ANALYSIS OF ESSENTIALS OF MARRIAGE UNDER MUSLIM LAW BY - DEEKSHA UPADHYAY
ANALYSIS OF ESSENTIALS OF MARRIAGE
UNDER MUSLIM LAW
AUTHORED BY
- DEEKSHA UPADHYAY
INTRODUCTION
Islamic Lawis defined in india as “personal laws of muslim applied by the
portion of islamic civil law”. muslim marriage law is very different from that
of any other personal law. marriage
is also known as nikah. the history of nikah was very much men dominating. In
pre islamic arabia, sexual relations between
a male and a female
based on various
terms was known as
NIKAH. women were treated as property, they didnt had any
inheritance right and were
always dependent upon men.
Prophet mohammad was the person
who changed this practise and position of women. he brought
equality among men and women in matter of performing legal powers and functions. the real meaning of
nikah is sexual relationship between
a muslim man and woman. but now it is use to refer to the contract that make relationship lawful.
Marriage under muslim law is in simple words a contract.i. The creation
and legalization of children is the primary goal of this treaty. "Marriage
is an institution ordained for the preservation of society, and in order that human beings may shield themselves from foulness and
unchastity," Ameer Ali quotes an ancient scripture as saying.
A marriage does not require any formality or religious ceremony. Marriage
under Islam is contract, hence all of the customary prerequisites for a legal
contract must be met. Thus, under Muslim law, the main requirements
for a lawful marriage are the competence to contract marriage, the proposal and
acceptance of the marriage, and the lack of any barrier to the marriage. At the time of the marriage, three witnesses must be present.
Marriage is categorized into three forms under
Islamic law: sahih marriage, which means legitimate marriage, batil marriage, which
means void marriage, and fasid marriage, which
indicates irregular marriage.
1. capacity for marriage
2. offer and acceptance
3. free consent
and will
4. No legal disability
5. A consideration
6. witnesses
The aim or objective of marriage in muslims are - procreation of child, union between parties and promotion
of love. Many muslim philosphers says that
marriage is nothing but a religious duty. for fulfillment for his/her
desire and procreation of children marriage
is very necessary. the husband has the
responsibility to provide maintenance to his wife and children. The wife is
entitled to Dower or Mahr, a sum of money or other property from the husband as
a mark of respect for the wife.
Literature review-
A.
ARTICLE
REVIEW
1. Marriage
Agreements Under Muslim Law - A Weapon in the Hands of Muslim Women
In this article the writer has highlighted how muslim marriage which is a contractual
marriage helps and empowers women. marriage agreement work as a weapon for
muslim women. the agreement should be valid and not illegal, the writer has
stated several points which explains in what cases an agreement can become [1]void.
the muslim matrimonial conditions helps women
in many uncertain situation of marital
life, like the power to get divorce
is only with the men unless it is delegated to women which can be
done by agreements, wife can make a
condition that the husband will not marry to other woman, wife can get
protection during the married life and after
the dissolution also for example through agreements she can get maintenance after dissolution of
marriage etc.
According to the author the future of women is in hands of matrimonial
agreement as now the women can make changes
in the marriage according to her and can lead a
happy life during or after the marriage.
2. Cousin Marriage Is Not Choice: Muslim Marriage and Underdevelopment
In this article the author tells us about the under developments and
loopholes in muslim marriage law. just like other articles relating to muslim
marriage law this article also states the topic of unequality amongst men and
women. it is stated that men have free will and choice of marriage but it is just opposite
for the muslim women. this paper
is talking about
3 points. To begin,
it contends that,
notwithstanding men's freedom to marry, traditional Muslim family law generates a consent structure
that equates to parental consent. As a result, the regime favours the elderly
over the younger generations. The second argument is about cousin marriages.it
tells the reason that why cousin marriages are
common in muslim law. third point is that this marriage system practised by
muslims can affect the economic growth.
So all these things are
discussed in a detailed manner
in this article and at the
end it concludes that all these
points result in deprivation of women’s fundamental rights.
3. Some Legal Aspects of Muslim Marriage
in Indian Sub-Continent-A [2]Review
In this article
legal aspects of muslim law is discussed. The author is at first differentiating between nikah and
muslim law marriage as nikah means a sexual[3] relationship between
man and woman
whereas muslim law marriage has a very definite
legal meaning. the article
deals with the legal aspects
of legal muslim
marriage and how far it has been affected by judiciary
and legislation decisions. The article is divided in four parts comprising of- Firstly
legal competency which tells that puberty and sound mind are two main and basic
aspects of competency of marriage. Second part deals with registration. the
validity of marriage does not
depend upon registration but non registration of marriage will create doubt in future.
third part is about consummation of marriage, in this part the
author has talked about several laws related to age limits and child marriages.
last but not least fourth part talks
about presumption of marriage. many times it happens that a question arises
over the validity of the marriage and in absence of direct proof some
presumptions are made.at the end
the author has concluded by briefly discussing
about all the acts and provisions which the author
have talked about
like family ordinance act, guardians and wards act etc.
4. Muslim Family Law in South Asia: the Right to Avoid an Arranged Marriage Contracted During
Minority
The presence of a guardian is very
important in case of marriage with a
minor. For the guardian's negotiated and contracted matrimonal union to be
legally solemnised, neither the minor's assent
nor presence is required.this article talks about this situation
and the rights to avoid the marriage
done during minority of either husband or wife or both, it also talks about who
all can be guardians and who are not eligible to be a guardian. the author also talks about the difference between hanafi and shia muslims in case
of minor marriages.in Hanafi law a marriage guardian other
than the father or the
paternal grandfather may contract the minor in a marriage which is valid and
binding until the minor after attaining the age of majority decides to come out
of the marriage and in case of
shia muslims only father and paternal grandfather can be
a guardian and other than them
on one else can be. judicial interpretation of 1939 provision in pakistan and
india is also mentioned by the author. The indian courts strictly dealt with it
and hence muslim marriage law in india is lot more stricter and opposing of the
ones in pakistan.
B. BOOK REVIEW
The Essentials of Islamic Marriage By
Sheikh Muhammed Rif'at 'Uthman-
This book talks about the essential ingredients of a marriage discussed in detail with the help of different case laws it also includes marriage
proposal, it tells when to make the proposal, how to make proposal and what is unlawful proposal. the idea of
offer and acceptance is explained Additionally, it outlines the foundations of marriage and the obligations that a couple has to one another. Sheikh
Muhammed Rif' at 'Uthman, who also wrote other novels, is the author. He is
well recognised among Muslims for being a Sharia law expert instructor.
According to this book, marriage is the union of men and women. It revitalises
the soul and fosters mutual intimacy
between the pair through companionship. he explained the essence
and essentials of marriage, also different types of marriages are also
mentioned in this book. the author concluded his book by giving an idea about what a happy marriage is
like and how to maintain a proper happy and perfect marital life.
C. REPORTS-
Rashida Khatoon
vs S.K. Islam, AIR 2005
In this case, a man promised a lady to marry her. The lady believed him
and had sexual intercourse, after sometimes a the lady gave
birth to a child. the lady asked the court to give her the status of wife. the lady claimed that he promised her to marry and she accepted it so there was an offer as well as
acceptance. the question rose before the courth that whether a mere promise
will amount to marriage in muslim law
The odisha high court stated that -In
order for a marriage to be valid, it must
first be proposed by one of the parties or
on their behalf, and then accepted by the other party or on their behalf in front of
two men or one man and two women witnesses, both of whom must be
responsible, mature Muslims. A marriage cannot be legally constituted by a proposal made
at one meet up and an acceptance made at another meet
up; both must be made at the
same gathering. Writing or
participating in a religious ritual are not necessary. The court held that
since there was absence of offer or acceptance to marry but only a mere
assurance that he will marry her in coming future and hence Simply living together
under such a guarantee will not confer
married status on the lady.
Abdul Ahad vs
Shah Begum
The facts of the case is that a minor girl of age 14 years was given into a marriage
with a major man.at initial time of marriage the man used to live in the girl’s house and later he decided to take
his wife back to his house. the parents of the girl refused to send her and
filed a suit for restitution of conjugal rights against the husband.
The high court of jammu and kashmir held that - when the marriage was
solemnized the girl was a minor and her consent was not valid instead the consent was giver by her wali
who was not competent enough to send
her in marriage as he was not a guardian and it was not quite clear that he has
the guardianship to give minor girl to marriage.
STATEMENT OF PROBLEMS-
1.
unequal position of women as compared to men, every muslim men has many priviledges over women like in the matter of marriage contracts, divorce,inheritence etc
2.
Mahr which means dower. It is not practically possible
for a wife to demand
her dower and maintain cordial
relations with her husband for a long period of time.
3.
Muslim law believes
that when a person reaches
the age of his or her puberty
that person is eligible for marriage but it is not necessary that they will attain
maturity at that age.
HYPOTHESIS
1. The
essential condition of free will and consent is not exercised as strictly
as it should be.
2. Muslim men
and women both should have equal rights and powers
3. The consent
of guardians of the bride is not necessary as the
girl should have their own
right to decide and choose and is not supposed to be backed up by someone
else's consent.
4. In future the status of
women in matter of muslim marriages will enhance.
OBJECTIVES
1. To get a glimpse of history
of nikah
2. To understand the essentials of marriage under muslim law
3. To understand the types of marriages under muslim law
4. To get more knowledge about contractual marriage
5. To observe the changes
happened in muslim
marriage laws.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The Method Used For The Research
By The Researcher Is Doctrinal.
The researcher utilized existing data or facts in the study and examined
them to generate a critical assessment of the sources.In order to understand a
wide variety of problems, the researcher includes a detailed analysis and
evaluation of the data that is already available.
By evaluating the facts or information already
available with the use of books, articles, journals, and blogs. The
research is largely concerned with testing hypotheses as well as defining and interpreting
the topic.
TENTATIVE CHAPTERISATION
This research paper contains 6 chapters
which details about this topic more specifically
The first chapter is the history of NIKAH.
This chapter
tells us about the origin of muslim marriage
laws and how it has evolved
over time.
The second chapter is the types of marriage in muslim marriage law This chapter
talks about different types
and forms of muslim
marriages.
The Third chapter is the essentials of marriage
This chapter
mainly talks about what are the essentials
of marriage in muslim law in detail.
The fourth chapter is rights and duties of spouses
This chapter breifly discuss the duties of married muslim man and woman
The fifth chapter is drawbacks of essentials of marriage under muslim law
This chapter
deals with some drawbacks which are there in the essentials of marriage
The sixth chapter is suggestions and conclusions.
This chapter
at last suggests the perspective of the researcher on this topic and concludes the purpose of doing
this research
ABSTRACT-
In the past years nikah was a purely male dominated practice which
changed over years and years. and now nikah is defined as-The original meaning of the
term "nikah" was the physical
union of a man and a woman. It is also used in a secondary context to relate to
the marriage contract which guarantees the legitimacy of the partnership. Marriage
is a relation which has a highly
honoured place in Islamic
ethical and legal system.
Islam defines marriage as asrehmat
(sympathy), sukun (peace of mind) and muaddat (love). According to Islamic law, marriage is a civil
contract that must have the voluntary assent of both parties in order to be
fulfilled. Marriage under muslim law is a contractual marriage in which both the
parties has to abide by certain essential ingredients of muslim marriage
which includes mainly offer and acceptance, competency, prohibition of several
disabilities, dower etc.
There are many characteristics of Marriage under
muslim law, it is a very strict as well as lenient
structure, in simple words there are
certain provisions which need to be strictly followed and there are some basic
practices which are usually followed in other
religions but not in muslim law like having 4 wifes
at the same time. the
essentials of muslim marriage is very same to that
of civil contract thats why it is often called as civil contract. the main
objectives of muslim marriage are to legalize sexual relationship and
procreation of child.
In this research, the researcher aims to study the essentials of marriage
in detail along with giving emphasize on different types
of marriage in muslim laws,it
also talks about
what is nikah and the origin of nikah, it briefly
discusses about the duty, rights and responsibilities of bride and groom, it
highlights drawbacks of essentials of marriage under muslim law.
CHAPTER-1
NIKAH
HISTORY-
Before the seventh century, women were not treated as equally as men. they
were married against their will and were treated as an object. but all this
practise changed when prophet muhammad came and by ther quaran which he
revealed in study of islam. As per him force marriage was no more permitted,
both husband and wife had to give their consent in order to enter into a marital tie.This
was a very huge change in the islamic tradition. and through this phase the
real interpretation of nikah was introduced to the world.
In order to ensure that the bride
is not forced and she has given her consent
for the marriage, the system of witness was adopted. If the ceremony is
segregated, the wali, or male guardian, is still responsible for making sure
that the bride accepts the marriage before they proceed with the marriage
contract. During nikah, at least two male witnesses are required to be present to observe the ceremony.
The bride price, or the mahr, was traditionally provided to the father
during the Nikah in exchange for his daughter's hand in marriage. As a result of a change in custom, the gift is now
handed to the bride directly to ensure her future security in the marriage.
WHAT IS NIKAH?
A religious ceremony done by the islamic law for the union of a muslim
man and woman is known as nikah.this ceremony is very important
among muslims as it holds a very
prestigious place among many families even if they are more tilted
towards the western culture.
Bringing newly wedded couples before allah is the main objective of
nikah. during the ceremony, the
couples will stand in front of the ceremony leader who is known as imam, and they have to say “i accept”
three times in order to show the acceptance to the witnesses and people present
at the ceremony. after this, they have to give their signature in the marriage
contract and then they are officially announced as bride and groom.
At the time of nikah,
two men witnesses will ensure that both husband
and wife has given their consent. The marriage is not
possible without the free and express approval of the parties. also both parties
have to agree for the mahr (a gift of money or anything to the
bride.).now a days, rings are used as mahr but it can be anything that the
wife wants keeping in mind the
income and affordability of her husband. during nikah, the bride and groom also
have to give a brief sermon and read from the holy quran.
There is a difference between marriage and nikah. Many people get
confused between these two terms. Nikah is the religious
ceremony that unites
a male and female, both the man and lady
are announced to be officially wedded couple at the end of nikah ceremony.
The partnership which the islamic couples enter is marriage but nikah
makes it official. after the nikah ceremony, it is hard for either of the party
to seek divorce as it becomes very complicated under muslim law. the legal
contract that man and woman enters into by giving their consent for marriage is
nikah.
Chapter -2
Muslim marriage- civil contract or sacrament
Marriage under muslim law is treated as both- a religous duty and a civil
contract by muslim jurists.many anglo- muhammdan authors have defined it as
a civil contract maybe because of characteristics of muslim or by the influence of modern conception of marriage maybe because
of characteristics of muslim marriage.as per them the precoess of marriage is
purely civil contact and not a
sacrament as contract gets completed
by offer and acceptance and the
same happens in muslim marriage.so they were interpretting muslim marriage as
civil law on the basis of similarity between the two.for
example- a marriage
involves an offer (ijab) from a side and an acceptance (qubul) from the
other. Marriage also needs a free
consent and sound mind from both parties.
Within the bounds
of the law, the conditions of marriage can also be modified
to suit particular circumstances. Additionally, it may be ended by the[6]
declaration of talaq.
Although some passages from the Quran are typically recited to mark the occasion, the Muhammadan law does not
expressly mandate any special services.
Another view is that marriage is a religious sacrament too.this point of
view is supported by judiciary as well.according to religious aspects islamic
marriage is an ibaddat(devotional
act).the prophet said that-"O gathering
of youngsters, anyone
among you is able to have should marry because it is a restraint on the appearance, and he
who is not able let him hold fast."
Justice
mahmood has stated-“Although it is
typically solemnised with the reading of a few verses from the Quran,
marriage is not a sacrament among Muslims; rather, it is only a legal contract, and according to
Muhammedan law, there is no ceremony that is specifically prescribed for the
occasion.” as per him muslim marriage is dependent upon offer and
acceptance by parties.in the above mentioned statement he has clearly stated
that muslim marriage is purely a
civil contract. he supported his statement
by mentioning that the dower in islamic marriage can be considered as
consideration which is a very important essential of a civil contract.
"We feel that we are not wrong
if we remark that there is an unfounded general perception that
a Muslim marriage is only a legal transaction pure and simple and has no
religious value or social importance linked to
it," it was said in the
case of Amina v. Koye.
The sacramental aspect of marriage is supported by the judiciary even if it is frequently seen as an
orthodox concept. In the landmark case of Anis
Begum v. Mohammad Istafa, Chief Justice Sir Shah Sulaiman attempted to present a more unbiased view of Muslim marriage by defining it as both a
civil contract and a religious sacrament.
As per Dr.Jung:
“Marriage, while basically a
contract, is also a devotional act with the goals of regulating social life in the interest of society and granting spouses the
right to enjoy each other's
company and have children.”
The last point is that marriage in Islam is frequently referred to as
neither entirely a civil contract nor a sacrament. Nothing but the merging of
the two can be found there.
Chapter- 3
TYPES OF MARRIAGES
The marriage contract's conclusion determines whether a marriage is
lawful or invalid. A contract can be made orally or in writing;it is not
necessary that the contract should be in writing only. The following are the
various forms of marriages:
Temporary marriage
(Muta marriage)
While all other islamic
sects forbid this kind of union, the Ithna Ashari of the Shia sect engage
in what is known as a "pleasure marriage." Ithna male is
allowed to have as many wives as he wants,
provided as they are all Muslims, Jews, or fire worshipers; however, Ithna
female is limited to only marrying Muslims.
All of the marriage's conditions must be disclosed
when the contract is signed;
any condition added later is invalid.
Features of muta marriage
?
Contract must be present
?
Offer and acceptance must be there between bride and groom
?
Dower should be decided at the time of
contract
?
Time period of nikah
must be specified, hours/days/weeks/months/years, if time period is not
given then the marriage will be considered as permanent.
?
There shouldn't be any
reciprocal inheritance between
the parties.
?
Unless and until stated in a contract,
the woman is not liable for maintenance.
?
The woman is entitled
to half of the
dower if the marriage is not consummated, and the full dower if it is.
?
The woman must observe Idda/Iddat in the event of marriage
consummation.
?
The man has the right to decline
procreation even without
the wife's consent.
?
Offspring are considered to be legitimate children
since they are entitled to inherit the assets of both parents.
?
If not prolonged, a Muta marriage
terminates when the duration of the union specified in the contract expires.
Permanent marriages
The different
types of marriages under this are-
(I)Sahih (valid)
marriage
A nikah between two people that satisfies all legal requirements is referred to as a Sahih (valid) marriage. Both the Shia and Sunni
sects approve of this kind of union.
Features of Sahih (valid) marriage
?
At the celebrations, the status of the husband
and wife is noted.
?
Between both parties, there is a mutual right to inheritance.
?
If a
marriage is broken for whatever reason—death, divorce, etc.—then the husband is forbidden - marriage with wife’s sister.
?
It grants children
born outside of this
marriage a status of
legitimacy.
?
The marriage contract
may include any terms and obligations in addition to those listed above, provided they do not conflict with Islamic law or with any other public policy.
(II) Batil (void) marriage
It is still referred to as a Batil (void)
nikah when there
is a violation of either
absolute or relative obstacles during the performance
of the marriage. Although both parties have completed the required steps for
marriage, it is still referred to as a marriage. Due to the partners' complete
incapacity to marry one another and the absence of any legal conditions
outlined in Muslim law that could render their marriage valid, this sort of
marriage is void. Both Sunni and Shia sects approve of this kind of union.
Features of Batil (void)
marriage
?
It is not treated
as a marriage because no legal rights and duties result from it.
?
The parties do not affirm their position as husband and wife.
?
This type of marriage results
in illegitimate children.
?
Without committing the crimes of polygamy and bigamy,
both couples are able to get married
again.
Fasid (irregular) marriage
Fasid (irregular) marriage is defined as a marriage that is performed in
contravention of a relative impediment. Although the marriage is not valid and not void, it can be made
valid by removing the relative hindrance (irregularity). Both the Shia and
Sunni sects approve of this kind of union, with the exception of the Itna Asari school of the former.
? It remains
in effect until and unless it is terminated by law.
? Both the wife and the kids are liable for
maintenance.
? When the marriage is confirmed, it becomes legal.
? The marriage
may be dissolved at any
time by either the husband or the woman.
? In the event of a husband's
death or a divorce, the wife must observe Idda/Iddat.
? Children born outside of marriage are totally
legitimate and entitled
to inherit.
? There is no right to joint inheritance between a husband and wife.
CHAPTER-4
ESSENTIALS OF MARRIAGE
1.
Offer and Acceptance-
In islamic marriage, proposal is called
as ijab and acceptance is called as qubul.an offer is made by one party and accepted by the other party. The offer
and acceptance as an essential
covers some other aspects
also. first of all, it is necessary for the offer and acceptance to be done at the same time.if an offer is made at another time and the acceptance is done at some other time it is not treated
as valid. the acceptance should be reciprocated to the offer.
As discussed above, witnesses are very
important. under sunni law two male or one male and two female witnesses are required. If witnesses are not present then the marriage will
become irregular. In shia law witness is not required during marriage but at
the time of divorce.
Both the husband and the wife must have free will and consent.
and it should be free from any deception, fear, or improper
influence. The nikah will not be regarded
as legal unless
and until the boy or girl's
legal guardian gives their approval
if they have not reached
puberty. the consent can be
either-implied or expressed. if at the time of giving consent any of the party
is merely smiling, laughing or is silent then it will be considered as implied
consent. The girl's consent must be given freely in order for the marriage to
be legal, and the father's consent does not serve as a replacement for the girl's
consent. In Sayad Mohiuddin v. Khatijabai, the court
ruled that the marriage
of a Shafei girl who had reached
puberty and was married by her father
against her will was invalid.
2.
Competent parties-
It is necessary for both parties to be able to comprehend the purpose of
marriage and to be capable of entering into a contract. Simply put, they should
be capable of entering into matrimony. A Muslim
who has attained
puberty and is of sound mind may do
so. The wife and husband
must both be able to comprehend the
nature of their conduct. Except in the
instance when it is contracted when the mad person was normal for a while, a
marriage that a lunatic enters into is null and void. However,
if the guardians of the mad person
enter into the marriage,
it is lawful.
Puberty is another important element to know the competency of the
parties. The Indian majority act does not apply to the Indian muslims. the age
after which a person can get in a sexual relationship or is capable od performing sexual intercourse and giving birth to child is puberty. muslim law considers
puberty and majority as same.it presumes that the age of majority of any person
is 15 but the hedaya law opposes this and lays down that tha age of majority for boys is 12
and for girls it is 9.in case of
shia muslims, the age of puberty
of female begins with menstruation.in the case of Sadiq Ali Khan vs Jai Kishori,
the privy council held that the age of mojirty for girls in
shia law is 9 years.
*it should be noted that until it is approved after the age of majority,
marriages of minors without a Guardian's consent are void. When a boy or girl
reaches puberty, they are free to marry whoever they choose, and the Guardian
has no authority to intervene. According to Sunni law, the father, paternal
grandfather, if any, the brother,
and other male relatives listed in the chart of residuaries, the maternal uncle,
mother or aunt, and the other maternal relations without the prohibited degrees,
and lastly, the state
have the right to contract to give a minor in marriage.
Dower
It is also known as ‘mahr’. this is the
money or any other property gives as
a consideration to the marriage by the groom to the bride .for the purpose of
financial security during and after the marital tie,it
is given. In case of Nasra Begum
v. Rizwan ali, AllahAbad High court decided that before cohabitation the mahr
should be given. And if bride is a minor, her parents or guardians have the choice to refuse to send her to
husband until full payment of mahr,
and she can be brought back as well if shes living with her husband.
3.
No legal disability-
Under some circumstances marriage is not permitted; it is known as legal
disability. These circumstances are
called prohibition which have been classified
into 4 classes-
?
Absolute prohibition
?
Relative prohibition
?
Prohibitory prohibition
?
Directory prohibition
Absolute prohibition- it comprises consanguinity, affinity and fosterage.
1. Consanguinity- it is also known as qurabat.
Every blood relationships are included under this-
a.
his mother or grandmother
b.
His sister-
full blood, consanguine or uterine
d.
His aunt and great
aunt
e.
His niece or great niece
A marriage prohibited because of the above mentioned blood relations of
the person is void and any issue arising from it are illegitimate.
2 Affinity- it is also known as mushaarat. Prohibited relationships of a man
under this are-
a.
His wife’s daughter
or granddaughter
b.
His wife’s mother or grand mother
c.
Wife of his son or son’s son or daughter’s son
d. Wife of his father
or paterna; grandfather
A lady who is barred
from marriage because
of affinities cannot
be married. Only if the marriage to the wife was completed is it forbidden
to get married to the wife's daughter or granddaughter.
Relative incapacity-
Relative incapacity only arises from situations when the marriage is declared
unlawful or irregular while the underlying cause is still present. Once
it is gone, the marriage loses its validity
and becomes legally
binding. As a result, it is distinct
from the situation of extreme incapacity, in which
the nikah is void ab initio and never can be made lawful. the following are the
relative incapacity-
1. Unlawful
conjunction-it includes the cases when a man marries two women who are related to each other
by blood or consanguinity or affinity.
hence he cant marry two sisters or niece and her aunt. This restriction
is in place to prevent confusion with kinship or a dual connection. However,
this restriction may be lifted if he
divorces his first wife or after her passing. According to Shia law, a Muslim
may wed his wife's aunt but not her niece without her consent. Under Shia Law, a marriage
that is forbidden due to an illegal
union is void; yet, under Sunni Law, it is deemed irregular
and void.
2. Absence of
proper witness-It is necessary for both parties to be able to comprehend the
purpose of marriage and to be capable of entering into a contract. Simply put,
they should be capable of entering into matrimony. A Muslim who has attained
puberty and is of sound mind may do so. The wife and
husband must both be able to comprehend the nature of their conduct. Except in
the instance when it is contracted when the mad person was normal for a while,
a marriage that a lunatic enters into is null and void. However, if the
guardians of the mad person enter into the marriage, it is lawful.
3. marrying a fifth
wife or polygamy- it is
illegal to bring fifth
wife in the marital tie that
consists of 4 wifes for mohammedans. for sunnis it is considered as irregular
marriage but this irregularity can be removed if the husband gives divorce to one of his four wives.
however, marriage with fifth wife is completely void under shia law.
4. Different religion-
a sunni boy can marry muslim girl or a kitabia
only.
5. Women
undergoing iddat- under shia law the marriage between a male and a female who
is undergoing iddat is void but in sunni law it is irregular and not void.
Prohibitory incapacity-
It happens due to following
reasons-
1.
Polyandry- A lady
who has more than one husband is said to be polyandrous. As long as the first
man is still living or the marriage is still in effect, it is against Islamic
law for women to get married a second time. A Muslim lady will be held
responsible and charged under Section 494 of the IPC if she marries again.
2.
Muslim woman if marries
a non muslim man even though he is a christian or a jew,
the marriage is void under shia law and irregular under sunni law.
Directory
incapacity-
1.
Marrying a pregnant woman- it is illegal to marry a
woman who is carrying the child of former husband in her womb.
2.
Prohibition of divorce-Re-union is not permitted once a marriage is dissolved by three decrees of
divorce, unless the woman is lawfully
wed to another man and the
union is dissolved after consummation.
3.
Marriage during pilgrimage- Shia law declares
marriages contracted while on pilgrimage invalid. Marriage occurring on a
pilgrimage to Mecca within the holy
city was viewed as unlawful by the Shafeis,
Malikis, and Hanabalis. However, the Hannafis regarded such unions as legal.
4.
Marriage with a
sick man- if a man is suffering from serious disease then the
marriage is invalid but if he gains recovery andthe marriage is consummated then it is valid.
Chapter - 5
Rights and obligations of spouses
In Islam, both men and women have rights over one another
when they engage into a marriage contract,
with the husband typically acting as
the family's protector and financial
backer. For both partners, there are two components to this guardianship:
One interpretation is that the husband must shoulder the financial
responsibility of providing for the shelter, food, clothes and other
requirements of his spouse or spouses and any children they may bear. In exchange, the wife has a
responsibility to protect her partner's money and possessions. She is free to hold property and assets on her own, and the husband has no claim to them until she grants him permission to do so, therefore if the woman is affluent
on her own, she is not
obligated to surrender it to the husband or children..In the mahr, which the husband gives to the wife for her sole use
and which is included in his
financial responsibilities, there is a premarital agreement about the financial
expectations from the husband.
According to a number of observers, a husband's dominance over his wife
is contingent, and the wife's obedience is equally constrained.
Women are also reminded that getting a divorce is not stigmatized if the husband
is not carrying out his obligations. Reiterated in the Quran, justice
for women involves emotional support. Men are also reminded that women cannot
be denied their mahr or bridal gifts until they are found guilty
of sexual immorality. Some husbands will put pressure
on their wives and demand the return of what they gave her
in situations where the arrangement was to defer the payment of the mahr in order to agree
to the breakup of the marriage.The husband does not have the right to take his wife's possessions in exchange for her freedom
from him if he has been abusive or careless with his duties. Even though the Quran commands: "Go before the court and submit
to binding arbitration," most couples regrettably choose not to do so.
Conclusion-
Muslim personal law describe marriages as being more like a legal
contract than a sacrament. Muslim scholars regard a marriage governed by
Mohammedan law to be essential because they see it as a relationship created to
fulfil each other's needs.in todays time
not only muslims of asia but muslim
all over the world follow this culture inspite of living in western culture.
Most of the muslims who live in western world still respect and abide by the rules
and regulations of it. The essentials of marriage are mostly similar to that of
a civil contract so many
scholars believe it to
be purely a civil contract but other scholars think it as a
sacrament as the prophet said that one who will not get married are
not his followers. So this argument
came to end by stating that it
is both a civil contract and a sacrament.
The essentials of muslim marriage
has many drawbacks
as stated in the paper. the status of women has increased alot but it is still not equal to
that of men. the codification of muslim laws, polygamy etc theses all issues
make the muslim marriage laws somehow
unreliable, but one should never forget the main essentials of marriage. If a
person follows the essentials of marriage and always follows
his marital duties
then he can lead to a happy
life. This is the
reason why people living in different
parts of the world still
believe in islamic marriage laws and follow it with good faith.
For the betterment of muslim women in future and for removing
the remaining aspects of muslim marriage which often
gets criticed, the judiciary and legislative authority should continue making
changes in the laws and customary practices for the good.