Open Access Research Article
FROM POLICY TO PRACTICE ASSESSING INDIAS ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND THEIR REAL WORLD IMPLICATIONS
Published Paper
Article Details
FROM POLICY TO PRACTICE: ASSESSING
INDIA’S ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND THEIR
REAL-WORLD IMPLICATIONS
AUTHORED BY - SARTHAK BORA &
NAKSHATRA DAPSE
INTRODUCTION
Environmental law in India is a
complex and evolving field that aims to protect the environment and promote
sustainable development. The Constitution of India recognizes the right to a
clean environment as a fundamental right, and it is based on principles such as
the polluter pays principle, the precautionary principle, and the sustainable
development principle. Enforcement is carried out by agencies like the Central
Pollution Control Board (CPCB), State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs), and the
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change.
Recent years have seen a growing
awareness of environmental protection in India, leading to the enactment of new
laws and regulations. The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Amendment
Act, 2016, introduced stricter standards for air emissions, and the Plastic
Waste Management Rules, 2022, banned the use of certain single-use plastic
items.
However, there are still challenges
in enforcing environmental laws in India. The CPCB and SPCBs are often
understaffed and underfunded, making it difficult to enforce laws effectively.
Additionally, there is a lack of public awareness about environmental laws and
regulations. Despite these challenges, environmental law in India is playing a
crucial role in protecting the environment and promoting sustainable
development.
MAJOR ENVIRONMENT LAW STATUTES:
• THE ENVIRONMENT
(PROTECTION) ACT, 1986
The Environment (Protection) Act, of
1986 is a comprehensive environmental legislation in India that aims to protect
and improve the environment. It establishes the Central Pollution Control Board
(CPCB) and State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs) to implement the act's provisions.
The act prohibits the emission and discharge of pollutants beyond permissible
limits, requires consent from the SPCB before emissions, establishes hazardous
waste management rules, establishes an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
notification, empowers authorities to take remedial action against polluters,
and provides penalties for violations.
The Act has had a significant impact
on India's environment, leading to reduced air and water pollution, improved
waste management practices, and increased environmental awareness. However,
there are still challenges in implementing the act effectively, such as
industries not complying with emission and discharge standards and improper
handling of hazardous waste. Despite these challenges, the Act remains an
important tool for environmental protection in India, improving public health
and improving the quality of life for many people. Examples of how the act has
been implemented include setting emission and discharge standards, regulating
pollutants, taking remedial action against polluters, promoting cleaner
technologies, and supporting environmental awareness programs.
• THE WATER (PREVENTION
AND CONTROL) ACT, 1974
The Water (Prevention and Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974 is a comprehensive legislation in India that aims to
prevent and control water pollution. It establishes a framework for setting
water quality standards, regulating discharge into water bodies, and enforcing
environmental standards. Key features of the act include establishing Central and
State Boards, establishing water quality standards, regulating discharge by
industries, municipalities, and other sources, requiring consent for discharge,
empowering boards to take remedial action, prohibiting the disposal of
pollutants without prior consent from the SPCB, and providing penalties for
violations.
The act has played a significant role
in improving water quality in India, leading to reduced pollution in rivers and
lakes and improved drinking water quality for millions of people. However, there
are still challenges in enforcing the act and ensuring compliance by
industries. The act remains an important piece of legislation in India's
environmental protection arsenal and continues to play a vital role in
preventing and controlling water pollution. Examples of how the act has been
implemented to improve water quality include setting water quality standards
for different water bodies based on their use, regulating the discharge of
pollutants into water bodies by industries and other establishments, taking
remedial action to prevent and control water pollution, and imposing penalties
on polluters for violating the act.
• THE FOREST
(CONSERVATION) ACT 1980,
The Forest (Conservation) Act, of
1980 is a significant environmental legislation in India that aims to conserve
and protect forests. It prohibits unauthorized tree felling and regulates
forest use, making it one of the strictest forest conservation laws globally.
The act requires compensatory afforestation for non-forest land diversion,
empowers the Central Government to take remedial action, and provides penalties
for violations.
Despite challenges in implementing
the act, such as criticized Central Governments for not being proactive in
approving proposals for diversion, and instances of illegal logging and forest
encroachment, the act remains an important tool for forest conservation in
India. The Central Government has approved proposals for the diversion of
forest land, directed state governments to take action against illegal logging
operations, and promoted sustainable forest management practices.
The Forest
(Conservation) Act, of 1980 is a crucial tool for protecting forests and
ensuring Sustainable development in India. It has played a significant role in
conserving and protecting forests, reducing deforestation, and promoting
sustainable forest management practices.
• THE AIR (PREVENTION AND
CONTROL OF POLLUTION) ACT, 1981
The Air (Prevention and Control of
Pollution) Act, of 1981, is a significant environmental legislation in India
that aims to prevent and control air pollution by establishing emission
standards, regulating industrial emissions, and promoting cleaner fuel
technologies. The act establishes Central and State Pollution Control Boards
(CPCB) and State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs) to implement the provisions
of the act. The CPCB and SPCBs have the power to set emission standards for
various sources of air pollution, regulate industrial emissions by requiring
consent from the SPCB, and promote cleaner fuel technologies. The act empowers
boards to take remedial action, such as issuing directions to polluters, taking
air samples, and conducting inspections. Penalties for violations include
fines, imprisonment, and establishment closure.
The act has played a significant role
in reducing air pollution in India, leading to reduced emissions from
industries and vehicles, and improved air quality in many cities. However,
there are still challenges in enforcing the act and ensuring compliance by
industries. The act remains an important piece of legislation in India's
environmental protection arsenal and continues to play a vital role in air
quality management.
• THE WILDLIFE PROTECTION
ACT, 1972
The Wildlife Protection Act, of 1972,
is a significant environmental legislation in India that aims to protect
wildlife, including endangered and threatened species, by prohibiting poaching,
trade, and habitat destruction. The act lists over 400 species of animals and
300 species of plants as protected, prohibits hunting, regulates wildlife trade,
establishes protected areas like national parks, wildlife sanctuaries, and
conservation reserves, empowers authorities to take action, and provides
penalties for violations.
The act has had a positive impact on
wildlife conservation in India, reducing poaching, trade, and habitat
destruction. It has also established and managed protected areas, providing a
haven for wildlife. However, there are still challenges in implementing the act
effectively, such as instances of poaching and illegal trade in wildlife
products. Some protected areas are not adequately managed, leading to habitat
degradation and wildlife loss.
Despite these challenges, the
Wildlife Protection Act remains an important tool for protecting India's rich
biodiversity, saving many species from extinction and contributing to the
conservation of India's natural heritage.
POLICIES IMPLEMENTED RECENTLY:
In the last six months, the Indian
government has implemented several environmental law-related laws. Numerous
environmental issues, including waste management, water and air pollution, and
climate change, are the focus of these programs.
In India, the last six months have
seen the implementation of several significant environmental legislation
policies, such as:
• Phase II of the National
Clean Air Programme (NCAP): With its commencement in January 2023, the NCAP Phase II seeks to cut
air pollution by 20–30% by 2024 and 30–40% by 2026. Stricter emission
regulations for automobiles and industries, the advancement of clean fuel
technologies, and enhanced air quality monitoring and surveillance are just a
few of the initiatives included in NCAP Phase II.
• The National Policy for
the Management of Solid Waste (NPSWM): The goal of the NPSWM, which was introduced in February
2023, is to turn waste into resources by 2030. The construction of
waste-to-energy plants, encouragement of waste composting and recycling, and
waste segregation at the source are just a few of the initiatives included in
the NPSWM.
• The 2023 National Water
Policy (NWP): The
goals of the March 2023 launch of the NWP 2023 are to rehabilitate all
contaminated rivers by 2030 and to provide clean and inexpensive drinking water
to everyone by 2024. The NWP 2023 calls for a variety of actions, including
upgrading wastewater treatment facilities, collecting rainwater, and recharging
groundwater.
• The National Green
Hydrogen Mission (NGHM) was established in April 2023 to position India as a world leader in the
production and export of green hydrogen. A variety of initiatives are included
in the NGHM, including the establishment of green hydrogen production
facilities, the provision of financial incentives for green hydrogen
initiatives, and the creation of a green hydrogen market.
• The NMEEE, or National
Mission for Enhanced Energy Efficiency, The NMEEE was introduced in May 2023 to reduce energy use
by 30% by 2030. Among the many initiatives included in the NMEEE is the
promotion of energy efficiency in transportation, industry, and buildings.
A big step has been taken in the
direction of solving India's environmental problems with these policies. They
offer a road map for collaborating with the government and other interested
parties to make the environment healthier and cleaner for everybody.
The Indian government has created a
variety of state-specific environmental law policies in addition to these
national ones. For instance, the "Pollution-Free Delhi" initiative,
started by the Delhi government, intends to cut air pollution in the city by
50% by 2024. The goal of the Maharashtra government's "Swachh Maharashtra
Abhiyan" is to eliminate all waste from the state by 2025. Because they
enable governments to customize their environmental policies to the unique
requirements of their states, these state-specific laws are crucial.
The Indian government is dedicated to
enhancing public health and preserving the environment. This devotion is
demonstrated by the environmental laws that have been passed in the last six
months.
AMENDMENTS:
In addition to the policies mentioned
above, the Indian government has also made several amendments to environmental
laws in the past six months. These amendments aim to strengthen environmental
protection and enforcement in India. Some of the key amendments to
environmental laws in India in the recent six months include:
•
Amendment to the Environment Impact
Assessment (EIA) Notification: The EIA Notification has been amended to include new
sectors and activities that are required to undergo an EIA. This will help to
ensure that all major development projects are assessed for their environmental
impact before they are approved.
•
Water (Prevention and Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974 Amendment: Tighter guidelines for wastewater discharge and stiffer
fines for violators are two of the changes made to the Water Act. This will
contribute to improving India's water quality.
•
Amendment to the Air (Prevention and
Control of Pollution) Act, 1981: Tighter air emission regulations and harsher penalties for
polluters are the two main changes made to the Air Act. This will contribute to
India's decreased air pollution.
•
The Environment Act has been amended
to give the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and State Pollution Control
Boards (SPCBs) greater
authority to enforce environmental laws. The Environmental Protection Act of
1986 has been amended. This will contribute to India's increased environmental
compliance.
The strengthening of
environmental protection and enforcement in India is made possible by these
amendments. They will contribute to tackling the nation's environmental issues
and establishing a more hygienic and salubrious atmosphere for everybody.
The Indian government has
also suggested several new environmental laws, including ones on plastic
pollution and biodiversity conservation, in addition to the aforementioned
amendments. Although these laws are still in the proposal stage, they should
become law in the upcoming months.
LANDMARK JUDGMENTS:
·
M.C. MEHTA V. UNION OF INDIA
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India is a
landmark judgment in Indian environmental law that established the right to a
clean environment as a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India. The case arose from a petition filed by M.C. Mehta, a lawyer and
environmental activist, challenging the pollution of the Yamuna River by the Delhi
Jal Board (DJB). The court ruled that the right to a clean environment is a
fundamental right under India's Constitution, Article 21, and that the
government must prevent and regulate pollution to safeguard the environment.
The M.C. Mehta case has significantly
impacted India's efforts to protect the environment, leading to initiatives to
raise environmental standards, such as cleaning up contaminated rivers and
lakes and establishing tougher regulations for air and water pollution. Public
interest lawsuits (PILs) contesting environmental pollution have also been
sparked by the ruling, requiring the government and business sector to take
action to protect the environment.
Despite criticisms, the M.C. Mehta
ruling remains a seminal decision in Indian environmental law, as it has
contributed to the establishment of the right to a clean environment as a
fundamental right. The Supreme Court now has the authority to uphold
environmental laws, contributing to the establishment of the right to a clean
environment as a fundamental right. Environmental activists still rely heavily
on the ruling, which has greatly influenced India's environmental protection
efforts.
·
AKHIL BHARTIYA UDYOG VYAPARI MANDAL
V. UOI (2013)
Akhil Bharatiya Udyog Vyapari Mandal
v. Union of India (2013) is a landmark Supreme Court of India case that
established the government's duty to promote sustainable development and
balance economic development with environmental protection. The court upheld
the ban, stating that the government must promote sustainable development and
that the ban was necessary to protect the environment. The court also held that
the government must balance economic development with environmental protection,
but in this case, the need to protect the environment outweighed the economic
interests of small businesses.
The Akhil Bharatiya judgment is
significant in environmental law in India, as it established the principle that
the government has a duty to promote sustainable development and must balance
economic development with environmental protection. The judgment has had a
significant impact on environmental policy in India, leading to the adoption of
policies such as the National Green Hydrogen Mission and the National Mission
for Enhanced Energy Efficiency. The government has also been given the power to
take measures to protect the environment, even if those measures hurt economic
development.
Critics argue that the judgment has
given the government too much power, leading to interference in business
operations and restricting economic development. Others argue that the judgment
is too vague and does not provide clear guidance on how to balance economic
development with environmental protection. Despite these criticisms, the Akhil
Bharatiya judgment remains a landmark in environmental law in India.
CONCLUSION
Environmental law in India is a
complex and evolving field with several challenges to address. One of the main
challenges is enforcement, which requires the strengthening of the Central
Pollution Control Boards (CPCB) and State Pollution Control Boards (SPCBs) with
more resources and manpower. Increased public awareness about environmental
laws and regulations is also crucial. The conflict between economic development
and environmental protection is another issue that needs to be balanced. The
government and civil society organizations are working together to strengthen
environmental laws, improve enforcement, and raise public awareness.
To address these challenges, the
government should increase the budget and manpower of CPCBs, launch public
awareness campaigns about environmental laws, promote sustainable development
by incentivizing businesses to adopt clean technologies and enact stricter
penalties for environmental violations. By doing so, India can create a cleaner
and more sustainable future for its citizens.
REFERENCES:
•
Rachit
Garg, Environment legislation in India, IPLEADERS (2022), https://blog.ipleaders.in/environment-legislation-in-india/
•
Environmental
Laws in India, GEEKSFORGEEKS (2022), https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/new-environment-laws-in-india/
•
Sannaya,
Introduction to Environmental law in India, LEGALSERVICEINDIA.COM, https://legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-635-introduction-to-environmental-law-in-india.html (last visited Nov 10, 2023).
•
Environment
Laws, S.S RANA & CO (2019), https://ssrana.in/corporate-laws/environment-law-india/
•
• Madhavi Gaur, Environmental, Social
& Governance Law India 2023, ADDA247 (2023), https://currentaffairs.adda247.com/environmental-social-governance-law-india-2023
(last visited Nov 10, 2023).
•
Paul
Collins, Sustainable development: Definition, objectives and examples, SELECTRA
(2021), https://climate.selectra.com/en/environment/sustainable-development
•
ENVIRONMENTAL
LAWS IN INDIA: AN INTRODUCTION - Jus Corpus, WWW.JUSCORPUS.COM (2022), https://www.juscorpus.com/environmental-laws-in-india-an-introduction
(last visited Nov 10, 2023).
Article Information
FROM POLICY TO PRACTICE ASSESSING INDIAS ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND THEIR REAL WORLD IMPLICATIONS
Authors: SARTHAK BORA, NAKSHATRA DAPSE
- Journal IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Published 2023/11/17
- Issue 7
About Journal
International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis
- Abbreviation IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Access Open Access
- License CC 4.0
All research articles published in International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis are open access and available to read, download and share, subject to proper citation of the original work.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis.