Open Access Research Article
THE IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW’S ON DOMESTIC LEGAL SYSTEM
Published Paper
Article Details
THE IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW’S
ON DOMESTIC LEGAL SYSTEM
AUTHORED BY
- GOPAL PALEKAR
SL21ULBBO31
SCHOOL OF
LAW
MAHINDRA
UNIVERSITY
May -2023
ABSTRACT
This article delves into the topic of
international law in the context of the Indian domestic legal system. It
highlights India's significant contributions to the field of international law,
yet notes that the country is hesitant to draft covenants that restrict their
freedoms. The article examines how international law is implemented in India
and the conditions assessed by international law. It also criticizes the
fundamental contradiction in approaches towards convention-making power at the
domestic level. Furthermore, the role of the legal bar in the implementation of
international law in India is explored. Ultimately, the article provides
suggestions for a new legal framework to enhance the performance of
international law in India. It endeavors to emphasize the importance of
studying state practice as a way to validate actuality and develop
international morals and ethics while also highlighting how India's adherence
to international law manifests in its legal system. Finally, the article notes
that there are no specific conditions assessed by international law to fulfill
scores to incorporate covenants or customs into domestic legal systems. It
concludes by reiterating that implementing international law requires
navigating complex legal systems and ensuring effective coordination between domestic
legal systems and international laws.
I.
INTRODUCTION
This article explores the role of
transnational law and its interaction with domestic legal orders in India. It
delves into the process of how transnational law is incorporated into the Indian
legal system and argues that India has made significant contributions to the
development of transnational law[1]. transnational law in fields such as human rights,
environmental law, arbitration, and trade law. However, India still shows
reluctance in drafting covenants that limit its sovereignty and explicitly
grant domestic courts judicial enforcement power. Through an analysis of the
contradictions in convention-making power and approaches at the domestic level,
this paper examines the role of the bar in perpetuating transnational law in
India. It addresses the conditions assessed by transnational law and examines
the relationship between transnational law and domestic law, proposing a new
legal framework for better implementation of transnational law.Throughout this
article, the terms "transnational law" and "domestic law"
are frequently used. Therefore, it is important to provide a clear definition
of these terms. This definition will assist readers in understanding the legal
issues surrounding the implementation of transnational law within Indian
domestic law. According to the United Nations, transnational law refers to the
legal responsibilities that states carry in their interactions with each other
and their treatment of individuals within their respective boundaries. The
scope of transnational law encompasses various issues of global concern, such
as human rights, demilitarization, transnational crime, refugees, migration,
issues of nationality, treatment of prisoners, use of force, conduct of war,
and more. It also covers the regulation of global resources such as land and
sustainable development, international waters, outer space, global shipping,
and world trade.Transnational law is divided into two different categories:
private and public. Private transnational law deals with issues between private
entities, such as individuals or corporations, that have a significant
relationship with more than one country. For example, a lawsuit arising from a
gas leak from a factory owned by Union Carbide in India would fall under
private transnational law. Private transnational law addresses conflicts
between public laws and determines which country's laws are applicable to
specific situations. On the other hand, public transnational law includes the
laws, rules, and principles that govern the conduct of nation-states and
international organizations among themselves, as well as the relationships
between countries and international organizations with individuals, both
natural and juridical. Public transnational law is sometimes referred to as the
"law of nations" or simply "international law." It covers
various areas of law, such as maritime law, commercial law, political law,
environmental law, human rights law, and humanitarian law.This article
primarily focuses on public transnational law. It is also important to note
that public transnational law should not be confused with private transnational
law. Additionally, there are five sources of transnational law: covenants,
custom, general principles of law, judicial opinions, and legal education.In
conclusion, understanding the definitions and differences between transnational
and domestic law and their various categories is crucial in comprehending the
legal complexities of transnational issues within domestic law.This article
highlights the significance of studying state practice as a means of supporting
transnational morals and norms, while also identifying the peculiarities of its
application in the Indian context due to its adherence to transnational law. The
paper examines the incorporation of transnational law in the Indian domestic
system, which may be accomplished through ratifying transnational covenants or
following customs. However, there are no specific conditions mandated by
transnational law for incorporating covenants or customs into domestic legal
systems, and the process of incorporation is generally not governed by
transnational law. Each state follows its own process of incorporation, with
indigenous values and customs also playing a role. Domestic courts may choose
to ignore transnational law until incorporated into domestic law, and the
incorporation of transnational law ultimately depends on the policy objectives
and values of a state's domestic legal system. Nonetheless, a state cannot
disregard its transnational obligations before international courts. State
sovereignty is a crucial issue in the implementation of transnational law, with
scholars stating that the restatement of transnational commands into domestic
legal norms is part of a state's sovereignty, and they may be unwilling to
surrender this to transnational control. States have a wide range of freedom in
the choice of means and styles to fulfill their transnational law obligations,
but sometimes the involvement of state bodies entrusted with promoting
legislation is necessary.
II.
DEFINITIONS
The term" transnational
law" and" domestic law" is constantly and materially employed
throughout this Composition. As similar, there's a need to stipulate to a
working description because of the term's significance then. This primary description should help
compendiums address the legal issues underpinning the perpetration of
transnational law in Indian domestic law.
III.
THEORIES ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
INTERNATIONAL LAW AND DOMESTIC LAW
The theory of monism suggests that
transnational law and external law share a common basis and are therefore part
of the same system of law. This view considers both as part of a universal set
of legal rules that applies to all individuals, regardless of their nationality.
In a monist system, transnational law is automatically incorporated into
domestic law without the need for separate measures to be taken. This means
that international law, once ratified, becomes part of the domestic legal
system. The proposition maintains that domestic law is subordinate to
transnational law, which allows the ICC Statute to be applied and arbitrated in
public courts. However, there are some exceptions to the monist approach. In
some cases, the direct incorporation of transnational law into domestic law
takes place at the time of ratification. Alternatively, in other countries,
direct incorporation only occurs for certain types of executing covenants.
Despite these exceptions, the general principle of monism remains a fundamental
aspect of international law.
Monism Theory suggests that
transnational and external law are just one in nature, and are part of a single
universal body of legal rules that governs us all, either inclusively or
separately. So, according to Monism Theory, it's like everyone's playing the
same game in different leagues--no need to incorporate transnational law into
domestic law! On the other hand, Dualism Theory looks at these two legal
systems as two different entities entirely. Before transnational law can become
domestic law, Dualists believe it needs to be translated into language state
legislation can understand. It's like we're all playing different games with
our own special rules! So, if you want the ICC Statute to apply in the public
court, you'd better learn how to speak politico-legalese first under Dualism
Theory.
Covenants are an essential source of
transnational law and India is a party to more than one hundred and sixty such
agreements that cover various aspects of law such as air, space, and maritime
law.93 The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties defines a
"convention" as an international agreement concluded between States
in written form and governed by international law, regardless of its
designation.94 However, according to the Indian Supreme Court's interpretation
in State ofW.B.v. KesoramIndustriesLtd., 2004, an agreement entered into by
India cannot become a part of the domestic law unless the Parliament passes a
relevant Act under Article 253.95 The principle of pacta sunt servanda
enshrined in Article 26 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties states
that every convention in force is binding on the parties to it and must be
performed by them in good faith.96 In practice there are no exceptions to this
fundamental rule which states that countries are free to determine their
international obligations under international law.97
The doctrine contained in Articles 26
and 27 of the Vienna Convention, 1980 embeds the principle that every
convention must be respected in good faith by all parties involved.98
Consequently, a party cannot employ its domestic laws as an excuse for failing
to abide by their treaty commitments.99 Numerous judicial decisions have
confirmed that provisions derived from international covenants may be applied
domestically to extend their protections.100 Indian courts often cite
conventions and other elements of international law when interpreting domestic
legislation.101 As noted by Vishakav v State of Rajasthan (1997), with respect
to gender issues arising concerning foreign nationals, domestic courts should
turn to international conventions and principles when interpreting national
laws if there is no inconsistency between them and there is a gap in national
legislation.102 In this case, international law was used as a guide for
defining national legislation; additionally it was determined that
international conventions compatible with basic rights should be interpreted
“to broaden their scope”103
In 2014 NationalLegal Services
Authorityv Union of India recognized transgender as a third gender category
-104 yet declared that when Indian legislature clashes with international
regulations then Indian courts will give precedence to national over
international laws; however where there is no inconsistency, external courts
should recognize rules from international sources105 Similarly, Neelabati
Beherav Stateof Orissa (1993) relied upon Article 9(5) of Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights (1966) for compensating victims suffering from custodial
death106 While Chairman Railway Boardv Chandrima Das (2000) invoked UDHR
principles while expanding scope Article 21 Constitution -107 thus confirming
principle that national court can accept rules derived from external sources108
Finally, 2017 report United Nations
country team lauded whole-of-Government approach implementation Sustainable
Development Goals109 including environmental impact assessments Forest
Conservation Act110 One issue highlighted Third Universal Periodic Review 2017
suggests Indian government could ratify several treaties111 especially
concerning use lethal force security personnel112 As per Section 46 Code
Criminal Procedure Law enforcement participants authorized all means necessary
execute arrest113 Therefore United Nations Special Rappoteur advocated review
legislative framework incorporate principles moral rights conforming external
regulations114 Subsequently Supreme Court India specified even when two types
regulations conflict court bound refer domestic act115 Nonetheless India unable
draft covenants constraining leeway expressly authorizing judicial
enforcement116 Therefore it essential India reconcile diverging legislations117
whenever feasible embrace transnational principles118
IV.
CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS FOR
INTERNATIONAL LAW
Before exploring the issue of operation of
transnational law in the Indian
environment, a brief overview of the indigenous provision would be useful.
The effectiveness of transnational law
depends upon the will of the countries
and the nature of the indigenous
distribution of power between the different
situations of governmental methodology of perpetration of transnational
covenants by state parties in their external and internal autonomous
spheres. 62 Under the Constitution of India, there's no specific and definite
reference to the status of transnational
law in the Indian domestic legal system; it also doesn't explicitly bear or
authorize the bar to draw on
transnational law.63 The Indian Constitution ensures that in the entire
Indian administration, high regard shall be given to transnational law and also to transnational morality.64 The Indian Constitution, espoused on 26th November 1950, was
greatly told by the values imbibed in The Universal
Declaration of Human Rights( UDHR). espoused by the United Nations General
Assembly, the UDHR's primary motive is to
cover and save the introductory abecedarian rights which all mortal beings are entitled to. still, there
are several vittles in the Constitution
on convention- making powers. According to
the Indian Constitution, ratified
covenants don't automatically have the force of law in domestic courts,
but the Constitution also provides that the Indian Government adheres to its convention
scores. 6 Composition 51( c) of
the Indian Constitution says, foster respect for transnational law and convention
scores in the dealings of organized peoples with one another. The
acceptance of emendations moved byDr.
Ambedkar,H.V. Kamath, Ananthasayanam Ayyangar andP. Subbarayan, draft
Composition 40 was espoused by the
Constituent Assembly in its present form as Composition51 .66 All the speakers
emphasized the commitment of India to promoting International Peace and
Security and adherence to principles of International Law and Treaty scores during the debate.67 Significantly, the clause' c' of Composition
51 mentions explicitly' transnational
law' and' convention scores' independently. According toProf.C.H.
Alexandrowicz the expression'
transnational law' then represents customary transnational law and' convention
scores' and stands for scores
arising out of transnational covenants.68 This interpretation seems
logical in the environment of the textbook of the draft of Article 40,
especially when one considers the
stations of courts in India on questions of transnational law.69 Also, the Composition
51( c) treats both transnational
customary law and convention scores on the same footings. 70 The Indian
Constitution is silent on the status of
transnational law in its domestic legal system. It doesn't obligate or
authorize the bar to draw on
transnational law in its decision
timber.
V.
TREATIES
Covenants are primary sources and an important
part of transnational law. India is a
party to further than one hundred
sixty covenants and conventions dealing
with different fields of law similar as
air law, space law and maritime law.93 The Vienna Convention on the Law of
Treaties defines a convention" as
an transnational agreement concluded
between States in written form and governed by
transnational law, whether embodied in a single instrument or in two
or further affiliated instruments and
whatever its particular designation." 94 still, under the Indian Supreme Court's
interpretation in State ofW.B.v. KesoramIndustriesLtd., 2004, a convention entered into by India can not come
a law of the land and it can not be
enforced unless Parliament passes a law under Composition253.95 As
bandied over, the principle ofpacta
sunt servandaenshrined in Composition 26 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of
covenants states that" Every
convention in force is binding upon the parties to it and must be
performed by them in good faith." 96 still, covenants should be performed in good faith[2]. Still,
there are no exceptions to the principle of the
introductory rule that states are free to determine their transnational
scores under transnational law.
97 It's said that the Vienna convention is the convention of conventions. The
doctrine of pacta sunt servanda contained in composition 26 and composition 27
of the- Vienna convention, 1980 lays down that every convention in force is binding upon the
parties to it and must be performed in good faith.98 A party may not bring the
vittles of its internal law as a
defense for its failure to perform a
convention.99 colorful judicial
pronouncements have made it clear that the provision of transnational
covenants might be read into being Indian law to expand their
protections.100 The Indian courts regularly cite covenants and other vittles of
transnational law for indigenous
interpretation. 101 For illustration, in 1997 Vishakav. State of
Rajasthan, case on sexual importunity of
women at the plant countries,"
regard must be had to transnational
conventions and morals for unriddling domestic law when there's no
inconsistency between them and there's a void in the domestic law." 10 2
The court used transnational law to find
the meaning of domestic law, and also held that
transnational conventions not inconsistent with abecedarian rights must
be read" to enlarge the meaning and content thereof" 10 3 In 2014, NationalLegal Services Authorityv.
Union of India case honored ambisexual
as a third order of gender. 104 The
court said" If congress has made any legislation which is in conflict
with transnational law, also Indian courts are bound to give effect
to the Indian law, rather than
transnational law. still, in the absence of contrary legislation,
external courts in India would admire the rules of transnational law." 105 In 1993, Neelabati Beherav. State of Orissa,
the court reckoned upon Composition 9(
5) of the Covenant on Civil and Political Rights( 1966) while granting
compensation to the victim for the matter of custodial death. 106 Also, in 2000
in the case of ChairmanRailway Boardv. ChandrimaDas, the court employed the principles of the UDHR while
widening Composition 21 of the Constitution's
compass by furnishing security to
rape victims of foreign citizens. 107
The Indian courts have incorporated
transnational law to fulfill its obligation by interpreting transnational law into domestic legislation.108
Hence, the Indian bar has played a
visionary part in enforcing India's transnational
scores under transnational covenants, especially mortal rights, development, and environmental
law. 109 For illustration, in 2017
periodic report of India's UN country
platoon ate the" whole- of-
Government" approach for the
perpetration of Sustainable Development Goals.110 The platoon appreciated India's commitment to
addressing climate change; the country
platoon appertained to
enterprises at the relaxation of
morals for environmental impact assessments and operation procedures under the Forest
Conservation Act.111 still, in the third
universal periodic review 2017, the United Nations country platoon indicated that India didn't apply recommendations contained in the former reviews regarding the ratification of
several transnational instruments.1 1 2
For illustration[3],
the Special Rapporteur took note of reports regarding deaths performing from
the inordinate use of force by security
officers with little adherence to the
principles of proportionality and necessity as defined under transnational
mortal rights law norms.1 1 3
Section 46 of the Criminal Procedure Code authorized law enforcement officers to use" all means
necessary" to perform an arrest
forcefully defied.1 1 4 farther,
it was recommended that India review the law and legislation in all countries regarding the use of force,
including the exceptional use of
murderous force, by all security officers to insure compliance with transnational
mortal rights law principles. 115 In the below- bandied cases, the Supreme Court of India
explained that if transnational law
conflicts with the domestic law also the
courts will be bound to give effect to domestic law. still, India remains reticent to draft covenants that circumscribe this free rein and that seek
expressly to accord domestic courts ajudicial enforcement part[4].
The covenants which are harmonious with domestic law are per se part
of domestic law and don't need legislative Act for their perpetration.1 16 India shouldn't shirk
transnational law because it conflicts with domestic law. India should
look for ways to apply transnational laws when it conflicts with
domestic laws.
VI.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the ever-evolving relationship between state
practice and transnational law is complex and vague. With the introduction of
the Indian Constitution, there is an established frame for transnational
conventions to be implemented into the domestic legal system. The government of
India holds exclusive power in entering and confirming any international
covenants, while Indian courts may refer to transnational law when no
contradiction exists between them and domestic law is lacking. Although this
composition has offered four suggestions for a better implementation of
transnational law in India's domestic system, further improvements can still be
made.
[1] ?Virendra
Kumar Ahuja. (2016). Public International
Law.
[2] uphold International Law (no date) United Nations. Available at:
https://www.un.org/en/our-work/uphold-international-law (Accessed: 03 May
2023).
[3] What is international law? (2016) Findlaw. Available at:
https://www.findlaw.com/hirealawyer/choosing-the-right-lawyer/international-law.html
[4] Library guides: New researchers’ library guide: home
(no date) Home - New Researchers’ Library Guide -
Library Guides at University of Melbourne. Available at:
https://unimelb.libguides.com/research
Article Information
THE IMPACT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW’S ON DOMESTIC LEGAL SYSTEM
Authors: GOPAL PALEKAR
- Journal IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Published 2023/05/31
- Volume 2
- Issue 7
About Journal
International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis
- Abbreviation IJLRA
- ISSN 2582-6433
- Access Open Access
- License CC 4.0
All research articles published in International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis are open access and available to read, download and share, subject to proper citation of the original work.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of International Journal for Legal Research and Analysis.