Open Access Research Article
CONFRONTING HURDLES IN THE ENACTMENT OF GOODS AND SERVICES TAX (GST) IN INDIA
Published Paper
Article Details
CONFRONTING HURDLES IN THE ENACTMENT OF GOODS AND SERVICES
TAX (GST) IN INDIA
AUTHORED BY - ABHISHEK ISLAM
B.A.LL. B (H), 2019-2024
AMITY UNIVERSITY KOLKATA
ABSTRACT
The
introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India on July 1, 2017, was
a monumental step in simplifying the country's taxation system. This abstract
provides a concise overview of the challenges and benefits associated with the
implementation of GST, focusing on its impact across various sectors:
manufacturing, services, agriculture, and e-commerce.
The initial
phase of GST rollout faced teething problems, including technical glitches in
the GSTN, ambiguities in tax rates and procedures, and migration challenges for
existing taxpayers. Incompetence among some tax officials exacerbated these issues,
but concerted efforts have since improved the system's functionality.
Despite the
substantial advantages GST has brought to the Indian economy, challenges
endure. Notably, a heightened compliance burden, especially for small and
medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), threatens to impede their operations.
Furthermore, the regressive nature of taxation and increased taxes on certain
essential items have sparked concerns. Initial resistance from some quarters
and adjustments in the tax system have necessitated ongoing adaptation.
Various
sectors, from manufacturing to e-commerce, have encountered sector-specific
difficulties, encompassing classification, compliance costs, rate clarity,
input tax credits, and supply chain disruptions. Government measures, such as
the composition scheme and training programs, aim to mitigate these challenges.
In summary,
the implementation of GST has delivered numerous economic benefits for India.
However, addressing persistent challenges, particularly those impacting SMEs
and the regressive tax structure, is vital to ensuring a seamless and efficient
GST system, which is essential for the country's economic growth and
development.
Keywords: GST, Challenges, Demerits, SMEs.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
1.
What were the specific challenges faced by small and
medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in complying with GST regulations, and how did
these challenges impact their operations and competitiveness?
2.
How has the regressive nature of GST taxation
affected different income groups in India, and what strategies can be employed
to mitigate its impact on lower-income households?
3.
What sector-specific challenges emerged in the
manufacturing, services, agriculture, and e-commerce sectors during the
implementation of GST, and what steps can be taken to enhance sector-specific
compliance and efficiency?
4.
How have government initiatives, such as the
composition scheme and training programs, contributed to addressing the
challenges associated with GST implementation, and what further measures can be
taken to ensure a smooth and efficient GST system in India?
OBJECTIVES OF THE PAPER
This paper
aims to assess the challenges in the initial implementation of the Goods and
Services Tax (GST) in India, examine its sector-specific impact, analyse the
regressive nature of GST, evaluate the compliance burden on small and
medium-sized enterprises, and assess the effectiveness of government measures.
The ultimate objective is to provide recommendations for policy adjustments to
ensure an efficient and growth-enhancing GST system while addressing persisting
issues.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research conducted for this paper
is secondary. This research paper aims to explore the economical and legal
aspects of the challenges concerning the implementation of GST. A qualitative approach
was used for all the data collection. All the data was collected through
various online sources like websites, scholarly articles, research papers, etc.
1. INTRODUCTION
TO THE PAPER
The Goods
and Services Tax (GST) was introduced in India on July 1, 2017, as a historic
tax reform aimed at simplifying the country's indirect tax system, which had
been a long-standing challenge. The pre-existing tax structure had been
characterized by a plethora of indirect taxes, such as excise duty, service
tax, VAT, and others, which created confusion and complexity for businesses and
taxpayers. The introduction of the GST marked a significant shift from the old
tax regime to a new, unified tax system.
The
implementation of the GST involved various steps, including passing the GST
Bill in Parliament, establishing the GST Council, designing, and developing the
GST IT system, registering taxpayers, migrating existing taxpayers to the new
system, and educating businesses and consumers on the new tax system. The GST
was designed as a dual model, where both the central and state governments have
the authority to levy and collect GST, ensuring a unified and consistent tax
system across the country.
The
introduction of the GST has brought significant changes to the tax system,
including tax administration, tax collection, tax rates, and compliance
requirements. GST has replaced multiple taxes with a single tax, streamlining
the tax structure and reducing the tax burden on businesses. It has eliminated
the cascading effect of taxes, where taxes are charged on top of taxes, leading
to an increase in the cost of goods and services. Additionally, the GST has
enhanced tax compliance, making it easier for businesses to comply with tax
regulations, which has also led to increased revenue for the government.
Despite the
benefits, the implementation of GST faced some challenges which has been
further discussed in detail in the research paper.
Overall,
the introduction of GST has been a significant reform in India's tax system,
with the potential to enhance transparency, efficiency, and ease of doing
business in the country. The GST has brought in a uniform tax system, which has
reduced the burden on businesses and taxpayers, while also promoting economic
growth. The government continues to work towards improving the GST system,
addressing challenges, and ensuring the successful implementation of this
landmark tax reform.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a
value-added tax levied on the supply of goods and services in India, replacing
multiple indirect taxes like excise duty, service tax, and VAT. GST was
introduced on July 1, 2017, and it is administered by the Goods and Services
Tax Council. It is a comprehensive indirect tax system, with a
destination-based approach, and is applicable to every stage of the supply
chain, from manufacturers to end consumers.
GST has played a vital role in
streamlining India's tax system by eliminating the cascading effect of taxes,
simplifying the tax structure, and enhancing transparency and efficiency in tax
administration.
Since its implementation on July 1,
2017, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) has brought various benefits to the
Indian economy. These benefits include simplifying the tax structure by
replacing multiple indirect taxes with a single tax, reducing the tax burden on
businesses by eliminating the cascading effect of taxes and allowing input tax
credit, increasing tax compliance by enhancing transparency and accountability
in tax administration and reducing tax evasion, promoting economic growth by
facilitating inter-state trade, lowering transaction costs, and boosting
investment, streamlining the supply chain by eliminating multiple taxes and
reducing the time and cost of moving goods across state borders, making Indian
goods more competitive in the global market by making exports more
tax-efficient, and increasing government revenue by broadening the tax base and
curbing tax evasion. Overall, the implementation of GST has had a substantial
positive impact on the Indian economy, benefiting businesses, consumers, and
the government.
3. CHALLENGES CONCERNING IMPLEMENTATION
OF GST
1. Initial Teething Problems- During the initial implementation of
GST in India, there were several challenges and teething problems. These
included technical glitches in the GSTN, which caused delays in tax filing and
refunds. Additionally, there was a lack of clarity on GST rates and procedures,
which caused confusion among taxpayers and tax officials. The migration of
taxpayers from the old tax system to the new GST system was also a challenging
process, with many businesses struggling to update their records and comply
with the new requirements. Extensive training was required for tax officials
and businesses on the new GST system, which took time and resources. Finally,
some businesses were resistant to the new GST system, either because they did
not understand the new requirements or because they did not want to pay more
taxes. However, many of these issues have been resolved over time, and the GST
system is now running more smoothly.
2.
Incompetent Tax Officials: Incompetent tax officials have been a significant challenge
in the implementation of GST in India. Some tax officials were not adequately
trained on the new GST system, which led to errors and delays in tax processing
and refunds. In some cases, officials were not able to resolve taxpayer
grievances, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction among businesses. This
lack of competency and expertise among some tax officials has been a hurdle in
the smooth implementation of the GST system.
3. Complex Tax System- The implementation of the Goods and
Services Tax (GST) system in India has brought several benefits to the economy,
but it is also complex in various ways. For instance, the multiple tax rates
for different goods and services can be confusing for businesses and consumers,
who have to keep track of the different tax rates. Additionally, businesses are
required to file multiple tax returns, including monthly, annual, and other
periodic returns, which can be time-consuming and challenging, especially for
small businesses. Furthermore, the GST system has a complex registration
process that requires businesses to obtain a unique GST identification number
(GSTIN) and comply with various registration requirements, which can be
difficult for small businesses and startups with limited resources and
expertise. Despite the benefits of the GST system, it remains a complex system
that requires careful navigation by businesses and consumers alike.
4.
Increased Complaint Costs- The implementation of GST has led to an increase in
compliance costs for businesses in India. The GST system requires businesses to
file multiple tax returns, including monthly, annual, and other periodic
returns. This process can be time-consuming and challenging, especially for
small businesses, which can result in errors and non-compliance. Additionally,
the GST system has a complex registration process that requires businesses to
obtain a unique GST identification number (GSTIN) and comply with various
registration requirements. This can be difficult for small businesses and
startups that may not have the necessary resources or expertise to navigate the
registration process. Consequently, businesses have had to invest more time and
resources into complying with the GST system, which has increased their
compliance costs.
5.
Compliance Burden on SMEs- The implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system
has increased the compliance burden on businesses, especially small and
medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). These SMEs may not have sufficient resources
to comply with the complex GST regulations, which can result in higher costs
and reduced competitiveness.
SMEs may face challenges
in understanding the various GST rules, regulations, and filing requirements.
Compliance with GST regulations can be time-consuming and resource-intensive,
which can be particularly challenging for SMEs. Furthermore, the compliance
burden of GST on SMEs can be significant, especially during the initial stages
of implementation, as they may need to invest in new technology and staff
training to comply with the new regulations.
In addition, SMEs may
have difficulties dealing with GST authorities, such as responding to GST
audits, assessments, and inquiries. Any errors or omissions in GST filings can
lead to penalties and interest charges, which could further increase the
compliance burden and financial strain on SMEs.
Overall, the compliance
burden of GST on SMEs can be a significant challenge that may impact their
growth and competitiveness. Governments can provide additional support and
guidance to SMEs to help them comply with the GST regulations and reduce the
compliance burden. This could include simplifying the GST rules and
regulations, providing training and assistance programs, and streamlining the
GST filing and refund processes.
6. Higher Taxes for Some Items- The GST system in India taxes
different goods and services at different rates, ranging from 0% to 28%. As a
result, some essential items that were previously taxed at a lower rate are now
taxed at a higher rate under GST. For instance, items like sanitary napkins are
taxed at a higher rate of 12%, while some luxury items like cars are taxed at a
lower rate of 28%. Some critics argue that this results in higher taxes for
essential items and lower taxes for luxury items, which may not be fair.
Nevertheless, the GST system was introduced to simplify the tax structure and
reduce the overall tax burden on businesses, which it has achieved to some
extent.
7. Resistance from Some Quarters- The implementation of GST in India
has received resistance from some quarters. Some businesses were initially
resistant to the new GST system, either because they did not understand the new
requirements or because they did not want to pay more taxes. Additionally, some
states were initially hesitant to adopt the GST system, as they were concerned
about losing their fiscal autonomy. However, over time, most of these concerns
have been addressed, and the GST system has been adopted by all states in
India. Nonetheless, some businesses and taxpayers may still have grievances
with the GST system, particularly with regards to compliance costs and the
complexity of the tax structure.
8.
Regressive Nature of Taxation- The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is considered a regressive
tax because it imposes the same tax rate on all goods and services, regardless
of the income level of the consumer. This means that lower-income households,
who tend to spend a larger proportion of their income on goods and services,
will pay a higher proportion of their income in GST than higher-income
households.
For example, a low-income
household that spends 90% of their income on goods and services subject to GST
would pay a higher percentage of their income in GST than a higher-income
household that only spends 50% of their income on taxable goods and services.
Essential items such as
food, healthcare, and education, which are consumed more by low-income
households, are typically subject to the same GST rate as non-essential items.
This means that low-income households are likely to spend a larger proportion
of their income on GST than higher-income households.
Although the GST system
aims to reduce the overall tax burden on consumers and businesses, the
regressive nature of the tax could potentially negatively impact low-income
households. To address this issue, some countries have introduced exemptions
and reduced tax rates for certain essential goods and services consumed by
low-income households.
4. CHALLENGES IN RELATION TO COMPLIANCE WITH
GST IN VARIOUS SECTORS
4.1.
Manufacturing Sector
The implementation of the
Goods and Services Tax (GST) system has presented a range of challenges to the
manufacturing sector. Some of the main challenges that manufacturers have
encountered are:
a)
Increased compliance costs: Under GST, manufacturers are required to comply with new
regulations, file GST returns, and maintain GST records. These compliance
activities can be time-consuming and resource-intensive, leading to increased
costs for manufacturers.
b)
Impact of new tax rate structure on margins: The new GST tax rate structure has
had an impact on manufacturers' margins. Some manufacturers have had to
increase prices to maintain their margins, while others have had to absorb the
increased costs, resulting in lower profitability.
c)
Classification of goods: Classifying goods according to the Harmonized System of
Nomenclature (HSN) code can be a complex and time-consuming task for
manufacturers. Proper classification is essential for determining the correct
GST rate to be applied.
d)
Determination of place of supply: The GST system requires the determination of the place of
supply for goods and services. This can be a challenge for manufacturers,
especially those involved in inter-state transactions. Properly determining the
place of supply is crucial for charging the correct GST rate.
e)
Valuation of goods and services: The GST system requires the valuation of goods and services
for the purpose of charging GST. This can be a challenge for manufacturers
providing discounts, free samples, or involved in job work.
In conclusion, the
implementation of GST has presented several challenges for the manufacturing
sector, including increased compliance costs, impact of new tax rate structure
on margins, classification of goods, determination of place of supply, and
valuation of goods and services. The government needs to provide support and
guidance to manufacturers to ensure a smooth transition to the GST system and
reduce the burden of compliance.
4.2.
Service Sector
The implementation of the
Goods and Services Tax (GST) system has brought various challenges to the
services sector. Here are some of the challenges faced by the services sector:
a)
Determination of place of supply: The GST system requires the determination of the place of
supply for services, which can be complex for service providers who operate
across multiple states. Proper determination is essential for charging the
correct GST rate, and failure to do so can result in compliance issues and
penalties.
b)
Invoicing requirements: GST requires service providers to issue GST-compliant
invoices. However, some service providers may lack the necessary infrastructure
to comply with these requirements, which can lead to compliance issues and
penalties.
c)
Input tax credit restrictions: While GST allows input tax credit (ITC) for services, there
are some restrictions that apply. Service providers may face challenges in
claiming ITC for services used in the course of their business, which can lead
to increased costs.
d)
Changes in tax rates: The GST Council may make changes to the GST rates, which can be a
challenge for service providers to keep up with. Frequent changes in rates can
disrupt cash flow and increase compliance costs.
e)
Lack of clarity on certain services: There may be a lack of clarity on the GST treatment
of certain services, which can cause confusion and compliance issues for
service providers. For example, services provided to international clients may
be subject to different rules, and the treatment of composite supplies may not be
clear.
In summary, the
implementation of GST has presented several challenges for the services sector.
These include determination of place of supply, invoicing requirements, input
tax credit restrictions, changes in tax rates, and lack of clarity on certain
services. The government needs to address these challenges and provide support
and guidance to service providers to ensure a smooth transition to the GST
system.
4.3.
Agricultural Sector
The Goods and Services
Tax (GST) system has presented several challenges to the agricultural sector.
Here are some of the issues faced by the sector:
a)
Lack of clarity on GST rates: There is a lack of clarity on the GST rates applicable to
agricultural products. Different rates apply to different types of agricultural
products, and there may be confusion among farmers and traders about the
applicable rates.
b)
Compliance burden on small farmers: The GST system requires farmers with an annual
turnover of over Rs. 20 lakhs to register for GST and comply with its
provisions. However, many small farmers may not have the necessary resources to
comply with the requirements, leading to increased compliance costs.
c)
Input tax credit restrictions: While GST allows input tax credit (ITC) for certain goods
used in agriculture, such as fertilizers and machinery, there are some
restrictions that apply. Farmers may face challenges in claiming ITC for these
goods, leading to increased costs.
d)
Supply chain disruptions: The implementation of GST has led to supply chain disruptions
for agricultural products. There have been reports of delays and additional
costs in transporting goods, which can affect the prices of agricultural
products.
e)
Lack of infrastructure: The implementation of GST requires farmers and traders to
have access to digital infrastructure to comply with the requirements. However,
there may be a lack of such infrastructure in rural areas, making it difficult
for farmers to comply with the requirements.
In summary, the GST
system has presented several challenges for the agricultural sector, including
a lack of clarity on GST rates, compliance burden on small farmers, input tax
credit restrictions, supply chain disruptions, and lack of infrastructure. The
government needs to address these challenges and provide support and guidance
to farmers and traders in the agricultural sector to ensure a smooth transition
to the GST system.
4.4.
E-Commerce Sector
The e-commerce sector has
faced several challenges with the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax
(GST) system. These challenges include:
a)
Classification of goods and services: The classification of goods and services under the
GST system is complex, making it difficult for e-commerce companies to determine
the correct tax rate for each product. This can lead to discrepancies in tax
collection and compliance.
b)
Compliance burden: E-commerce companies are required to comply with several GST provisions,
including registration, filing returns, and payment of taxes. This can be a
significant burden, especially for small and medium-sized e-commerce companies.
c)
Lack of clarity on GST rates: There is a lack of clarity on the GST rates applicable to
e-commerce transactions, particularly for cross-border transactions. This can
cause confusion and difficulties in determining the correct tax rate for
transactions.
d)
Tax Collection at Source (TCS): E-commerce companies are required to collect TCS from
sellers on their platform, which can be challenging to implement, particularly
for small sellers who may not have the necessary knowledge or resources.
e)
Integration with IT systems: E-commerce companies need to integrate their IT systems with
the GSTN (GST Network) to comply with the GST requirements. This can be a
significant challenge, particularly for small and medium-sized companies that
may not have the necessary IT infrastructure.
In conclusion, the
implementation of GST has presented several challenges to the e-commerce
sector, including classification of goods and services, compliance burden, lack
of clarity on GST rates, TCS implementation, and integration with IT systems.
It is important for the government to provide guidance and support to the
e-commerce sector to address these challenges and ensure a smooth transition to
the GST system.
5. KEY TAKEAWAYS
The implementation of the Goods and
Services Tax (GST) in India was a significant reform aimed at simplifying the
taxation system and promoting economic growth. The GST replaced several
indirect taxes, such as excise duty, service tax, and value-added tax (VAT),
creating a unified tax system for the country. The implementation of the GST
required significant changes to the existing tax structure and IT
infrastructure.
Although the GST has brought several
benefits to the Indian economy, it has also faced several challenges in various
sectors. One of the significant challenges is the compliance burden,
particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). SMEs may not have
the necessary resources or knowledge to comply with the GST provisions, leading
to a significant compliance burden for them. Additionally, the regressive
nature of the tax can impact the purchasing power of the lower-income groups.
The manufacturing sector has faced
several challenges with the implementation of the GST, including the
classification of goods and services, compliance burden, and difficulties in
implementing IT systems. The services sector has also faced challenges with the
GST, such as the classification of services and the lack of clarity on GST
rates. The agricultural sector, a major contributor to the Indian economy, has
faced challenges such as the lack of clarity on GST rates for agricultural
products and the difficulties in implementing GST compliance for farmers.
The e-commerce sector, a rapidly
growing sector in India, has also faced several challenges with the
implementation of the GST. The classification of goods and services, compliance
burden, lack of clarity on GST rates, and the implementation of TCS are some of
the significant challenges faced by the sector.
Despite the challenges, the GST has
brought several benefits to the Indian economy. The removal of cascading taxes
has reduced the tax burden on businesses, leading to lower costs for consumers.
The simplified tax compliance process has made it easier for businesses to
comply with the tax provisions, reducing the administrative burden on them. The
GST has also led to increased revenue for the government, which can be used for
developmental purposes.
To address the challenges faced by
the GST, the government has introduced new provisions such as the composition
scheme, the e-way bill, and the reverse charge mechanism, addressing some of
the concerns of SMEs. The government has also provided training and education
programs to businesses to help them comply with the GST provisions.
Additionally, the government has been working to address the regressive nature
of the GST through measures such as reducing the tax rate on essential goods
and services.
In conclusion, the implementation of
the GST has been a significant reform for India's taxation system. Although the
GST has faced several challenges, the benefits it brings to the Indian economy
cannot be ignored. The government's efforts to address the challenges faced by
the GST are commendable, and it is crucial to continue working towards making
the GST system more effective and efficient. The successful implementation of
the GST is essential for India's economic growth and development.
REFERENCES
·
"GST in India: A Brief History and Analysis"
by Anjali Sharma (2020) -
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3647471.
·
"Implementation of GST in India: A Critical
Analysis" by Chandan Kr. Tiwary and Sarvesh Kumar (2021). -
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352957287_Implementation_of_GST_in_India_A_Critical_Analysis.
·
"GST Council Meet: Centre, States Lock Horns Over
Compensation" by NDTV Profit (2020) - https://www.ndtv.com/business/gst-council-meet-centre-states-lock-horns-over-compensation-2303546.
·
"GST and the Manufacturing Sector in India"
by Sathya Menon (2018) -
https://www.academia.edu/37705239/GST_and_the_Manufacturing_Sector_in_India.
·
"GST Impact on Service Sector in India" by
Rajni Rani and Dr. Shilpa Jain (2021) - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350797173_GST_Impact_on_Service_Sector_in_India_An_Analysis.
·
"GST Impact on Agriculture Sector" by Suresh
Kumar (2018) -
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326827800_GST_Impact_on_Agriculture_Sector.
·
"GST Impact on E-commerce Industry" by
Indian Institute of Commerce and Trade (2018) -
https://iict.in/gst-impact-on-e-commerce-industry/.
Article Information
CONFRONTING HURDLES IN THE ENACTMENT OF GOODS AND SERVICES TAX (GST) IN INDIA
Authors: ABHISHEK ISLAM
- Journal IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Published 2023/11/04
- Issue 7
About Journal
International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis
- Abbreviation IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Access Open Access
- License CC 4.0
All research articles published in International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis are open access and available to read, download and share, subject to proper citation of the original work.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis.