic knowledge of these things should be
given to them. Different boot camps, programs, nukad must be constituted by the
government and the NGO’s for spreading awareness. Most of the victims of
heinous crime are the people who are not aware or are illiterate, they are the
soft targets of the criminals. And the base of this article is about gender,
first step must be that the stereotypes related to women in the society shall
be disregarded. The thought process of the patriarchal generation should be
moulded in such a way that they consider women as equal and powerful to them.
The past can’t be change but the present and future can, so focus on the youth
for this development to be inaugurated. Their minds should not be manipulated
with wrong perspective about women than only they can bring change in the
society.
The women
those who do not do jobs and are homemaker, are also the victims of crime at
their home itself. Initiatives should be taken for the protection of these
women those who are disconnected with the outer world. And cannot raise their
voice for justice.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books Referred-
- Handbook on Sexual
Harassment of Women at workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal)
Act,2013 by Government of India, Ministry of Women and Child Development
- Criminal law case and
materials (AUTHOR: KD Gaur)
Reference links:
[1] [Un Women Facts and figure: Ending
violence against women],
[https://www.unwomen.org/en/what-we-do/ending-violence-against-women/facts-and-figures](
last visited July 8, 2024)
[2][International Day for the
Elimination of Violence against Women],
[ https://www.un.org/en/observances/ending-violence-against-women-day
](last visited July 7, 2024)
[3][UNDRR:Violence],[https://www.undrr.org/understanding-disaster-risk/terminology/hips/so0006
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[4][United Nations: Office on Genocide
prevention],
[ https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/crimes-against-humanity.shtml
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[5][NIH, National Library of
Medicine],
[ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4958928/
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[6][United Nations Human Rights: Declaration of Basic Principles of Justice for Victims of Crime
and Abuse of Power],[https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/declaration-basic-principles-justice-victims-crime-and-abuse ](last visited July 9, 2024)
[7][Un Women: Ending Violence against Women],[
https://www.unwomen.org/en/what-we-do/ending-violence-against-women/ ](last visited July 9, 2024)
[8][Times of India],[ https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/books/features/the-biggest-perpetrator-of-domestic-violence-is-silence-meghna-pant-on-toxic-relationships-and-abuse/articleshow/98359791.cms
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[9][Global Organized Crime Index:
Human Trafficking],[ https://ocindex.net/crime/human_trafficking ](last visited July 9, 2024)
[10][UNHCR: Global law],[ https://www.refworld.org/legal/resolution/unga/2003/en/12969
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[11][United Nations Human Rights],[ https://www.ohchr.org/en/stories/2021/07/female-genital-mutilation-can-be-stopped-says-hc
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[12][News Click: Crime against women in
India],[ https://www.newsclick.in/crime-against-women-india-4-ncrb-report-2023 ](last
visited July 9, 2024)
[13][World Health Organization: Violence
against women],[ https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/violence-against-women ](last
visited July 9, 2024)
[14][PAHO: Pan American Health
Organization],[ https://www.paho.org/en/topics/violence-against-women
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[15][Equality and Human Rights Commission],[
https://humanrightstracker.com/en/progress-assessment/violence-against-women-and-girls-uk-government-assessment/
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[16][National Family Health Survey India],[ https://rchiips.org/nfhs/nfhs3.shtml ](last visited July 9, 2024)
[18][Un Women: Facts and figures:
Ending violence against Women],[ https://www.unwomen.org/en/what-we-do/ending-violence-against-women/facts-and-figures#83919
](last visited July 9, 2024)
[19][India-1-aman-globalvoic: Call for
submissions: COVID-19 and the increase of domestic violence against women],[ https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2022-01/India-1-aman-globalvoic.docx#:~:text=According%20to%20data%20shared%20by,Commission%20received%201477%20DV%20complaints.
](Last visited July 9, 2024)